Proposed rendering for Meshacket Commons housing development which calls for building 36 rental apartments and four homeownership units.

MVC Hears Plans for Meshacket Commons Housing Development

The Martha’s Vineyard Commission opened a public hearing on the the first major affordable housing project planned in decades for the town of Edgartown.

Traffic safety, public water use and free access to broadband internet were all topics for discussion when the Martha’s Vineyard Commission opened a public hearing last week on the first major affordable housing project planned in decades for the town of Edgartown.

The income-restricted Meshacket Commons housing development is planned for an 8.5-acre undeveloped site owned by the town at 38 Meshacket Road near the capped former town landfill. The plan calls for building 36 rental apartments and four homeownership units with a total of 78 bedrooms in a complex that includes apartment buildings, town homes and a community center with bicycle storage, all linked by walking paths and surrounded by native vegetation.

“[This] is one of the biggest affordable housing projects to come before the commission in quite a number of years,” said Doug Sederholm, who chairs the MVC’s land use planning committee.

The nonprofit Island Housing Trust is the developer, and will lease about seven acres, while the town would retain the rest of the property, according to an MVC staff presentation at the online hearing.

The project represents years of preliminary work, said Jason Mazar-Kelly, a member of the Edgartown affordable housing committee who also chairs the town’s affordable housing trust.

“It’s been a long time coming,” Mr. Mazar-Kelly said. “The committee in Edgartown is very relieved to see it all coming to fruition.”

Affirmative Investments is partnering with IHT to develop Meshacket Commons, which will then be managed by The Community Builders (TCB), which also manages the Morgan Woods development.

Under the plan, the rental units will be available to tenants earning 30 per cent to 110 per cent of the median income for the Vineyard, while the ownership homes will be available to people earning 90 per cent to 120 per cent of the median.

If incomes increase above these ranges, housing trust executive director Philippe Jordi said, the rents will increase in proportion, so tenants continue to pay the same percentage of what they earn.

Incomes will be verified annually and short-term rentals will not be allowed, he also said.

Two apartments are intended to be handicapped accessible, with washers and dryers inside the units. Other tenants will share laundry facilities in their buildings.

Solar panels and green building techniques will help keep utility prices low for the all-electric neighborhood, Mr. Jordi and Craig Nicholson of Affirmative Investments said.

Edgartown water superintendent Bill Chapman volunteered to advise the applicants on their utility plan.

“I think I can help that project with a design that will afford more fire protection and better water quality,” Mr. Chapman said.

Engineer Jason Kroll of Horsley Witten Group, which is designing the site, said he would contact Mr. Chapman.

Commissioners expressed concern about the twists and turns of Meshacket Road in the area of the proposed complex. A traffic study estimated Meshacket Commons would generate about 270 automobile trips a day.

“In both directions from this site, there is serious need of the building of bike lanes and pedestrian paths,” said Jeff Agnoli. “There needs to be town improvements. They would be essential to making this work.”

The road is outside the scope of the DRI application, Mr. Sederholm said, “but absolutely worth following up with the town.”

Mr. Nicholson said the Vineyard Transit Authority is considering the feasibility of a bus stop on Meshacket Road. The closest VTA stop currently is almost a mile away, near Morning Glory Farm.

Noting that some children in his town of Oak Bluffs have to go to the public library to access the internet, commissioner Fred Hancock asked whether Meshacket Commons would offer free wi-fi for its residents.

Mr. Nicholson said it was a possibility.

“Anyone who’s paid a Comcast bill on this Island will be very interested in you addressing that issue,” Mr. Sederholm said.

The hearing was continued to Sept. 22.

Two other hearings were also continued: one on a plan by Stillpoint Martha’s Vineyard, a new nonprofit that joined with the Martha’s Vineyard Land Bank in a recent conservation purchase near Priester’s Pond in West Tisbury. Originally approved by the commission in 1988 as a 12-home subdivision, the property now has seven lots owned by the land bank, four by Stillpoint and one by a private home buyer.

