State contractors entered the state forest this week and cleared three homeless encampments, razing tents and leaving several Islanders without their possessions.
State contractors entered the state forest this week and cleared three homeless encampments, razing tents and leaving several Islanders without their possessions.
Crews hired by the state Department of Conservation and Recreation cleared the encampments on Monday, after posting notices on trees in the area and talking to people who had been sleeping in the tents.
With the Island’s sky high housing costs and lack of a year-round homeless shelter, the forest has become a place for people with nowhere else to go. But camping in the forest is illegal and DCR has cleared camps once a year for the last four years, said Conor Laffey, the state forest superintendent.
“I don’t really know the solution but it’s not for people to come and live in the state forest,” he said Thursday.
DCR said the clearing was done for public safety and environmental reasons after the sites were found to be littered with trash, feces, vodka bottles, cigarette butts and evidence of fires in pine needles.
“In coordination with state and local law enforcement, DCR routinely clears encampments in state parks to protect the environment, the safety of the public and to maintain our public lands,” the agency said in a statement. “These actions help reduce risks from uncontrolled fires and hazardous conditions; prevent damage and contamination to natural habitats; address unsanitary conditions; and are part of our ongoing work to maintain our public assets and ensure they are safe spaces for all.”
Several police departments were aware of the situation and Edgartown police were there during the cleanup on Monday, according to DCR. The agency said it would continue to work closely with municipalities and public safety officials, as well as local agencies and organizations that help people affected by the clearings.
It’s not clear how many people were staying in the encampment. Sharon Brown, the director of homeless services for Harbor Homes of Martha’s Vineyard, estimated about 20 people were there, though Mr. Laffey said there were only about three people there as of last week.
In the clearing, people’s belongings were rounded up, according to Ms. Brown.
“They took everything, birth certificates, I.D., medication, everything,” Ms. Brown said.
“The [Massachusetts] Department of Conservation and Recreation contacted a private company off-Island, and they came on with some dumpsters and they cleared everything and took it to the dump off-Island,” she said.
One client, whose epilepsy medicine was trashed, was taken to Martha’s Vineyard Hospital after suffering a seizure, Ms. Brown said. Another camper lost her only photographs of her deceased children.
“I’ve been on call after call, with so many tears,” Ms. Brown said.
“I called around to see if there was any way that we could at least get some of the stuff back, especially the identification, but it was all disposed of,” she added.
Harbor Homes and emergency services officials are now working to help replace the confiscated identification documents and prescriptions, Ms. Brown said. They are also trying to find alternative places for the people to sleep, but finding space is proving difficult. There are no shelter beds on Martha’s Vineyard between late April and Nov. 1, and Ms. Brown said nothing is available on Cape Cod either.
“I can’t find one bed right now,” she said. “We have nowhere for them to go [and] we’re afraid to provide more tents and sleeping bags because we’re not sure if this is going to happen again.”
DCR did not touch any of the people’s belongings before July 29, according to Mr. Laffey and several notices were given. He also has gone out to the campsites once a month, offering to help clean up the trash.
The clearing comes as officials have had concerns about the potential for forest fires. Mr. Laffey said he’s seen signs of camp fires and propane grills.
There is no shelter for the Island’s homeless population in the summer. Harbor Homes has been operating a winter shelter on the Martha’s Vineyard Community Services campus but that location closed down at the end of March.
The organization is hoping to create a more permanent shelter and is looking at a potential location in Oak Bluffs but those plans are still in the very early stages.
The article was updated Thursday morning after speaking with a representative from the Department of Conservation and Recreation.

Comments
As one person said people
Bill Past IslanderAs one person said people have been setting up tents in the state forest for years and years. Thanks to the recent newspaper article complete with pictures the state had to do something. Some kind of notice would have been the right way to do it as other cities and towns have done when they have removed homeless encampments. I am sure there are more that they haven't found yet.
I lived and worked on MV May
YurielI lived and worked on MV May thru October 1981.
Two co worker friends of mine lived in a tent in the woods because they couldnt afford renting for the summer. One was a school teacher and the other was a tour bus driver.
The Gazette has really
Tara J. Whiting-Wells West TisburyThe Gazette has really outdone itself with shoddy reporting. To write and post an article before talking to all involved parties is lazy at best and, in this case, damaging to all parties trying to help in what is a no win situation. I reached out to the forest warden at 9:30 am and immediately received a response. Even the picture is misleading as it is not the area of the state forest where the present encampment was located. If it was the signs that DCR had posted of the date of the clearing would be visible. Advanced notice was given twice in the past month. Mr. Lafey keeps track of these encampments, offers to help remove trash and anytime there was a plan to remove the illegal encampments, he informed everyone well ahead of time. He also works with state and local police officers. A quote from Mr. Lafey; 'These sites were littered with trash, feces, vodka bottles and cigarette butts in pine needles that showed signs of fires starting in the pine needles'.
When was the last time someone from Harbor Homes or another unhoused advocate group walked out there? Then they would have seen the notices and been in a position to facilitate.
Instead of taking a bit of time to gather as much information as possible, the Gazette rushed to paint the DCR and 'state agencies' as the bad guys. Does the paper think that anyone likes this situation or that unhoused people are having to be displaced again makes any of them feel good? The MV Times ran an article recently about this whole horrible situation. There is nothing good about any of this. I am sure when Mr. Lafey attended forestry school he did not think he would be placed in this kind of position. But it was grossly unfair to paint him, DCR and other agencies as some sort of heartless group that 'raided' this area. At least pretend to do your job as ‘reporters.’
Camping in the forest is not
Carol Oak BluffsCamping in the forest is not the answer. People need modern sanitation facilities. Untreated human waste and open fires degrade and threaten the forest. While many people may be down on their luck, some are camping out so they can rent their homes for profit during the summers, or as a way to save money on lodging. If we want to have camping in the state forest, we need to change the designation and add restrooms and more fire controls.
Sad situation all the way
AM 02539Sad situation all the way around, but clearing seems necessary. It also seems as though notice this was about to happen was posted / provided. I think the completely wrong element is the disposal of all the belongings - they should have been gathered as respectfully as possible and taken to a central location (with that whereabouts posted at the cleared sites so owners knew where to go) and held for a reasonable amount of time - losing critical documents / medication / possessions is challenging for anyone, regardless of your lot in life.
Add new comment