Four waterfront parcels owned by the DeSorcy family could be sold.
Jeanna Shepard

Group Forms to Save Prime Waterfront Property

<p>A strategic stretch of the Vineyard Haven working waterfront is for sale and an Island group hopes to form a nonprofit to buy it.</p>

A strategic stretch of the Vineyard Haven working waterfront is for sale and an Island group hopes to form a nonprofit to buy it, the Gazette learned this week.

Owned by the DeSorcy family, the four parcels of prime commercial waterfront property fronting the Vineyard Haven harbor have been offered privately for sale with an asking price of $8 million, according to several people familiar with the offer. Leo DeSorcy, an officer of the trust that hold the properties, declined comment this week.

Map outlines property area for sale.
Graham Smith
Map outlines property area for sale.
Graham Smith

“It’s not on the open market yet,” explained Nat Benjamin who owns the Gannon and Benjamin Marine Railway and is a member of the group trying to buy the properties. “The DeSorcys have offered it to us first and they are giving us a reasonable amount of time to put together an offer.”

Mr. Benjamin said the group that has formed aims to preserve the marine and water-related use of the land and buildings.

“We’re very concerned. It’s a critical piece of waterfront property. It’s sort of the heartbeat of the waterfront,” he said.

The properties include numbers 30, 34, 42 and 46 Beach Road. The combined area of the four parcels is 1.18 acres, according to assessors records. The properties are assessed at a combined appraised value of $4.5 million. There is 185 feet of water frontage in the four properties combined, according to assessors records.

In addition to Gannon and Benjamin, buildings on the properties include the Martha’s Vineyard Times, two art galleries and two small apartments, a commercial warehouse, and the site of a former paint store.

John McDonald, a member of the Martha’s Vineyard Museum board of directors, is chairman of the group working to secure the properties. He said the group’s mission is to preserve and continue the marine use of the land and buildings, while promoting job preservation, job creation and year-round housing.

“I think a lot of people are going to get involved,” Mr. McDonald said. “What we would like to do initially is raise $250,000 just from local people, small gifts, to get the vision statement well enough oiled so we can go out to the greater population and raise , hopefully, some bigger gifts. To pull this off is going to take some serious dough.”

He said the initial vision of the working group is to open up the property to tenants connected with science, oceanography and the arts.

“Good things can happen in this niche-y little traditional watercraft world,” Mr. McDonald said. “If we can get it as a center, not just Gannon and Benjamin but as a center for all the related arts, I think it’s going to cement Vineyard Haven as a world class center. All that stuff is happening right now, and they feed on each other. I think this would be a great opportunity to have it all work together more seamlessly than it is at the moment.”

The area is zoned for commercial waterfront use with restrictions that are part of a district of critical planning concern (DCPC) created for the area through the Martha’s Vineyard Commission. Commercial use is restricted to water dependent businesses in a zone that runs 100 feet back from the high water mark. Permitted uses in that zone include aquaculture facilities, boat yards and marine terminal facilities. The deep water Vineyard Haven harbor is also a documented shellfish resource for scallops and hardshell clams, and spawning area for winter flounder.

Longtime Vineyard Haven family owns strategic stretch of waterfront.
Jeanna Shepard
Longtime Vineyard Haven family owns strategic stretch of waterfront.
Jeanna Shepard

Beyond the 100-foot mark from high water, zoning bylaws allow for consumer, professional or commercial service establishments, professional, business, or social service offices and retail trade.

The DCPC was created in 1999. “The commission specifically finds that controlled development of lands and waters within the Vineyard Haven harbor district is essential to the maintenance of the Island’s unique cultural, historic and economic values,” commissioners wrote at the time the district was designated.

Mr. Benjamin said the effort to buy the property is in its very early stages.

“We’re trying to put together a group and define our mission, and make some very general plans for the property, using as many of the buildings as we can as they are,” he said. “The stage is so early there’s a lot of balls in the air and none of them have landed yet.”

A respected wooden boat architect and builder who established the Gannon and Benjamin shop with his partner Ross Gannon in 1980, Mr. Benjamin said it is important to preserve the maritime heritage and traditions of Vineyard Haven.

