Bus shelters will remain in place but the benches will be removed.
Mark Alan Lovewell

Tisbury to Remove Bus Shelter Benches at SSA Terminal

The Tisbury select board this week agreed to remove the benches from two bus stop shelters across from the Steamship Authority terminal in Vineyard Haven.

The Tisbury select board this week agreed to remove the benches from two bus stop shelters across from the Steamship Authority terminal in Vineyard Haven.

Meant for transit riders, the shelters have become a hang-out for loiterers and a turn-off for bus and ferry passengers, police Sgt. Max Sherman said.

“It’s been a site of alcohol use, drug use, urination and people sleeping there as well,” Mr. Sherman told the select board at a public meeting Monday afternoon. “It’s become, as the main port, kind of an eyesore as you come in.”

Martha’s Vineyard Transit Authority (VTA) administrator Angela Gompert detailed the problems in a letter to Mr. Sherman earlier this year, requesting the benches’ removal.

“That area has increasingly become a site of concerning activity, including the misuse of the benches by individuals engaged in substance abuse, fighting, loudly cursing and other inappropriate behavior,” Ms. Gompert wrote.

With the Harbor Homes winter shelter program scheduled to close later this month, Mr. Sherman said the bus shelters could attract even more people if the benches are still in place.

“You know we’re all for trying to support them [homeless people] as much as we can, and we don’t want to turn their lifestyle into a criminal matter, but I do believe that if we remove the benches — just inside the stalls, not outside — that we will see a decrease in their sleeping there or hanging out there, and [more] people that are actually taking the bus,” he said.

Tisbury police chief Christopher Habekost also spoke Monday, saying he believed the bench removal would not pose an undue hardship.

“It’s just kind of like a discouragement of sort of camping out in those two enclosures. There’s still benches in other areas... if they’d like to sit for a reasonable period of time. And there’s other places that they can go as well, especially in the nicer weather,” Mr. Habekost said.

The police department also is working with the Steamship Authority and Harbor Homes regarding individuals who linger in the ferry terminal building, he said.

“We’ve discussed many different things that we can do, both enforcement wise, but also just assisting people, and we’ve come up with some good solutions,” Mr. Habekost said.

The police department now checks in with terminal management every evening, he said.

“Those reports have been coming back to me, and I think that it’s successful,” Mr. Habekost said.

The select board voted unanimously in favor of removing the covered benches, rendering the two bus shelters standing-room-only for the future.

Among other business Monday, the select board voted to alter the wording of the leaf blower ban article for the annual town meeting warrant, removing all language regarding electric-powered blowers and Sunday/holiday limitations.

Board member Roy Cutrer was the main proponent of the last-minute changes, which came one day before the board officially signed the town meeting warrant.

Mr. Cutrer spoke heatedly against the inclusion of electric blowers in the warrant article, which — as in other towns — asked for Tisbury to limit the use of all powered blowers to specific hours and times of day and prohibit them on Sundays and federal holidays.

Board member Christine Colarusso also favored leaving Sundays out of the proposed bylaw, saying she often works six days a week and wants to do yard work when she can.

Tisbury resident Margo Sharff, the article’s sponsor, said many Tisbury residents — including about 90 people who signed her informal petition to the board calling for leaf blower control — take a different view.

“I do hear you that we are in working class neighborhoods and that people work six days a week, but we also have residents saying ‘I work 6 days a week, and I want one day and a few federal holidays to open my windows, sit in my yard, play with my children, study and rest,’” she said.

As changed by the board, the article now gives electric leaf blowers free rein while imposing a complete prohibition of gas-powered blower use on Sundays, town counsel David Doneski said, because the remaining language specifies only what days the machinery may be used: Monday through Saturday, within specific hours and times of year.

“The conclusion from that would be that they are not permissible outside of those hours, meaning no Sunday operations,” Mr. Doneski said.

Ms. Sharff lamented that the last-minute changes left her and her neighbors — who have already held a voter information session on the original article — no time to bring a citizens’ petition to the board before the warrant was finalized Tuesday.