Stillpoint wants to use a barn on the property for educational events. Commissioners asked the applicant to provide more detailed information about the proposed activities when the hearing continues Oct. 6.

A third DRI hearing opened on an application to demolish a 122-year-old house at 43 Look street in Vineyard Haven and replace it with a new, larger home.

Builder Michael Morrison of Reveal Homes told the commission the house is an environmental hazard, including water damage, and should be replaced.

The home lies outside the town’s historic district and is not in the state database of historical buildings.

Commissioners had little to say about the existing building, but Mr. Hancock expressed concern about the proposed replacement, which features porches on two floors.

“When I first saw the picture I said ‘Oh boy, this is the Hamptons,’” he said. “This just doesn’t fit at all.”

Innkeeper Fred Rundlett of the nearby Look Inn asked if the new house would be used for short-term rentals.

“I don’t ever see that happening,” owner Bryan Purdy said. “The intent right now is either going to be long-term rentals or it’s possibly going to be sold.”

He continued: “I’d like to make it a year-round rental so that people can actually use the place, preferably Islanders, to live there. That’s the thinking now.”

The demolition hearing was also continued to Oct. 6.

Finally, commissioners approved their written decision approving the Vineyard Wind maintenance building in Vineyard Haven, including an addendum that will prohibit long-term storage of materials outside the building.

Comments

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Mon, 09/12/2022 - 20:58

Permalink

Islander Edgartown

Don’t build to rent, build to own . Who wants to rent for 30 years and have nothing. You guys just don’t get it

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 09/13/2022 - 07:11

Permalink

Pat OB

Slapping an apartment complex on the vineyard is a slap to the face of hard working citizens who saved/make enough money to purchase a residence on the island. Don't feed the animals, they become dependent, same thing goes with housing. This is a bad idea that will open up the vineyard to more and more less desirable citizens/ dependents.

Sara

Wow! Just wow! To insinuate that some hardworking people on Martha’s Vineyard who barely earn enough to easily make ends meet, somehow aren’t worth building housing for, is extremely insulting and elitist! Calling them undesirable citizens and comparing them to animals is disgusting. Really?? Shame on you!

William

This pathetically elitist comment is the heart of the problem, that is unwarranted discrimination and criticism of those who don’t have the means to buy or rent housing on the Island. All of the very hard working individuals who wait your tables, fix your cars, do plumbing and electric work on your house, clean your house, clerk at your bank, check you out at the grocery store, work in the hospital and health care services (and many more) see this ignorant rant for what it is, the real slap to the face. When the median housing price on the Vineyard is well over 1 million it’s not hard to see where the average worker wage comes no where close to affordable housing.

Tom Ellis Edgartown

This is one of the most reprehensible and disgusting comments I've ever seen published in this paper. It is unfortunate that you detest fellow islanders so much during a housing crisis. A better comparison though is that the wealthy are doing the housing equivalent of hoarding food during a famine.

islander3 Edgartown

Wow, I am grateful that you are not my neighbor. For many of us, neighbors, community, these are one of the biggest draws to staying here despite how challenging housing can be at times.
Whatever would you think of me as your neighbor? I am just a mere renter - me and my outdated car, my outdated iPhone, juggling two jobs. How appalled would you be? How does Edgartown even allow me to exist here?
Be a better neighbor Pat. I may just take care of you at the hospital or at the restaurant that I work some day and I will certainly try to treat you with the respect that I too wish to receive.

Mark Hess Edgartown Affordable Housing Committee

There are many, many reasons that this proposed development is being put forth as a mostly rental community. (There will be 4 ownership units). I will be glad to discuss those reasons with you at anytime, or anyone else for that matter. We feel that the plan has been well thought out, and has the general support of all those that reside in the immediate area. Furthermore, the project has the support of the various agencies within the town. The plan encompasses the most modern methods of building design, construction, and energy efficient production.
While I will openly try to hear your point of view, I disagree with your attempt to air it the way you have. Again, I will be glad to answer any questions you may have.
On a more personal note, I find your published comments both; derogatory to the potential residents of the said development, and disrespectful to all of the islandwide committees, boards, and charitable organizations that have worked so hard on this project.