“Our mission is to preserve and expand traditional wooden boat building, to continue the education, training, and internships we’ve been doing,” he said. “To provide employment, and we also want to provide public access to these activities, and to the waterfront.”

Melinda Loberg, a Tisbury selectmen who has been active in waterfront issues, said the parcels are of huge importance to the town.

“All the waterfront has been important,” Ms. Loberg said. “There has been a lot of changing of hands, and generational shift. The Boch property and the DeSorcy property are both in the hands of the next generation.”

This story has been changed from an earlier version that reported incorrectly on the combined appraised value of the properties.

Comments

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 07/24/2018 - 17:17

Permalink

Edward James Gilmartin Edgartown

Donations !

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 07/24/2018 - 18:34

Permalink

Tisbury voter Vineyard haven mass

One other property across street,H.N.Hinckley and sons building vacant,Think beach rd.is up for some big changes real soon,Hope Tisbury is up for the challenge and make some good decisions better how they cancelled Stop and Shop project,..and our Post Office looks great.

Tisbury Future VH

Wouldn't it be great if Stop & Shop bought Hinckley and built a new store there? Nantucket has 2 Stop & Shops and both are nice. Parking would be much better there, too.

Mr. B Chilmark

The last thing that Beach Road needs a cross-traffic magnet 150 yards from Five Corners, 50 yards from The Net Result area (including the Shell and Citgo stations).

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 07/24/2018 - 19:39

Permalink

Fred OB

It's a sad parcel of land now with a lot of potential. Since the paint place closed up the area has looked more derelict. Maybe the SSA can relocate there and take pressure off 5 corners and keep that parcel sea-faring. Then we could get a Trader Joe's or Market Basket to backfill where the current SSA is. Something useful instead of mothballed buildings.

Bill OB

I've lived in MA my entire life and grew up when Market Basket was Demoulas. NEVER have I heard it called "trash basket". The new store at Sagamore is modern, reasonably priced, and friendly. Maybe your attitude is something we need less of.

tom hodgson wt

"Trash Basket"???? That's gratuitious dissing, if ever. Have you been to the one in Sagamore? Excellent store. Excellent prices. Excellent selection. Well worth checking out.

Mike Cape

I've literally never heard it called trash basket, I'll take their fresh meats over the garbage at stop and shop any day of the week. Maybe get off the island and try something different for a change.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 07/24/2018 - 21:22

Permalink

deshandra brown Edg

This is a perfect example of where the land bank should step in to preserve a working waterfront, along with expanding public access with a park, public paths, walkways etc

Mr. B Chilmark

If it is meant to be a magnet for people, then parking will need to be considered. In any event, the sidewalk approaches would need to be appreciably widened.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 07/24/2018 - 21:45

Permalink

NYC developer Nyc

Cannot be redeveloped
Non conforming location nothing new can be built
Do your homework not with half that

NYC2 Manhattan/Chilmark

As an Authority SSA has power of eminent domain. It could truly do good things for the harbor by flexing its Authority muscle and taking the parcel + Hinckley. A real opportunity to take pressure off of five corners congestion/chaos. Tisbury town leaders have no vision for the harbor except to jump up and down and get surprised.

Katherine Scott Tisbury

I don't think such a move would take much pressure off Five Corners. Or, the "pressure" would turn up elsewhere.
Better stick with the devil you know, and don't poke a stick into a hornets' nest. And don't mix metaphors.

Sorry Charlie MV not NYC

Your comment that nothing new can be built there is not true. They can go through the MVC. The new MVC is better than the one when it was under the directorship of the Canadian.
Not impossible.

Problem is with this group, they 're the same ones that let this derelict condition exists. The boat builder has materials all over the place. So imagine if they own it? It will look even worse (if that is even possible).

NYC Developer NYC

Read the Tisbury Zoning Sorry Charlie..... only allowed and Requiring Permit from the Board of Appeals:
Within the Shore Zone: That's 100 ft from beach grass
- Non residential structures and uses – containing
no plumbing fixtures;
There are also state and federal as that's a flood zone
existing structures is all that's allowed - That's why I'm the developer...