“This has left us in a position in which we’re presenting the article we did not want to present,” Ms. Sharff said.

Tisbury holds its 2025 annual town meeting on April 29.

Also Monday, the select board voted to give town administrator Joseph LaCivita the task of vetting candidates for harbor master, a position that will become vacant after Gary Kovack leaves next week to replace retiring Edgartown harbor master Charlie Blair.

Human resources director Pam Bennett said the town has begun advertising the job and received one applicant as of Monday afternoon.

Mr. LaCivita will review the applications and conduct interviews to screen for finalists, with the select board conducting the final interviews, according to Monday’s vote.

“We are up against a busy season,” Mr. LaCivita said, acknowledging the urgency of bringing a new harbor master on board. “Our former harbor master has agreed to help us in getting him or her up to speed,” Mr. LaCivita added.

Comments

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 04/02/2025 - 17:37

Permalink

Tom Engley West Tisbury

We need to help find a place for these people. It’s like saying we can’t have a homeless shelter because it attracts homeless people. There was a Sunny spot across from Cumberland farms. The bench was removed because someone was always sitting on it. Yes he is homeless it’s was removed by the chamber of commerce. Removing the benches punishes everyone. Who can’t see this re think this. Please. These are not pests they’re humans. Police should do their jobs to protect and serve. Does Tisbury new town manage even know where these benches are. Come on man.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 04/02/2025 - 20:38

Permalink

Jim Edgartown

This is outrageous! We are going to remove the seats because of drug use and homeless people? What about the poor seniors, special needs etc… that can’t stand for long periods of time?? For heavens sake you can see the police station from the stop.
Deal with the situation at hand, don’t penalize the people who need those benches.
Me included:(

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 04/02/2025 - 20:46

Permalink

john crelan Vineyard Haven

If the island wishes to reduce the use of cars and the bringing of cars to the island then the V.H. ferry bus shelter with Benches should stay and others built across the island based on their current use and need. Perhaps the high school building department could build a few per year as a form of
community outreach.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 04/02/2025 - 23:06

Permalink

Seriously VH

How does removing a bench deter any of this? Let alone address the root cause of what’s driving homelessness to begin with.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 04/03/2025 - 11:48

Permalink

Andy West Tisbury

This change in the benches is deplorable.

This isn't a stop where people wait very briefly for buses that come every couple of minutes. I have to wait in that spot for up to an hour and a half when taking the bus, assuming things are running on time. You've changed the accessibility of public transportation for people like me. If I want to sit, which is not really a choice for me when waiting that long, I need to do somewhere else and then sit either in the sun on a hot day or exposed to the elements on wet, windy, and/or cold day?

And for what, so people don't need to deal with the homeless situation. This seems to be a case of out of sight, out of mind.

The board has taken zero consideration for people that rely on those benches on a day basis.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 04/03/2025 - 15:46

Permalink

Amy Edgartown

Why don’t the police just enforce no loitering? What a shame for the other 99% that rely on these for basic transportation needs. Think elderly/ disabled/ parents juggling little ones. Most of enjoy a sit while we wait at any age truly. What a shame

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 04/04/2025 - 04:11

Permalink

Glen Caldwell Tisbury

Great job Tisbury,..your solution is a thoughtless, lazy hit of the “easy button”. Why not take the whole shelter away, if grandma has to stand and wait for the bus she might as well be cold and wet too. Do better!

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 04/04/2025 - 07:13

Permalink

Mary VH

Are you kidding me??? The police station is right around the corner? I can’t stand for more than 10 minutes because of a health condition.
This is unbelievable.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 04/04/2025 - 10:00

Permalink

Brian VH

This is an embarrassment! Really we can’t take care of the issue, so we remove the benches? Meanwhile the police station is a few hundred yards away? Come on we can do better. I see elderly and others with disabilities use the benches. Please I hope this is not going to happen.

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.