The Cuttyhunk Ferry Company's space in New Bedford has gone out to bid.
Jeanna Shepard

Cuttyhunkers Want Ferry to Stay Put

MassDevelopment, a quasi-public agency focused on stimulating economic growth in the state, put out a request for proposals for the different parcels on the New Bedford state pier, including the spot used by the Cuttyhunk Ferry Company.

For 20 years, Jono Billings has been running the lone scheduled ferry from New Bedford to the small island of Cuttyhunk. 

The ferry runs out of a small spot on the Whaling City’s state pier, shepherding thousands of passengers, hauling freight and keeping the island’s connection to the mainland afloat. 

But his time on the pier could be running out. 

MassDevelopment, a quasi-public agency focused on stimulating economic growth in the state, put out a request for proposals for the different parcels on the state pier, an 8-acre area that has been eyed by developers for restaurants, retail shops and the state’s burgeoning offshore wind energy industry. 

The Cuttyhunk Ferry Company is one of the parcels up for grabs in the bidding process. In an attempt to ensure its lease is renewed, the Gosnold select board voted Saturday to band together with Mr. Billings, as well as the conservation nonprofit Buzzards Bay Coalition, on the lease application. Town officials hope it will impress upon MassDevelopment just how critical it is for the ferry to maintain its foothold on the New Bedford pier.

Mr. Billings and select board member Gail Blout declined to comment on the application, saying the request for proposals process doesn’t allow respondents to talk to the media. Mark Rasmussen, the president of the Buzzards Bay Coalition, did not return a request for comment. 

Cuttyhunk is one of several islands that make up the town of Gosnold. It sits just north of the Vineyard, acting as the demarcation line between Vineyard Sound and Buzzards Bay. Part of Dukes County, the island has little in common with the rest of the county.

Though it can swell to several hundred people in the summer, Cuttyhunk has only about a dozen year-round residents. The one-room schoolhouse is currently devoid of full-time students and its small roads are usually driven over by golf carts, not cars. The island, just under a square mile, has a couple of places for renters to stay, an oyster bar, a pizza place and a small market, none of which are open in the off-season. 

In the winter, the ferry runs on Sunday, Monday, Friday and Saturday. Mr. Billings ferries the mail, groceries and other essentials from the mainland. 

Anything that doesn’t make its way via barge, goes across the ferry. 

“As a year-round resident of Cuttyhunk, I rely on the Cuttyhunk Ferry to transport my groceries, other goods, my mail and myself when needed to travel to/from the mainland,” Michelle Carvalho, a teacher at the school and the head of the Cuttyhunk STEAM Academy wrote in a letter of support. “The small year-round population would be especially devastated by any changes in access to the Cuttyhunk Ferry service and may result in more residents moving off the island.” 

With no students at the school, the academy welcomes science-based field trips from nearby schools. If there were no ferry, the academy would also lose its connection to its mainland partners, Ms. Carvalho said. More than 500 students and staff from New Bedford schools came for trips in the last three years and more are planned for the spring. 

“The Cuttyhunk STEAM Academy heavily relies on the Cuttyhunk Ferry to access mainland resources for its educational field trips, guest lectures, and specialized equipment, and materials,” Ms. Carvalho wrote. 

Proposals to MassDevelopment were due Wednesday and the agency will consider how they benefit the agency, the region and the state. In its RFP, the agency said it is looking for a “vibrant mix of commercial and industrial uses” for the pier that preserve or expand water-dependent uses, including shipping, cargo handling, cold storage and dockage for the city’s famed commercial fishing fleet. 

“Current uses at the pier, including the Cuttyhunk Ferry, will be considered as part of our review,” said Kelsey Schiller, a spokesperson for MassDevelopment. 

Ideas for the rejuvenation of the pier have been tossed around for years. Last year, MassDevelopment picked Taber’s Wharf Partners to develop the pier after a previous request for proposals. 

The conglomerate had envisioned restaurants, a new seafood auction house, retail stores and an operations hub for the offshore wind energy industry, but never mentioned the Cuttyhunk Ferry Company in its plans. 

According to the New Bedford Light, Taber officials later said the ferry company was welcome to stay, but the overall plans were eventually rejected by the state, and the pier was put out to bid again in separate parcels instead of the whole 8-acre swath. 

This is the first time the town and the ferry line have joined forces in the application to MassDevelopment. The Gazette was unable to determine whether anyone else submitted a proposal for the lease and there will not be a public opening of bids, according to the request for proposals. Awards are expected to be made in March or April. The Buzzards Bay Coalition, which is based in New Bedford, has a strong interest in Cuttyhunk, having helped preserve hundreds of acres on the island. 

If the ferry cannot stay at its current location, it’s not clear where else Mr. Billings could go. There are few places that are close enough to Cuttyhunk, have space for customer parking and have a crane that could move freight. 

Without a ferry, a water taxi from New Bedford would be the only remaining service to Cuttyhunk, a situation Islanders said would be untenable.

“I urge all stakeholders to support the Cuttyhunk Ferry proposal and work together towards a brighter future for Cuttyhunk Island,” Ms. Carvalho wrote.

Comments

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 03/01/2024 - 07:54

Permalink

Dale Lynch Cuttyhunk Island

Retail Shops, Restaurants, Hotels and Condos and the like do not belong on a WORKING WATERFRONT. Portland Maine and other Ports pushed back in the 1980's against the gentrification of working waterfronts. Which support hundreds of small maritime related business including the Ferry. The development focus for encouraging Retail Shops ,Restaurants, Hotels and Condos should be in the Downton Areas of New Bedford. This mornings article in the New Bedford Light reenforces this argument.

