More than 200 Islanders are expected to take part in Martha Goes to Beacon Hill on March 23, an event organized by the Coalition to Create the Martha’s Vineyard Housing Bank.
When legislators convene on Beacon Hill Thursday, March 23, they will be joined by many Vineyarders hoping to ease the Island’s housing crisis.
More than 200 Islanders are expected to take part in Martha Goes to Beacon Hill, an event organized by the Coalition to Create the Martha’s Vineyard Housing Bank. On the steps of the state capitol, the group will lend its support to a proposed Vineyard housing bank bill that is before the legislature.
“We have healthcare workers, first responders, farmers, boat builders, retirees, retail workers, small business owners all willing to contribute,” coalition administrator Noah Lipnick said. “We had a dancer sign up who said she is very good at whistling loudly in crowds.”
All six Island towns voted in favor of the housing bank last spring, to be funded by a two per cent transfer fee on most real estate transactions over $1 million. The housing bank aims to ease the burdens on renters and homeowners by converting existing properties into income-restricted rentals and providing prospective homeowners with loans for down payments, among other things.
But the road to approval has already proved to be a difficult one. Last year the initiative stalled at the state level and legislators traveled to the Island to discuss decoupling the transfer fee from the bill, saying that the legislature was more likely to approve statewide enabling legislation rather than a specific bill for the Island.
A similar bill for Nantucket was set forth by Mr. Fernandes, but died in the legislature.
Island towns, however, voted not to modify the document and in January Mr. Cyr and Mr. Fernandes filed a home rule petition on behalf of the Vineyard
Mr. Lipnick hopes next week’s demonstration will set this bill on a different path.
“We wanted to make sure we hit the ground running, so there’s no mistake in our legislators’ minds that this issue is important to us,” he said.
The all-day event begins with a 7 a.m. ferry to Woods Hole, after which five private chartered buses will take attendees to the capitol steps. There, half the group are signed up to meet with legislators while the other half will make their presence known in front of the state house.
Afterwards, participants will head back in the buses to catch the 3:45 p.m. return ferry.
Moving several hundred Vineyards on and off the Island is no easy feat, coalition member Abbie Zell said. It took several months of planning just to imagine what the transportation, food and itinerary for the event could look like. To encourage attendance, the coalition reached out to towns and business owners to give their employees paid time off to attend the event. Goldie’s Rotisserie is also signed up to provide food for the day.
“Diverse representation and big numbers are critical to our success, so we wanted to remove whatever barriers possible,” Ms. Zell said.
To get critical face time with key legislators, John Abrams said coalition members have been in contact with Mr. Cyr and Mr. Fernandes, who are in the process of coordinating meetings for next Thursday. The group has also spoken with members of Gov. Maura Healey’s office, who have highlighted affordable housing as a top priority for the administration.
“She’s very supportive,” Mr. Abrams said. “This is the first time a governor has appointed a cabinet member specifically for housing. I’m not sure if they’ll be there on Thursday, but they’re certainly with us.”
Although Ms. Zell and Mr. Abrams have been involved in the housing bank coalition for several years, Mr. Lipnick first joined the coalition last December coming off campaign work with the Maine Democrats. With more than 70 per cent of Islanders voting in support of the housing bank, Mr. Lipnick said he had never organized around such a popular issue before.
“It’s kind of unheard of,” he said of the approval rate. “It’s made our lives a lot easier as organizers...Now it’s just been about letting the community know this is happening.”
Growing up spending summers on the Island, Mr. Lipnick said he began to feel the housing crisis acutely as he watched more and more of his friends move off Island to purchase houses and start their families.
“I think we all know too many people who may have grown up here, who want to live here, and have been forced to leave,” he said. “That’s the thing about this crisis. It affects everyone.”
Mr. Lipnick said he felt especially encouraged by the wide range of people who have signed up to attend next week’s demonstration, among them 50 high school students from Martha’s Vineyard Regional High School and the public charter school.
“We have an attendee as young as five years old and an 85-year-old,” he said. “It’s an intergenerational issue.”
