Report from Port Chester, N.Y.- based Elliot Marine analyzed a potential switch from diesel to electric.
Tim Johnson

Electrifying Ferry Fleet Remains a Distant Prospect for SSA

Electric-powered Steamship Authority ferries are a long and very costly way off, according to a marine study by boat line consultants.

Electric-powered Steamship Authority ferries are a long and very costly way off, according to a marine design and engineering firm engaged by the boat line to study the feasibility of going electric.

At a meeting of the boat line governors Thursday afternoon, consultants from Seattle-based Elliott Bay Design Group joined the SSA board of governors online to present the results of their in-depth research into how the boat line might electrify its fleet.

Only by going all-electric could the Steamship Authority realize significant energy savings, Elliott Bay engineer Lydia Benger told the board.

The company presented three options for hybrid propulsion systems, with electric batteries joining diesel generators, but none would save more than an estimated 7 to 10 per cent in energy costs, Ms. Benger said.

The capital cost of building a fully electrified vessel is north of $12 million, according to the Elliott Bay study, while the shoreside charging stations needed to power up electric ferries on either side of the sound have a price tag of their own — both in dollars and in changes to the waterfront.

“Think of . . . an electrical substation,” shoreside power specialist Andy Bennett told the board, describing the visual impact of the installation, which he said would be about the size of two large shipping containers each in Vineyard Haven and Woods Hole, with buried conduits connecting to the power grid.

“You need to think about that. That terminal’s going to be not what it is,” Mr. Bennett said. “[Charging equipment] will displace some things, but it appears at first flush to be manageable,” he continued. “The bad news is it’s expensive. The size batteries you need is millions of dollars.”

Electrification plans are underway in the Washington state ferry system, Mr. Bennett said, but the fleet there remains 100 per cent diesel at present.

“These things take time,” he said.

The Elliott Bay report was commissioned as part of the boat line’s regular useful-life reviews of its vessels, which have taken place in 2012 and 2018 and are ongoing in 2022, general manager Robert Davis said.

The full report is posted online as part of the agenda packet for the May 26 meeting (found by navigating from About to Meeting Notices on the SSA website).

Among other business Thursday, the board granted permission for Cape & Islands Transport Company to add a third vessel, named MV Water Taxi, to its Falmouth-Edgartown route.

The company already is licensed by the SSA to carry passengers aboard either the Pied Piper, its largest vessel, or its slightly smaller Sandpiper.

The water taxi, purchased last year when the company was eyeing a down-Island route, is licensed to carry 40 passengers and two crew, fewer than half the capacity of the Pied Piper, Mr. Davis said.

The company is not requesting any other changes to its license agreement, which limits it to only one vessel in service per trip, Mr. Davis said.

SSA general counsel Terrence Kenneally said that adding the smaller boat will allow the company to run the more fuel-efficient vessel when passenger demand is lower.

“This is really just an operational flexibility they’re asking for,” he said.

Governors also heard an upbeat report from treasurer/comptroller Mark Rozum, who said passenger traffic in April was up more than nine per cent over 2021.

“We’re getting close to pre-pandemic levels,” Mr. Rozum said.

Director of marine operations Mark Amundsen gave an overview of the freight ferry Governor’s recent breakdown, explaining that a scheduled replacement of fuel injectors caused a disruption in engine timing that stalled the boat.

After a software update, the boat line took an extra day to make sure everything was running correctly before returning the vessel to service, Mr. Amundsen said.

While her hull is 68 years old, he said, the Governor still has plenty of useful life left in her following a complete replacement of her propulsion system in 2011.

“Also, the auxiliary power generation has been totally renewed in that vessel,” Mr. Amundsen said.

Comments

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sat, 05/28/2022 - 20:43

Permalink

Carol formerly Chilmark

Climate change will be a lot more expensive. Wildfires consuming the Cape & Islands, 120 degree days in the summer - those are in the near future. Don't wait. Act now.

thomas hodgson wt

Are you trying to say thirty years is a long time? That may be half to a third the expected human lifetime, but thirty years is an eyeblink, geologically speaking. In the last hundred years, still an eyeblink geologically, sea level has risen about a foot. Factoid: In 2020, global sea level set a new record high—91.3 mm (3.6 inches) above 1993 levels.

Carol formerly Chilmark

Incorrect; currently, MA electricity is generated 50% from fossil fuels (excluding rooftop & parking lot solar, which is counted as a reduction in demand, not as generation).

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Mon, 05/30/2022 - 10:20

Permalink

Jose Oak Bluffs

The technology to produce an electrified boat fleet is many years in our future. Even if we could magically create these today, there is a good chance that we won't have a reliable supply of electricity to run them. An article in the May 27th edition of the Wall Street Journal reads in part:

Last week the North American Electric Reliability Corporation (NERC) warned that two-thirds of the U.S. could experience blackouts this summer. Welcome to the “green energy transition.”

In a world of rolling blackouts, how reliable could an electric boat fleet be?

It takes an enormous carbon footprint to manufacture these ships. Further because most of our electricity is still produced using fossil fuels as opposed to green technology, running electric boats and cars is not a carbon neutral proposition. I wonder if these electric boats/cars are net producers of carbon emissions if one considers that it takes fossil fuels to produce the electricity to run them, and fossil fuels to manufacture them. Also, the mineral extraction mining that is required to produce the batteries is a large source of pollution (water pollution in particular), but since that is not a fossil fuel and typically occurs in countries outside of the US, I suppose it does not weigh into the discussion.

The transition to green technology is not a free lunch. For green technology to work, it needs to be accepted which means it must be both reliable and available at prices that are acceptable by our population. I believe that we are decades away.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 05/31/2022 - 05:37

Permalink

Jason Peringer Vineyard Haven

New administration building for MILLIONS? No problem! New multi-million dollar ticket office in Wood's Hole? Sure! High time for the State to take a good, hard look at the SSA charter and step in with some legislation here...

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 05/31/2022 - 06:17

Permalink

Jeff Winter Formerly Oak Bluffs

I think the SSA should be about the business of making our ferry rides a pleasant experience and not think about converting to electric boats. 120 degree days is a bit farfetched.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 05/31/2022 - 07:39

Permalink

Tim Falmouth

We could spend eternity debating whether or not mining for tons of cobalt, lithium and copper to make batteries for electric power is good or bad but I think we should prioritize our problems. Global climate change is something we will be living with Forever. But just yesterday the Steamship canceled two Governor more trips. That is the main cargo ferry to and from the Vineyard. Last week the Steamship closed the entire Oak Bluffs terminal. They have been canceling trips for over a year due to staffing shortages. If we want to prioritize the problems, SSA should maybe drop the vaccine mandate or loosen up on their marijuana prohibitions or at least stop adhering to draconian state ethics rules about things like nepotism which no other state agency adheres to. Maybe then he would find enough warm bodies to keep the boats running.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 05/31/2022 - 08:36

Permalink

Michael West Tisbury

At the very least I’m glad the Governor has a lot of life left! Love that boat

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.