West Tisbury Creates Short-Term Rental Committee

The short-term rental committee was created after town meeting last month passed limits on vacation rentals. The town is the first on the Island to create a bylaw on the controversial properties. 

West Tisbury formed a new committee this week to oversee short-term rentals and town officials are searching for new members. 

The short-term rental committee was created after town meeting last month passed limits on vacation rentals. The town is the first on the Island to create a bylaw on the controversial properties. 

The select board Wednesday gave the committee the green light to start meeting, and it has been tasked with coming up with rules for rentals, which have a long history in town but have raised concerns about the loss of year-round housing.

The committee hopes to focus on researching possible fee structures to then bring back to the select board. 

“[Our next task is] to research what’s available in terms of these commercial outlets and  finding out exactly what they do and how much they charge and whether they would be appropriate for us,” member Bea Phear told the select board Wednesday.

Current members include Ms. Phear, John Rau, Karen Overtoom and Sheila Morris. The town is looking for three more members to round out the committee.  

West Tisbury’s new bylaw allows homeowners to only rent one property as a short-term rental and it requires owners to live in the home for at least 30 days. The town also has a minimum rental period of two nights and it requires the homes be owned by an actual person. Limited liability companies and other ownership structures are allowed if every owner is a “natural person.” 

Comments

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sat, 05/18/2024 - 09:23

Permalink

Jean WT

This is outrageous! With the given economic situation, we need all the help we can get…
You really want to cut the hand that feeds us??? The tourists help us!

Joe West Tisbury

Jean, I could not agree more! Folks want all this affordable housing which I understand. But many people like myself rely on a rentals to survive on the island. We also need tourists and Short term rentals, without them we want need affordable housing. There will be no jobs

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Mon, 05/20/2024 - 14:18

Permalink

Ellen West Tisbury

This is has to be the most ridiculous and stupid ideas. Why I ask? We don’t need the tax revenue any more, that the rentals bring into our Town? If we push tourists away we are in deep water! We need tourists and rentals to survive as a community. I still ask Why? Can someone please answer???
If it’s affordable housing we will not have to worry, because there will be no tourist means no jobs.
Stop this before it’s too late.

John West Tisbury

I agree, I don’t get it. We all want affordable housing, but there will be no more good paying jobs on the Island. We are pushing tourists away. Without our tourists we have no economy.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 05/21/2024 - 10:15

Permalink

Ronald Henderson DC

Wow, so much hysteria in these comments. No one is looking to ban short term rentals, this bylaw was put in place so that homeowners can LEGALLY be able to rent their house on a short term basis. It is actually protecting their ability to engage in STR. The only hinderance will be if you are a major hotel chain looking to buy single family residential homes to then rent out. Do you understand this, or are you just advocating for hedge funds and hotel chains to buy up our town?

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 05/21/2024 - 10:49

Permalink

Mark A Vineyard Haven

I applaud this move. Short-term rentals are a commercial use in a residential area. At the very least, the property should be either a rental or a home, not both. Homeowners shouldn't be allowed to rent their homes during the "hot months" to bankroll their groovy island lifestyle. It's an expensive place to live.

Katie Donnelly WT

Hi Mark A,
People on MV have been renting there homes for many many years… you described a “groovy island life style” myself and many many others rely on a few weeks to support our families. If you call that groovy so be it. I call it survival.
To ban STR for one will hurt our economy. Why are we so anti tourist? We need these folks.

Dollar cost averaging

Have you put any thought into how much things will cost when the volume goes down? The overhead of business stays the same so when volume goes down what happens to the price? SSA, gas, milk… everything?

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 05/22/2024 - 13:51

Permalink

Michael edgartown

a well know corporate real estate company has decided to sell their properties on nantucket......most over $3million plus....with the inability of a buyer to rent out these properties, nantucket will become an island for only the rich....congratulations to them

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.