Jon Winet Gosnold-Cuttyhunk Climate Action Network

Dale Lynch'comments are spot on.

Downtown New Bedford is a largely untapped resource - and honoring its whaling history can be a far greater economic driver. Eliminating the working waterfront and replacing it with questionable commercial operations will cheapen the authentic New England experience New Bedford can offer.

For those of you have visited "Fisherman's Wharf" in San Franciso, you may well have noticed that commercial development over the years has actually resulted in the disappearance of fishermen! It is now a shabby neighborhood of the City that no locals frequent. It is now comprised of tourist trap stores, and overpriced mediocre sea food. New Bedford can do better.

And of course, as Cuttyhunk year-round resident Michelle Carvahlo states, the Cuttyhunk Ferry is in fact essential to the life of Cuttyhunk.

One correction: Ethan Genter's excellent article mistakenly adds two weekdays the Ferry runs. It's actually only on Friday and Monday that it makes its essential trips to the island.

Thanks again to Mr. Genter and to the MV Gazette for spotlighting this important local story.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 03/01/2024 - 10:25

Permalink

Frances Cammarata Stoughton, MA

This is very disturbing! Parents and grandparents are buried on the island which we visit at least annually.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sat, 03/02/2024 - 14:00

Permalink

Michael Milanoski COHASSET

The Commonwealth needs to maintain our commercial maritime activities on public waterfront property including the state pier in New Bedford. Similar to the steamship authority, Cuttyhunk Ferry has an identical public purpose role that is critical for safety of the public island. Cuttyhunk Ferry should be granted a similar size operational space as part of the bid requirements for any private redevelopment proposal on this public asset, state pier that is being managed by MassDevelopment.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sat, 03/02/2024 - 15:01

Permalink

Dennis Proulx

I take the side of Cuttyhunk inhabitants. What would they do and where would they go if the ferry moved? It’s vital to them. Especially the mail ! They are great people. Please consider their welfare very seriously!

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sat, 03/02/2024 - 23:05

Permalink

Rev. Scott Ward Washington

For the tens of thousands of parishioners who have been served by the historic iconic Cuttyhunk Island Church atop the island, which has seen services held by Episcopalian, Roman Catholic, United Methodist and other Faith groups, and the clergy who have faithfully ministered to people of all ages, in seasons of celebration and sorrow, the ferry from New Bedford to Cuttahunk has been not just a practical and vital lifeline for anyone on the island, but a connection that fosters Faith, too. There's a reason why Jesus spent time at the Sea of Galilee and on boats too. It's also a reason why there are churches and places of faith in New Bedford and on Cuttyhunk too. It's true that Cuttyhunk is the smallest of the Elizabethan chain of islands. But it also has the richest history that stretches back to 1602 when Bartholomew Gosnald first visited. Gosnold is the one who also named Cape Cod and Martha's Vineyard during that visit. Because of the success of that visit, other people would come to America. Gosnold would be a part of the Jamestown expedition. It's hard to imagine America as we know it today without Gosnold and the native Americans who first came to Cuttyhunk island and the Vikings before them as well. The wonderful thing about Cuttyhunk is that anyone can go for a day visit thanks to that Ferry from New Bedford to Cuttyhink. The Ferry is not just for the privileged few but a practical way for anyone to visit a beautiful historic heritage island thanks to that ferry that runs from New Bedford to Cuttyhunk in all seasons and all seas. The dedicated dock space for the Cuttyhunk Ferry in New Bedford has served generations of visitors and residents of Cuttyhunk, hard-working small businesses, and people of faith. It is just a simple ferry but a critical link to the foundation of America. Allowing The Cuttyhunk Ferry to continue to use its dedicated dock space in New Bedford is not only the right thing to do but the patriotic thing to do too. Long before developers ambitiously eyed New Bedford's waterfront and imagined glittering restaurants and upscale retail venues, that waterfront served a more practical and modest noble purpose, from the brave Ferry that sailed the seas from New Bedford to Cuttyhunk to the Generations of immigrant fishermen who risked their lives everyday to go out and bring in nature's bounty amidst uncertain weather and restless seas. They helped build New Bedford. There is a place for development but there is also place for continuity and connection to something bigger than ourselves. That's what the ferry from New Bedford to Cuttyhunk represents. That's why allowing the continued use of that dedicated dock space in New Bedford for the Cuttyhunk Ferry is not only practical but good public policy, too. It's a way to highlight and promote New Bedford's values and attract new businesses and families, too. The character of a city is determined not just by the number of retail stores and restaurants it has but by its cultural connections, too. Allowing The Cuttyhunk Ferry to use the dedicated dock space it has now accomplishes both those goals. And earn the Goodwill and gratitude of visitors, Islanders, residents, New Bedford residents and visitors, and people of faith. That's a priceless legacy worth protecting and promoting. History Matters. Faith Matters. Respectfully, Doing the Right Thing Matters too.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 04/05/2024 - 14:04

Permalink

CWO 4 Edward Juratic USCG Ret. Kirtland, Ohio

As a retired Coastie I was stationed on Cuttyhunk for over a year in 1956. I found the Islanders a very welcoming group of people. I remember the restaurant Seabreeze near the station where many a drink was poured, although the Island was dry. We had several cook-outs behind the station with the islanders. CG supplied quite a bit of the food the seafood by the Islanders. I remember the Tilton's, Haskells, Veeders and Smiths to name a few. The ferry should be kept, this is history and the island has a lot of it. I have a few pictures of my time there.

Ed Juratic

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.