Martha's Vineyard Hospital CEO Is Fired

<p>After just 13 months on the job, the president and chief executive officer of the Martha&rsquo;s Vineyard Hospital was abruptly fired Monday morning for reasons that have not been disclosed.</p>

After just 13 months on the job, the president and chief executive officer of the Martha’s Vineyard Hospital was abruptly fired Monday morning for reasons that have not been disclosed.

In a press release emailed to the Gazette, hospital board chairman Tim Sweet said Joe Woodin was “stepping down” from his role and that former president and chief executive officer Timothy Walsh would return as interim CEO. The release gave no reason or time frame for Mr. Woodin’s departure.

But speaking to the Gazette by telephone, Mr. Woodin said he had been fired.

“I just got summarily fired at 8 a.m. with no notice and no discussion of anything I’ve done wrong — by the board chairman [Timothy Sweet],” Mr. Woodin said.

Reached by phone, Mr. Sweet had little comment. “He is stepping down from his position. I would really like to stay with the press release,” Mr. Sweet said. He did say that Mr. Woodin’s departure is the result of a board decision although he could not say if there had been a vote.

“It was a decision of the board — I would rather not get into the process right now,” he said.

The press release, signed by Mr. Sweet, noted that Mr. Woodin had “brought many fresh ideas and changes” to the hospital since his arrival. “We extend our thanks to Joe for his dedication and hard work in our behalf and wish him fair winds and all the best wherever his next steps may lead,” the press release said.

But Mr. Woodin, a longtime rural hospital executive from Vermont who was hired last year to take the helm at the Island’s only hospital after a nationwide search, did not mince words.

He said he was asked without warning on Monday by Mr. Sweet to sign an agreement saying he was resigning for personal reasons — and he refused.

“I’m not resigning. I love this job. I just bought a house,” Mr. Woodin said.

“This is the worst of Island politics and this is between the board chairman and me,” Mr. Woodin said. “Apparently I have crossed him, although I have always respected him. I was speechless.”

Mr. Woodin said he was given no reason for the firing. “There have been no performance reviews given to me, no documentation, no phone calls, not a single concern over my performance,” he said.

Mr. Woodin, 56, was named in February 2016 to replace Mr. Walsh, who was retiring after 16 years. He started work last May.

Mr. Woodin came to Martha’s Vineyard from Gifford Medical Center, a critical access hospital in rural central Vermont, where he had been president and CEO since 2000. He also formerly held key positions at Fletcher Allen Health Care, formerly the Medical Center Hospital of Vermont.

Trained as an industrial engineer, he began work in business and manufacturing but early on in his career moved into hospital administration in Vermont, spurred initially by his work in a homeless shelter in Burlington, Vt.

At the time of his appointment, Mr. Sweet, the board chairman who also led the search committee, said Mr. Woodin almost immediately rose to the top of the candidate list. “He quite frankly seemed to be custom made for exactly what we were looking for,” he said.

For his part, Mr. Woodin said at the time his decision to take the Vineyard job was spurred by personal events.

“In life a lot of the things we do are structured and planned and we think through them . . . . and sometimes things happen in life that are dramatically different,” he said. “For me it was the loss of my wife and high school sweetheart that was sort of the calling that I could have easily ignored. But I decided I should probably have the courage.”

Mr. Woodin came under criticism after he announced in February that the hospital would be closing an elderly independent living unit at Windemere because of low residency and deep financial losses.

Last month, Mr. Woodin announced that the hospital had reached agreement with Martha’s Vineyard Community Services to convert a building known as the Red House to a crisis stabilization unit. The plan had been negotiated by Mr. Walsh, but Mr. Woodin put it on temporary hold saying he needed to find suitable space to house the billing department that would be displaced.

In the press release, Mr. Sweet credited Mr. Woodin with conducting a comprehensive facility study outlining the present and future needs on the hospital campus.

“Joe’s training as an industrial engineer came to the fore as he facilitated a collaborative review of the old 1972 hospital building and all the departments delivering care within,” the press release said. “His assessment showed that as MVH has continued to grow and evolve since the opening of our new hospital in 2007, there remains more work to be done to insure that the delivery of primary and specialty care will complement the environment and patient centered care that our new hospital has brought to our acute care. We are committed to continue the important work that Joe began to plan for our future and be the best we can be.”

On Monday Mr. Woodin said: “I am being tossed out. My computer has been shut off and I’m packing up. This is unbelievably unseemly.”

Comments

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 06/07/2017 - 11:57

Permalink

Rick and Shelley Off Island

We know Joe personally and he is a man of utmost integrity and competence. This can not be allowed to stand. Not only is this patently unfair to him, but this is a huge loss for the island as well. There is no better time than now to examine the board, its processes and make changes. If action is swift, there still may be time to right a wrong and retain a world class executive for the hospital.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 06/07/2017 - 12:05

Permalink

Rick and Shelley Off Island

We know Joe personally and professionally and he is a man of utmost integrity and competence. Not only is this unfair to Joe as the CEO of the hospital, but it also represents a significant loss for the Island. This cannot stand. The time is now to examine this decision, the leadership of the Board, and its processes. If action is swift, there may still be time to right a wrong and save a world-class executive for the hospital.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 06/07/2017 - 14:45

Permalink

John Rodenbaugh Tisbury

30 years ago the hospital was dysfunctional and mopeds were hated but unable to be banned. Ah, sweet memories....

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 06/07/2017 - 17:44

Permalink

Mary Ellen Larsen tisbury

We're not in Kansas anymore. I am a recent retiree from MVH and have seen many changes resulting in improvement of services and patient care. Unfortunately with this growth and outside influence we have lost our identity and since of family. Joe Woodin's credentials as a rural hospital adminestrator was a good fit. everything i have heard and saw he was a real asset to the facility. hospital family and community. The Board however has lost site of who we are and relish being a collector of art. It is time for Tim Sweet to take that huge fishing boat and resign from the board and others who have been there forever should join him.We need to replace the art and pay homage to past medical and nursing staff. There is a beautiful oil painting of the original hospital hanging out of site down one of those corriders instead of behind the hospitality desk in the main lobby for the public to see.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 06/07/2017 - 23:28

Permalink

Employee Off Island

Mr Woodin never exhibited anything short of the utmost level of professionalism, true vestment and respect for MVH . He held a professional bar that set an example for all of us to always strive to in achieving the best possible patient care outcomes. Positive visions were becoming reality, avenues of communication were opening and a feeling of genuine caring from the top was finally being felt by so many . It's a very sad loss for MVH ... sending many heartfelt thanks to a wonderful leader that will missed more then words could ever convey .

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 12/29/2017 - 03:58

Permalink

Female Doc in West Tisbury off island

What did ever happen with this seemingly precipitous firing? In seeing the review of 2017, I don't see that there was any investigation into this.
I know of a medical student who chose not to go there for a rotation as she never heard back from the supervising M.D. What is going on there?

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.