Later this spring, the coalition is planning a letter-writing campaign to members of the housing and revenue committees and will make another trip to the State House when the hearings begin and Islanders have the chance to give testimony.
The most important thing, Mr. Lipnick said, is to keep the momentum going.
“When we invest in housing, we’re investing in our healthcare system, our public safety system, our education, and our small businesses,” he said. “I can’t think of an issue that doesn’t relate back to housing.”

Comments
It blows my mind that the
Mark EdgartownIt blows my mind that the only solution for every island issue is to slap a tax on it. Why should homeowners be penalized for investing in and maintaining their homes?
Agreed. This tax only makes
Rational Person Oak BluffsAgreed. This tax only makes home ownership more expensive for islanders. Spare me "the seller pays the tax"! Sellers may write the check but buyers will pay the price. At today's prices all buyers, including first time young families, will pay at least some of this tax as well as some of the Land Bank fee. Outrageous.
I am so proud of this citizen
Caitlin Vineyard HavenI am so proud of this citizen led campaign. Noah, we are lucky ducks to have you at the wheel. There are still bus seats to fill - join us March 23! Travel + food is covered by CCMVHB, but you must RSVP at https://www.ccmvhb.org/
Affordable housing is in
Gina Menemsha/NYCAffordable housing is in crisis mode in many areas. The Housing bank Bill if it ever gets out of Committee will be re written many times prior to a vote .. But seriously doubt the state legislators will be anxious to pass another tax to support the Bill.. It's not the only fix..
We definitely need to provide
Frank Brunelle Vineyard HavenWe definitely need to provide affordable housing and the article says that our legislature would prefer to create a state wide solution. ThiS is a national and state wide problem and this effort of 200 people to petition the state to allow a 2% tax over one million makes a lot of sense. Vermont recently adopted a state wide law with tax incentives, funds via grants to developer, and reforms on permitted land use. Kudos to everyone involved and best of luck. https://vermontbiz.com/news/2022/march/30/vermont-senate-passes-afforda….
“We have healthcare workers,
knock it off mv“We have healthcare workers, first responders, farmers, boat builders, retirees, retail workers, small business owners all willing to contribute,” coalition administrator Noah Lipnick said. “We had a dancer sign up who said she is very good at whistling loudly in crowds.”
Then let them write the checks. Those of us that worked hard, saved, invested are not interested in another handout of our money to our peers who chose other options in life. I'd like a 'give me' house in Palm beach too but they are smart enough to laugh it off their island'. Its not coincindence that proponents of this TAX will likely benefit themselves financially in the construction of affordable housing.
Simple solution, move some
Glenn MakonikeySimple solution, move some where you can afford to live. Big Period! It's not the tax payers problem to subsidize housing for people to live somewhere they can not afford. Save America from becoming a 3rd world country! The Transition over the pass 2 years has been scary.
I know local officials are
Don Klepper-Smith 5 pine lane, WTI know local officials are well intentioned about providing affordable housing, but they talk out of both sides of their mouth. In our 40 years on the island, we tried to provide affordable housing with our apartment garage. However we were fined for keeping security deposits in a Ct bank, not a local one. 41 people inquired about our place when we last put it in the market. State laws work against small landlords, so maybe they should rethink things. We were glad to pull our property off the market. It simply wasn't worth the hassles.
Can't wait to see this moved
Keith Chatinover (former County Commissioner) EdgartownCan't wait to see this moved forward at the state level! This is an investment in our community and essential for our future.
Two Questions: 1) For what
Chappy Guy ChappyTwo Questions: 1) For what purpose(s) have the short-term rental local option taxes been used? One of the original arguments for this tax was to earmark the funds for affordable housing. Has any of that occurred or has the new revenue simply been dumped into to the towns' general funds? 2) Why a transfer tax and not a property tax adder? If EVERYONE benefits from having sufficient affordable housing on the island, which I think is a basic premise of the effort, then why not simply have EVERYONE contribute in a progressive, pro rata fashion instead of making this a wealth transfer mechanism targeting a subset of property transfers, thus making the revenue source a) unstable and b) punitive towards those who invest the most capital in the island?
Add new comment