It's looking likely that the Oak Bluffs ferry will run according to schedule, despite a request by Tisbury safety officials for a diversion in late August to accommodate departing music festival crowds.
Mark Alan Lovewell

SSA Frowns on Tisbury's Request for Beach Road Weekend Ferry Diversion

Tisbury safety officials have asked the SSA to divert its 8:30 ferry departure from Oak Buffs to Vineyard Haven for Beach Road Weekend, but the boat line’s board of governors gave a series of thumbs-down to the request.

In preparation for the Beach Road Weekend music festival in late August to be held at Veteran’s Park in Vineyard Haven, Tisbury’s police chief and fire chief have asked the Steamship Authority to divert its 8:30 p.m. ferry departure on August 26, 27 and 28 from Oak Bluffs to Vineyard Haven in order to accommodate an estimated 800 off-Island ticket holders when performances end at 8 p.m.

But the boat line’s board of governors, meeting Tuesday morning online, gave a series of thumbs-down to the request, which was relayed through SSA general manager Robert Davis.

It’s not the first time festival organizers have asked the SSA to accommodate them, said Martha’s Vineyard governor James Malkin, relating a dialogue he said took place over the past winter.

“Myself and the port council members were approached by the Beach Road promoter and organizer who wished us to add additional trips to take people to and from the concert,” Mr. Malkin said. “We made it very clear that the Steamship Authority is not a charter operation for individual businesses or events, it runs a service that provides goods and transportaton to the people who live and commute and travel back and forth to the Island.

“We also told the organizer that we would not take bulk reservations for passengers coming back and forth, and suggested he look at the capacity and do what he could, which might include limiting the number of tickets,” Mr. Malkin said.

Ferry diversions — usually for weather or mechanical reasons — already rankle Oak Bluffs leaders, Mr. Malkin said, citing a select board meeting at which he and port council member Joe Sollitto were called in to discuss the loss of embarkation fees and local business revenue that result when boats are diverted to another port.

“Unless the select board of Oak Bluffs is willing to do this because of the public safety issue, I have a very hard time supporting any changes to our schedule, and our docking, and our deployment of crew, for a single businesses that may have gotten ahead of itself,” Mr. Malkin concluded.

Falmouth governor Peter Jeffrey and Barnstable governor Robert Jones backed up Mr. Malkin’s position, saying that without a compelling risk to public safety, they would not support the festival’s requests.

“I’m also concerned about its impact on the town Falmouth, of increased traffic as well as a lack of coordination of a single business to [consider] the Oak Bluffs community as well as the town of Falmouth,” Mr. Jeffrey said.

Vineyard Haven fire chief Greg Leland told the Gazette Tuesday night that he did feel there were safety issues, adding that the boat line’s board of governors has not agreed to hear from the Tisbury public safety officials making the request.

“We’ve attempted to have a conversation with them,” said Chief Leland, adding that he and Chief Habekost both see the diversion as an imperative.

“Absolutely, we need to have that done,” the fire chief said.

Festival proprietor Adam Epstein told the Gazette Tuesday that not only did the diversion request not come from his organization, but that he also did not ask for extra ferry trips when meeting with SSA officials in late February, as Mr. Malkin asserted Tuesday.

“I did not make that request,” Mr. Epstein said. “I was misrepresented. Those allegations were untrue.”

Mr. Epstein also told the Gazette that Oak Bluffs itself requests a diversion of the 8:30 departure during Illumination Night in August to reduce traffic in town.

Mr. Jones said at the meeting that the Beach Road Weekend organization should consider chartering vessels to return its off-Island customers to the Cape.

“Private enterprise, they just can’t dictate the [SSA] transportation schedule,” Mr. Jones said.

“There are people that have more flexibility, but we don’t have the privilege,” he added. “I can’t support this.”

With no objection from Nantucket governor Robert Ranney or New Bedford governor and board chair Moria Tierney, Mr. Davis said he would confirm with Oak Bluffs town officials that they support retaining the 8:30 p.m. departure.

The 8:30 p.m. ferry from Oak Bluffs is not the boat line’s last daily departure from Martha’s Vineyard; the Island Home leaves Vineyard Haven daily at 9:45 p.m.

Story has been updated to correct that the request to have the ferry diverted to Vineyard Haven came from Tisbury public safety officials and to include comments from the Tisbury fire chief and event organizer.

Comments

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 07/19/2022 - 19:36

Permalink

George Stein OB

Bravo SSA!

