The Trustees of the Reservations has decided to withdrawn some Cape Pogue trails from its application for oversand vehicle access.
Ray Ewing

Trustees Pull Cape Pogue Trails From OSV Application

In an effort to secure at least some oversand vehicle access ahead of the summer season, The Trustees of Reservations Friday announced it has withdrawn trails and beaches on Cape Pogue from its application with the Edgartown conservation commission.

In an effort to secure at least some oversand vehicle access ahead of the summer season, The Trustees of Reservations announced Friday it has withdrawn trails and beaches on Cape Pogue from its application with the Edgartown conservation commission.

The Trustees are the largest land trust in the state and have sold oversand vehicle permits to its Chappaquiddick properties since 1990. As the organization seeks to renew oversand access this year, it has weathered a series of contentious public hearings about its management practices.

Over the past several months, Chappaquiddick residents have questioned the Trustees’ management of oversand vehicle access on Cape Pogue, spurred in part by a lawsuit claiming that the practice has caused significant harm to the area’s delicate ecosystem.

Throughout the hearings dating back to November 2022, residents and conservation commissioners alike urged the Trustees to separate its notices of intent by property so that some portion of oversand vehicle access might go through.

Until this announcement, Islands portfolio director Darci Schofield had maintained that its properties were similar enough to fall under one application. As the summer deadline approaches with no clear resolution in sight, however, Ms. Schofield said they have decided to adopt this new approach and pulled trails from the Jetties to the Gut.

“While we regret not being able to issue OSV permits for the Cape Pogue beaches, taking this approach will ensure that we can at least issue OSV permits for Leland to the Town Jetties for this season,” Ms. Schofield said in a written statement.

The announcement comes a little more than a week before the next scheduled public hearing with the conservation commission on March 22.

The sale of oversand vehicle permits typically begins in January with trails opening up to oversand vehicle access in late May.

Read the Trustees’ full statement online here.

Comments

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 03/10/2023 - 21:45

Permalink

Carl Kelly East Chop\ NJ

This is nothing but a land grab by the elite living on Chappy under the guise of preservation. I have been fishing those waters and relaxing on those beaches for 50 years and now that has been taken from me and future generations. Why have this land if we can use it? What a disgrace.

Ron Domurat Edgartown

You hit the nail on the head! The Trustee's caved and the property owners on Poge got exactly what they wanted-they won! The Trustee's also win by not having to deal with it anymore. The users are the losers! More than 50 years of OSV access to good late spring and early summer fishing is gone. Shameful!!

Rich Edgartown

Carl
I agree with your sentiment, but please don't despair. This beach theft is temporary and will be remediated in due course. Greed, cloaked in the convenient yet flimsy cloth of environmental concern, is no match for justice.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sat, 03/11/2023 - 07:22

Permalink

Ben J. Edg

30 years of driving out to the gut (mostly the best pure solitude to be found in the Spring and Fall) but wow, what a complete breakdown in communications on both sides. Totally avoidable conflict that should have been mediated years ago. Their “plan” that was hammered by Chris Kennedy and really showed the disconnect. Appears the Trustees are now buried up to their axels and there’s no tow line in sight. What a shame.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sat, 03/11/2023 - 08:41

Permalink

Tom Engley West Tisbury

These lands are fragile and no one really owns them people who have deeds to these lands are just caretakers. Nature is in charge not us nothing is being taken from you. We need to get away from me me me attitude. Chappy is a fragile out post. Look banning rafting in the gut during the summer and dropping anchor in there may have payed off big year for scallop fishermen. But we really don’t know if that made a difference or not. Driving on the beach is a privilege not a right.

Rich Edgartown

A privilege that can still be FULLY enjoyed all the way to the gut with some simple, reasonable accommodations. OSV to the gut for licensed fishermen who complete a conservation course of study. Who among us would not be willing? Sign me up!
We must pursue compromise, not binary outcomes

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sat, 03/11/2023 - 14:19

Permalink

Anonymous

The town, county, or state should use eminent domain to allow continued public access at Cape Pogue.

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.