Wealthy Man (net worth > 0.02 usd) MV

The MVC doesn't have the authority to overrule local zoning or their own DCPCs. They can add restrictions. But not remove them. A typical MVC decision grants a town the authority to continue with their review under their laws under the condition that they include all MVC restrictions. Again, they can add, not overrule.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 07/25/2018 - 08:07

Permalink

WD WT

I'm all for revitalizing the waterfront with maritime use, and would gladly donate for that purpose. However, if funds cannot be raised, and/or businesses related to maritime do not step forward to develop on the property, then I'm also in favor of rezoning, and revitalizing the area with businesses which have nothing to do with maritime usage. From the sidewalks, derelict buildings and the overall drab and run down look of that area it is time to do something - meaning develop the real estate and land. For a downtown location on this fantastic island, that stretch is the most blighted stretch on the entire island. Vacant buildings, crumbling sidewalks, a dust storm at the Sunoco station where it should be paved, and plantings added, and lets not forget the facade of the MV Times with the surrounded weed forest! Where is the pride?

Katherine Scott Tisbury

The boat-building equipment is genuine, not "props."
If you want a "theme park" waterfront, maybe go to Newport.
Better to leave Vineyard Haven a bit funky than to tart it up and themefy a la off-island "resorts."

WD WT

I'm not talking about the boat equipment at all - I appreciate the work going on there, and what the equipment represents. I'm speaking to the derelict nature of the buildings. There is simply no reason for the Times landscaping to look the way it does, for the surrounding area to be unkempt. It just seems that many on that stretch have gotten used to letting things fall apart, like taking a cue from one block of buildings - not all of course, but some. I hope the group gets the funding it needs, and the area is revitalized - but anyway it goes - it needs an upgrade.

Katherine Scott Tisbury

WD: Perhaps businesses along there are waiting for definitive info on the Beach Road plan,before they redo their landscaping.
I personally see no reason why a couple of feet couldn't be taken on either side of the road. Just move the signage and "landscaping," such as it is, back a couple of feet.
Still, you are right, they could clip the rosa rugosa and the privet along there.

Cub Tisbury

Most of the valuation is probably for the land. The buildings are in pretty bad shape and have had no improvements in decades so I'm guessing they are not assessed that highly. Developing the area would certainly help the town's tax base.

Town resident, too Tisbury

Appraised value is half of asking price. Why would they want to hand millions over to new owners? Silliness. And the new owners shouldn’t be a non-profit. The parcels need to contribute to the town’s tax base, not be a scam to avoid paying property taxes.

Town resident, too Tisbury

Appraised value is half of asking price. Why would they want to hand millions over to new owners? Silliness. And the new owners shouldn’t be a non-profit. The parcels need to contribute to the town’s tax base, not be a scam to avoid paying property taxes.

John Gault Oak Bluffs

I completely agree with Town Resident,too. Making this a non profit that will not pay any property taxes on this expensive property is just the beginning, the people in charge will receive a salary for themselves, staffing, you know another Martha's Vineyard Commission in making the that will control a very large section of the waterfront and make up there own rules and regulations. Just my opinion, but its important to look under all the rocks to make sure nothing is being hidden.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 07/26/2018 - 07:34

Permalink

R Scott Patterson Edgartown

The entire area is at sea level, sea levels are rising. Investing large sums on money here is just foolish!

Taxpayers Edgartown

The people of Vineyard Haven would welcome a tax break. If
the Landbank Organization gets a hold of this property, more tax revenue is lost. I envision a boardwalk/Pier similar to the one in Chicago to be built. There would be restaurants and shops built on this pier.This would bring in huge tax revenue, beautify that dilapitated area, and would take into consideration of the rising sea levels. What are other peoples thoughts on this?

miked WT

I agree
Developing a boardwalk type area with Shops, Restaurants, Cafes would be an incredibly smart thing for Tisbury to do with this golden opportunity.
Let's see how short sighted Tisbury is on this one.

Mr. B Chilmark

Rising sea levels or not, it floods anyway. You are right on target. I wonder what sort of insurance would be available for building in that area...and if it were available, at what cost?

