In a select board meeting this week, fire chief Alex Schaeffer shared several renderings for a proposed new fire station building, which would include a new community training space and expanded parking.
Edgartown’s fire station could be getting a hot new look.
In a select board meeting this week, fire chief Alex Schaeffer shared several renderings for a proposed new fire station building, which would include a new community training space and expanded parking.
After a 2019 feasibility study found that the current station was in need of a major overhaul, the Edgartown fire station building committee has been brainstorming what those changes could look like since June. The committee determined that building a new station at the current location on Peases Point Way would be cheaper than renovating the existing one.
The proposed plans would give the new station a footprint of 14,000 square feet, double its current size. Most of that square footage would be the shared community space, which would be open to community CPR classes, first aid trainings and municipal meetings as needed.
“They’re the kind of things we’ve done in the past when we had the space,” Chief Schaeffer told the Gazette, adding that much of the station’s prior demonstration space had been turned into sleeping barracks.
The new building would also include an auxiliary bay behind the main building for additional storage and a small parking lot to be shared between the elementary school and the station. The auxiliary bay would allow the station to continue to function during the construction process.
The committee is still working out certain planning details, Chief Schaeffer said, so it’s possible they may add additional parking in the future. Other than that, the station retains key similarities, particularly in its historic look and feel after select board members raised questions of aesthetics in a December meeting.
“We want to make sure it best fits the character of the town,” Chief Schaeffer said.
The project is estimated to cost $21.5 million, with funding going up to a vote in town meeting this spring. If approved, construction would likely take place in a year, town administrator James Hagerty said.
Just next door, the police department has hired a new officer. The select board approved the appointment of John Dacey, a former patrolman at the Falmouth Police Department, at Chief Bruce McNamee’s recommendation.
“By all accounts from what I’ve heard…this is a top-notch candidate that we’re lucky to get,” Chief McNamee told the select board.
Before working in Falmouth, Mr. Dacey spent five years in the Coast Guard.
“You sound like you’ll fit right in,” select board chair Margaret Serpa said.

Comments
There has been little public
Bob EdgartownThere has been little public talk about the need for a new fire station. Now in a Quick few months they want us voters to spend over $21M this is out of control. There is no way we need this big of space. We do not need additional meeting space we have the library, town hall and places we could rent if needed. Out of control wish list for this group. Better to spend the money trying to regionally solve the fire and EMT issues facing the island.
This comment feels incredibly
Susannah EdgartownThis comment feels incredibly shortsighted. As stated in the article, this plan appears to have been developed due to a feasibility study that took place 4 years ago. If their previous training spaces are now being used as sleeping barracks there seems to be a clear need; they, and the community members they serve, require that they have proper training and equipment to provide us with emergency services when necessary. How do you see this accomplished in a room rented from the library that would be used for a toddler sing-along the hour before?
This is a much needed and
Born and Raised MVThis is a much needed and long overdue project, it has been decades since the current building met building standards for EMS and fire guidelines. Please support the volunteers who sacrifice their time and safety for the rest of us, their personal safety and health depends on it, as does that of our community. We all deserve a fire station with appropriate training and sleeping spaces, thank you to Chief Schaeffer and all members of our department, you are indispensable to our community and much appreciated.
Keeping up with Jones of
Ed EDGARTOWNKeeping up with Jones of other towns. I fully support all of our first responders. But 21 million just like that? I don't think we are anywhere near of expanding the facility yet. Much more reasonable to continue doing maintenence and upkeep on a very solid building that currently meets our needs. It's not needed right now.
Edgartown has no ability to
Slater MVEdgartown has no ability to be remotely fiscally conservative or even responsible. It’s always got to be new and shiny.
With all kindness, with what
EdgartownWith all kindness, with what fire service operational knowledge do you confidently state that the building meets their needs? Are we just assuming it meets their needs due to what we see as we drive by?
I see a well built building.
Ken Edg.I see a well built building. It would be a shame to destroy it.
Yes to the new Fire Station!
Island HomeYes to the new Fire Station! Ask any department member, they will all be happy to explain how it's necessary to effectively do their job.
Add new comment