George W. Aquinnah

Pat is right, while there are a few benefits to the proposed housing, there are far more negative aspects to look at. Help the citizens that are already here on the island, give existing residents the tools to become successful and helpful to the island economy. Cheap housing isn't the answer. To the comments about how mean Pats comments was, sometimes the trues hurts, help getting up, is better than any hand out.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 09/13/2022 - 07:25

Permalink

Lionel Spiro

It would be great if Comcast or one of its Executives with an island connection would find a way to fund endowed Wi Fi service. Does Comcast have reduced and affordable plans for affordable housing?

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 09/13/2022 - 10:30

Permalink

Islander 2 Edgartown

I'm pretty shocked by these comments. The people who do valuable work in this community need affordable accommodation...? How do you think people work their way up to buying?? To independence? Talk about not getting it

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 09/13/2022 - 13:00

Permalink

Bob Edgartown

Let’s see how much the MVC can turn a project that’s been worked on for several years and has been well thought out look bad. Already trying to make an affordable housing project more expensive by wanting them to redesign roads and bike paths etc. Please MVC get out of the way and let this proceed. Homeownership is not for everyone and this will help fill a huge hole in housing here.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 09/13/2022 - 13:43

Permalink

Lorraine Edgartown

No, No, NO, No, NO, NO MORE traffic, please, it is hideous. I am not able to safely bicycle during the "season" which is now extended by months, the entire Edgartown area is a choke point...just clearing the Triangle from the Village center, or vice versa, is nutsy cuckoo. Please, just rein in this run away horse, or we will all be back in buggies and shanks mare. Please, refrain from this project.

Laurence Edgartown

I hope you never need to visit the hospital, go to the bank, buy take out, need gas in your car, propane delivered, buy groceries...

Tom Ellis Edgartown

Traffic will grow whether or not Islanders are able to continue to live in the community. I hope you are out there protesting every mcmansion being built as they are built, as projects like these are an extreme minority of development occurring on island.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 09/13/2022 - 15:29

Permalink

Tom Ellis Edgartown

IHT and projects like these are the only things holding the island community together in the face of the near catastrophic flooding of wealth.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 09/13/2022 - 18:25

Permalink

Nathan Durawa Edgartown

270 trips a day looks and sounds very low. Someone should look at traffic studies for Morgan Woods and compare to current traffic on 10th street. Having lived on 10th st for 2 years I can tell you the traffic is nonstop 24 hours a day year round. Cleavelandtown rd and Meshacket are already dangerous and over used by heavy trucks. Now the town will have to attempt to make it safer for children walking to and from school and bikes riding along a narrow road.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 09/14/2022 - 09:45

Permalink

Pamela Dolby Edgartown

I would like to commend the Affordable Housing Committee and their Assistant for bringing this project to fruition. This has taken years to put together….. Congratulations!

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sat, 09/17/2022 - 07:13

Permalink

Deborah Robertson 31 Road To The Plains Edgartown MA

I am generally supportive of efforts to provide affordable housing. However the density of this project seems high in an area that already has issues with trucks and traffic. I also agree with the sentiment that the project should be built with more affordable for sale units and less rental. I understand that building for sale would reduce the number of units but if our community goal is to provide housing for families that live and work here for sale does a better job of achieving that goal. In unit washer and dryers are the norm for rental projects today and should be included. As discussed a bike path and sidewalk should be added along Meshacket Road.

I have over 30 years experience in banking and commercial real estate lending and I have financed many projects in CT with an affordable component. I would be interested in discussing further.

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.