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 07/26/2018 - 17:48

Permalink

Wealthy Man (net worth > 0.02 usd) MV

I will throw in my two cents here. This is an highly emotional issue for all involved, and justifiably so. Images of great craftspeople thrown from their shops, those shops replaced by fancy condos and restaurants long on prices and short on value. Take a deep breath. If the group working to save this waterfront raises some tens of thousands of dollars, don't spend it on visioning sessions and fundraising campaigns. No charity auction dinners please. Not yet. Spend it on a good engineer and land use attorney. Pretend you are the "bad guy" and figure out what a diabolical developer could legally do with the property. The MVC may not be to everyone's taste, but their DCPC regulations sure do stand up in court. Tisbury zoning has nearly as strong an influence on what can and will be done here. I will make an educated guess that based on the incredibly stringent use restrictions placed on this land by the MVC and the people of Tisbury that the DeSorcy family will wind up getting far less than even the assessed value for their land. Don't let them fool you into raising well meaning dollars to pay them off for a threat they don't present. Negotiate, but first, figure out what this land is really worth to an investor with bad intentions. Pay them a tad more. That will leave about four million bucks in unused much appreciated donations for the next battle to keep this island nice.

NYC Developer NYC

You nailed the nail on the head! Im also a Vineyard developer and my family has a long history of developing on MVY, one of the largest.
Read the Tisbury Zoning only allowed and Requiring Permit from the Board of Appeals: Within the Shore Zone: That's 100 ft from beach grass - Non residential structures and uses – containing no plumbing fixtures; There are also state and federal as that's a flood zone existing structures is all that's allowed - with setbacks from road and the septic/flooding issue, I would not even pay assessed value.

Ed Edgartown

What about a pier and promenade similar to what was done in Oak Bluffs? It could connect (somehow) to the other improvements being suggested for the street.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 07/26/2018 - 17:50

Permalink

George Stein Edgartown

Diversity of ideas is nice. The planned changes to the adjoining road avoid mention some how. Temporary housing for summer employees has to go somewhere. Septic tank for 5 corners overflow could work . Open minded and not in a hurry works.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 07/26/2018 - 19:02

Permalink

Betty Ann Edgartown, Ma

What is going on with my favorite Hardware store?? I went there last Saturday and it looks like it’s closed??

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 07/27/2018 - 07:51

Permalink

Shelley Oak Bluffs

First things first: This presents a nice clean slate for addressing the flooding issue. Creative engineering first; creative usage after.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 07/27/2018 - 21:17

Permalink

Wealthy Man (net worth > 0.02 usd) MV

Just a point of clarity here. Non-profits are not exempt from property taxes. Charities are. There is a vast difference. And Massachusetts won't even defer to IRS recognition of charities. They leave that to the local assessors in a town, with some very stringent guidelines. Vineyard Haven assessors are not soft on this issue, and there is no way the current use could be continued under some non-profit sleight of hand. Have some faith, emphasis on some, and perhaps not too much. Mass courts tend to lean towards exemptions when a common sense sniff test would suggest profiteering. Just please consider that current for profit businesses would have to make huge changes that benefited the public in ways much more meaningful than just being a nostalgic reminder of better times. Education, openness to those without much money at all, providing a function government should but can't...that gets you a tax break. It could be an exciting new direction for what exists now. But it certainly won't be an easily won tax shelter. This is a great opportunity for VH and all involved.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sat, 07/28/2018 - 08:01

Permalink

Kenny VH

Taxes in Tisbury are already tough for many residents, so whatever is done, it can’t be a non profit that will not contribute to the tax base. That area is in disrepair, and needs a substantial facelift. Don’t wax nostalgic about preserving the area for those who toil at their craft for little more than love. Gannon & Benjamin build wooden boats for rich people, and if they end up with the property, they need to clean up the area, and pay their fair share in property taxes.

Edward Tisbury

I'm tired of folks claiming we have a high tax rate in Tisbury. I moved here 7 years ago from a suburb of Boston. My property taxes are 25% of what I paid there. This false narrative of high taxes in Tisbury is what keeps our town from investing in the future. It gets really depressing to see Tisbury do nothing, all the time, on anything.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sat, 07/28/2018 - 23:04

Permalink

JAMc VH and New Orleans

Gannon and Benjamin is an establishment of excellence, ethos, and island history. I believe it is a great point of pride for the island to have one of the top wooden boat building shops in the country, if not the world, right on the VH harbor. I, for one, would do anything I could to make sure they stay right where they are. Nat and Ross, I hope you prevail.

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.