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 07/20/2022 - 00:14

Permalink

Tom Engley West Tisbury

Times have changed many more rules and regulations when I was a kid they ran special trips for the circus. And as of late special trips to Nantucket for MVRHS football games My son paid to take his car so he could drive on the grey lady.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 07/20/2022 - 03:28

Permalink

Harry Dias VH

How about the private event planner to end it's events early to follow the regular SSA schedules of VH departure if the safety is such a concern?

Why should the fire chief join this and suggest the other way?

It might become a poor precedence.

Poor thinking.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 07/20/2022 - 07:01

Permalink

Robert EDgartown

Someone needs to remind the SSA that they are owned by the State, and when the police and fire departments ask them for something concerning public safety, and crowd control, they should listen. The SSA can cancel and delay ferry runs, they can make or break peoples schedules depending on their service, yet when asked to perform a service for the public, the SSA declines the request and offers now good explanation. The SSA acts as if they are denying the request of an individual, when in fact it is a request from the public! The tax payers are the owners, and the publics voice should be heard. It's time to start fighting back against taxation without representation! I guess the SSA's upper maglement(upper management) know more about public safety the the police and fire chiefs.

Jo-Ann West Tisbury

SSA is not owned by the State and doesn't pay any more attention to them than to us. But, if you think the State could run it better, maybe you've forgotten the Big Dig.

Jackie Chilmark

Adam Epstein ignored public safety by selling out tickets before this aspect of public safety was addressed! Can't blame the SSA for Epstein's failure, nor should they be blamed for the zoo Epstein has created. The public did not ask for a logistical nightmare. At least put the blame squarely where it belongs.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 07/20/2022 - 07:05

Permalink

Dan WT

The SSA does diversions to VH all the time. I get emails every week with trip diversions. Come on, what s one trip to help the folks out?? Put the Politics aside Malkin and Sollitto do the right thing.
FYI I have no interest in attending, not my type of music, full disclosure

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 07/20/2022 - 09:13

Permalink

Tom Tisbury

How many passengers according to Coast Guard Regulations are allowed on the scheduled 8PM and 945PM? just asking

Schools Out Tisbury

It's all a click away on the SSA's website - every ferry has info about it there. For passenger capacity: Island home - Carries up to 1,210 persons (including passengers and crew), with inside seating for approximately 625. Martha’s Vineyard - Carries up to 1,274 persons (including passengers and crew). The Nantucket - Carries up to 768 persons (including passengers and crew).

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 07/20/2022 - 09:37

Permalink

Carol Edgartown

This is politics at its best! Put the politics aside and help the folks out and get home safely please!
Boats are diverted all the time from OB..

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 07/20/2022 - 10:38

Permalink

Lorraine Edgartown

It is worth noting that some remember the mission statement for the Steamship Authority. Everything is getting completely out of hand. The traffic is unbearable, the constant din of machinery, unable to ride bicycles safely at all anymore, stop the insanity. The island is not, I repeat NOT, an ATM machine. Ratchet back, folks, some of us like to hear ourselves think. IMHO

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 07/20/2022 - 14:11

Permalink

Herb Rosen Brookline

I really think the SSA should divert the one boat to accommodate the Concert goers… what’s the big deal? They divert boats all the time and this is a safety issue.
Herb

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 07/20/2022 - 15:05

Permalink

Jon Denver, CO

The SSA is jeopardizing the safety of 800 of their customers. With this decision, 800 concert goers are going to have to make their way, in a hurry, to Oak Bluffs to catch to 8:00pm departure. I think this shows a bit of arrogance on the SSA's part to inconvenience 800 paying customers and respond that they're not a "charter company". Beach road will be a mess those nights and paying concert goers will have to miss part of the headliners act in order to scramble to OB.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 07/20/2022 - 17:59

Permalink

George Stein OB

Reservations for the excursion in question from OB were made months ago. Good faith to honor those patrons is indeed prudent. Privately funded event can negotiate a vendor to provide this tservice of transportation when tickets went on sale. This is not the first time this event has been scheduled. At some point we may have a federally funded wastewater holding tank installed at this site . Five Corners might also someday lose its status as a flood zone.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 07/20/2022 - 19:11

Permalink

Dean Charette

Bravo SSA. Looks like you're the first to stand up to the person who think everything and everyone is for sale.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 07/21/2022 - 07:44

Permalink

Adam Troy Epstein Vineyard Haven

Beach Road is happy to transport festival goers from the festival to OB after the festival on our shuttles at our cost. But, on the advice of the Tisbury Police and Fire Chiefs and the Oak Bluffs Police and Fire Chiefs, they all requested the diversion of the 8:30pm boat to VH so that festival-goers can just walk across the street to the terminal instead of rushing anyone on a bus between the Towns.

We have also offered to pay OB any lost embarkation fees from the diversion.

It’s actually pretty simple.

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.