Select board met Monday over Zoom.

Edgartown Says It Will Back One-Time Funding Formula for a New High School

The Edgartown select board said Monday it will support a one-time funding formula for a major renovation project at the high school.

The Edgartown select board said Monday it will support a one-time funding formula for a major renovation project at the Martha’s Vineyard Regional High School, after town administrator James Hagerty broke down the potential cost to each town.

The one-time funding formula was proposed by the Chilmark select board two weeks ago as a way to break political gridlock among the six towns over how to pay for a future new regional high school. The high school recently made the eligibility list for the Massachusetts School Building Authority, which reimburses a significant percentage of the capital costs for school building projects.

Under the proposed one-time formula, the three down-Island towns would each pay 25 per cent of the cost while the three up-Island towns would collectively pay 25 per cent. The formula is based on population data from the 2020 Census.

“We should thank Chilmark for putting this forth, getting the ball rolling,” selectman Arthur Smadbeck said at the meeting Monday. “I think it seems to be a pretty fair way of doing it.”

Mr. Hagerty gave a presentation assuming the project would cost $100 million and would be paid for through a 20-year loan. After subtracting the MSBA reimbursement and adding the interest accumulated over the course of the loan, each 25 per cent share would be around $26 million, according to his calculation.

Under the current funding formula, OB would pay almost $30 million and Tisbury roughly $28 million. Edgartown would pay almost $25 million and the three up-Island towns (collectively) would pay roughly $22 million.
 
“I think it’s a compromise . . . it tries to be as equitable as possible based on the various concerns,” Mr. Hagerty said. “The school needs to be built and we can all agree on that.”

Islandwide discussion on the matter will continue next Monday, when a joint meeting of the regional high school committee and the six town select boards is planned.

The meeting begins at 6 p.m. over Zoom.

In other Edgartown business this week, Mr. Hagerty informed the board that the town had received no responses to an invitation for bids for the Fourth of July fireworks display. The budget was increased from $45,000 to $90,000 and bids will go out again, Mr. Hagerty said.

“I want to make sure that we have the fireworks for obvious reasons,” he said. “I’m going to keep putting the pressure on and then hopefully we’ll get a bidder.”

The annual fireworks and parade will return this summer after a two-year hiatus due to the pandemic.

Also this summer, restaurants will no longer be able use public space to expand outdoor dining. For the last two summers the town has allowed the use of sidewalks and some blocked-off street areas in order to accommodate pandemic restrictions. But with cases abating as the Island heads towards summer, Mr. Hagerty said he would let that accommodation expire.

“We said we’d do it during the height of the pandemic, we did it another year, we were the only Island town to do it, but my recommendation would be not to continue,” he said.

In conjunction with the Vineyard Transit Authority, the town will apply for a state grant for small street clean-up projects on Church street and Peases Point way.

The board also voted to allow the conservation commission to change its fee structure for permits.

Corrected from an earlier version which misstated the numbers under the current funding formula.

Comments

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 03/09/2022 - 14:35

Permalink

Peter Palches Oak Bluffs

Serious communication and commitment to working together in good faith on a complex Island-wide problem will be needed in order to reach agreement on high school funding. Most people glaze over when words like tax base, tax rate, assessments, formula, bonding, operating, capitol etc. whiz by. They rely on people like Hagerty, Smadbeck, and Malkin -- people they expect to be able to trust. What we have in this story about Edgartown and Chilmark is simple gamemanship. Malkin's idea is a simplistic gimmick. Edgartown's quick endorsement attempts to create an image of sincere interest in cooperating to find a workable formula. Maybe that worked for others. It didn't for me.
Kids suffer when adults play games with each other over school funding. Failure to face up to funding issues here on the island is a main reason why we have so many school boards for so few students. Education is a huge investment with huge benefit to everyone --especially students, but to all Islanders, young and old. We need to be serious about it, fund it ingtelligently and fairly, and organize ourselves well to provide it.
We don't need more gamesmanship.

edgartown taxpayer edg

We are very fortunate to have responsible representatives in our town that you mention: Mr Hagerty and Mr Smadbeck and our other 2 selectpersons. This one time extra expenditure beyond our responsible share is a gesture to get the job done. I don't mind subsidizing OB this one time, for the 'great good' of all. Do you want to share your port fees with Edgartown>

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 03/09/2022 - 16:18

Permalink

Mike Somewhere

This is the correct way to calculate towns responsibly
By attendance by town
100M seems a little light though
200M for a school building of this size is our experience
We have completed over 20 new schools for NYC SCA/BOE

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 03/10/2022 - 07:39

Permalink

John Edgartown

So let me see if I have this straight....current funding is by headcount by town - that would seem to make sense - if every town had their own school that's exactly how you would fund it - you would take your costs, create a budget and come up with a per student costs - you could then debate that cost per student and decide among your select board whether that's too high or too low. In this case, we have one town out of the six that decides it doesn't want to pay by that formula and would like the other five towns to subsidize their students because the school resides there - OK. But what intrinsic value DOES OB gain from having the school in it's confines - great athletic facilities for them to use, a decent performing arts center to utilize, students with the shortest bus ride to school, the island's emergency shelter? and the list goes on.... it seems to me that we are dealing with a recent phenomenon in our republic - it's not truly equitable if I don't view it as somehow advantageous to me(regardless of what the numbers actually demonstrate). That about cover it?

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.