Longtime Edgartown shellfish constable Paul Bagnall told the town select board Monday that he planned to resign, effective Jan. 1, 2022, after an extended career on the waterfront that has spanned three decades.
Longtime Edgartown shellfish constable Paul Bagnall told the town select board Monday that he planned to resign, effective Jan. 1, 2022, after an extended career on the waterfront that has spanned three decades.
Mr. Bagnall, who has served as the shellfish constable since the mid-1980s and is now 66, told the board that he thought it was time to step aside at the end of the year.
“I got my reappointment this year, but after 30 years I didn’t get my last merit raise, so I’ll take that as kind of indication that it’s time for me to step down and let younger people take over,” Mr. Bagnall said. “I just wanted to thank you.”
A veteran of the Edgartown waterfront who has been instrumental in preserving the bay scallop fishery throughout the once-plentiful Cape Pogue shellfishing grounds and beyond, Mr. Bagnall has worked as a mentor and peer for shellfish officers and aquaculturists across the Vineyard during his career, earning a reputation as the Island’s senior shellfish constable.
His efforts to preserve eelgrass beds and scallop seed led to him being named the officer of the year by the Massachusetts Shellfish Officers Association in 2007. He previously served as head of the Martha’s Vineyard Shellfish Group.
In December of 2020, Mr. Bagnall was involved in a dispute with a neighbor and charged with defacing property in Edgartown district court. He agreed to pay $1,500 in restitution, and the charges were later dismissed.
On Monday, Mr. Bagnall thanked the select board for his years of service and appointments. Select board members said they would take his request to resign in January 2022 under advisement.
In other business Monday, the board voted to approve the 2021 scallop season, with recreational scalloping opening on Oct. 1 and commercial scalloping opening a month later, on Nov. 1.
The recreational limit was set at one 10-gallon washbasket, and the commercial limit at three 10-gallon washbaskets daily. Dragging is not allowed until Oct. 29.
Mr. Bagnall estimated there will be between 20 and 30 commercial scallopers on the bay, down from good years that see between 50 and 60 commercial scalloping vessels.
“The season that we’re looking at is probably a little better than last year, but no bonanza,” he said.
The town also took multiple steps on the climate change front, hearing a presentation from Martha’s Vineyard Commission consultant Megan Gombos on the Island Climate Action Plan, and adopting an update to its town-specific hazard mitigation plan.
According to MVC special projects planner Dan Doyle, the largest change between the 2015 and 2021 plan is the inclusion of an extensive municipal vulnerability plan, particularly for wildfire and flood risk.
The town also voted unanimously to extend outdoor dining regulations until the end of October.
Adopted as a pandemic adaptation, special zoning regulations that allow for outdoor dining in the town were originally scheduled to end during Columbus Day weekend. But town administrator James Hagerty suggested extending them to the end of the month due to their popularity.
“I’ve received some requests to extend the date . . . for those same reasons about the Covid situation, and its progression,” Mr. Hagerty said. “I think that is appropriate.”
The select board agreed, voting unanimously to extend the regulations until Oct. 31.
“They’ve done a good job on that, and hopefully the weather holds out to make it until the last day of October,” selectman Margaret Serpa said.
“I heard the weather was going to be like this all winter,” Mr. Donaroma quipped.

Comments
Thank you Paul for all that
Bob EdgartownThank you Paul for all that you did for the town and the fish. You have a good team behind you and are leaving the town in good hands. Fair winds in your next adventure.
Sad news to see Paul step
Islander EdgartownSad news to see Paul step down. He has done a tremendous job over the years and will be missed. I hope he decides to stay on in some sort of advisory capacity.
No merit raise after 30 years
Gina Bagnall Lincoln Niantic, CTNo merit raise after 30 years of service, local and statewide recognition of his achievements in the waters of Edgartown and beyond ? Over some dispute with a washashore ??? I’m a town truck on a town right of way… Really ? How petty can the town get ? Glad he’s retiring and will get away from small town politics… Sad for my hometown.
Gina, you put a nice spin on
David EdgartownGina, you put a nice spin on this. Firstly, Paul's had plenty of annual merit raises in his 30 year career. Secondly, I wouldn't consider doing donuts in a neighbor's front yard while driving a town vehicle "a town right of way". $1,500 in victim restitution is not a small matter. Thirdly, your negative use of "washashore" implying the victim is a town lesser resident says a lot about your perspective. We don't live in a caste system here. Honor Paul's decades of service. But don't whitewash the ugly episode that happened, either.
You are mistaken. I know for
James B EdgartownYou are mistaken. I know for a fact he did not "do donuts in a town truck" all he did was drive on a town easement,which is legal, get your facts straight before you spew nonsense.
Why keep dumping on
Grant Parker EdgartownWhy keep dumping on washashores? It was a neighbor dispute. There would’t be any physicians at the hospital or many school teachers on island. Those nice people in Niantic should kick out people born at a hospital outside Niantic. But, you don’t have a hospital in Niantic. Bet they are more welcoming to new people. Congrats on the retirement.
What a great career
Tom West TisburyWhat a great career
Good with a sense of humor.
Carolyn Pearson Western NCGood with a sense of humor. Late 80s. Was pull over for no shellfish lic. with half a bucket of clams. I said, "not mine the dog got them". He didn't believe me, so sent my lab out. She dug around with front feet,found one, drove down & brought it out. He said, OK?! & let us go!
Great job, my brother. All
Donald Bagnall Seymour, CTGreat job, my brother. All good things must transition to other good things. You gave it your all and many have benefited from your knowledge. Stay out of the hot sun :)
Over the years a real asset
M Kelly Turners FallsOver the years a real asset to the town. Very helpful and willing to educate any novice. He assisted many in making shellfishing enjoyable. Enjoy retirement Capt. Shellfish!
A friend since 1980. X had no
Mark Hufe ProbidenceA friend since 1980. X had no pretensions, just committed to doing a good job for the town and helping amateurs and professionals alike with all things shellfish.
Thank you, Paul, for your
Kathi Mettler Fairfield, CTThank you, Paul, for your many years of service and congratulations on your retirement.
Great job, Paul!
M Neuhoff West TisburyGreat job, Paul!
Hats off to you, from Edgartown to West Tisbury!
Add new comment