Former Peltz family property abuts town-owned beach at Lambert's Cove in West Tisbury.
Mark Alan Lovewell

Land Bank Buys North Shore Property in West Tisbury for $3.8 Million

A property fronting James Pond and Vineyard Sound is the latest purchase by the Martha’s Vineyard Land Bank in what is shaping up to be an active year for the public conservation organization.

A north shore West Tisbury property fronting James Pond and Vineyard Sound is the latest purchase by the Martha’s Vineyard Land Bank in what is shaping up to be an active year for the Island’s public conservation organization.

Property includes frontage on James Pond.
Mark Alan Lovewell
Property includes frontage on James Pond.
Mark Alan Lovewell

The land bank announced Thursday that it had bought 6.8 acres in West Tisbury for $3.88 million. The seller is Sandhurst MV, a limited liability company that had bought the property from the former owners, the Peltz family. The hourglass-shaped parcel includes 330 feet of white sand beach fronting Vineyard Sound, abutting the town-owned Lambert’s Cove Beach, and another 390 feet along the eastern side of James Pond, opposite the former Mohu estate of Katharine Graham.

The land bank announced the purchase on its Facebook page Thursday morning. West Tisbury selectmen were informed about the purchase at their meeting late Wednesday afternoon.

The property is currently closed while the land bank studies it and prepares a management plan, according to its usual practice. Expected to be open to the public by the summer of 2022, it will be known as the James Pond Preserve.

“We always close a [new] property and study it for a year,” land bank executive director James Lengyel told the Gazette by phone Thursday morning.

“We want to make sure we do a full species inventory, and get the lay of the land,” he said.

Eventual plans call for opening the property and beachfront to the public, Mr. Lengyel said.

Graham Smith
Graham Smith

The property includes grassland along the pond and a high dune with long views of Vineyard Sound and the Elizabeth Islands. Mr. Lengyel said a small part of the property is wooded.

The land also contains a large house and several smaller buildings, all of which are destined to be removed unless the land bank decides to keep one of the outbuildings as a caretaker’s cottage.

“The land bank’s goal is to un-develop and re-naturalize the property,” Mr. Lengyel said.

Part of the current plan for the new preserve is to allow some parking for hikers and beachgoers. The attraction of the saltwater beach makes it likely the land bank will use a timed reservation system, as it did this summer at the Manaquayak property that includes Ice House Pond, Mr. Lengyel said.

But before any management plan is finalized, the land bank will bring it to the public, including neighboring property owners and the town, for comment, he said.

“We want to make sure our use complements the neighborhood,” Mr. Lengyel said.

Land bank plans to open public access to the beach in 2022.
Mark Alan Lovewell
Land bank plans to open public access to the beach in 2022.
Mark Alan Lovewell

The likely time frame for airing the draft management plan is February or March of 2022, he said.

The property had gone on the market for sale, Mr. Lengyel said.

The purchase marks the third major acquisition for the land bank this year. Funded by a two percent fee on most arm’s length real estate transactions, the land bank has seen its coffers grow with the recent real estate boom. Last week alone the land bank collected nearly $1 million in revenues.

In September the land bank and Sheriff’s Meadow Foundation announced they would buy 304 acres of undeveloped land at Red Gate Farm, the historic, ecologically rare oceanfront estate in Aquinnah owned by the family of Caroline B. Kennedy.

Due to close at the end of the year, it is the largest conservation purchase on the Vineyard in recent memory.

The total purchase price is $27 million, with the land bank contributing $15 million to the purchase, while Sheriff’s Meadow will contribute $12 million.

In late October the land bank bought scenic Arrowhead Farm in West Tisbury with a plan to preserve the iconic property as a working farm in perpetuity.

The land bank paid $4.43 million for the 33-acre property; the owners Robert and Charlene Douglas will retain a life estate on the property as part of the terms of sale.

The land bank eventually plans to return the horse farm and equestrian center nestled at the crook of scenic Indian Hill Road to active agriculture with a tenant farmer.

Last month the lank bank joined with the Island Autism Group to buy the 17.5-acre former Child farm off Lambert’s Cove Road for $1.2 million. Part of the property will become open space, and part will developed into a residence for people with autism.

The land bank was created in 1986 by an act of the state legislature.

Comments

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 12/03/2020 - 17:20

Permalink

Mark Edgartown

Great year for the Land Bank, so appreciative of all the awesome work that they do for our island.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 12/03/2020 - 17:35

Permalink

Vasha Brunelle Vineyard Haven

Thank you Land bank for making such an interesting piece of our Island available for anyone to explore and enjoy.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 12/03/2020 - 17:57

Permalink

Nettie Kent Ruel Chilmark

What about keeping the homes already on the site for affordable housing? Why tear down buildings when this real estate boom has turned the housing crisis into a housing apocalypse for those of us year round families trying to stay here at our home.
I appreciate what the land bank does and enjoy the trails, but we need housing and we need it desperately.

Martha Klein Edgartown

Agreed. I don't understand why a portion of the Landbank Tax can't be allocated to the Island Housing Trust. Perhaps the Landbank could partner with IHT and they could work together to figure out how to preserve and protect not just the island, but Islanders....

Nis Kildegaard Edgartown

In fact, the Land Bank does partner, and has partnered actively and creatively with affordable housing agencies here since 1991. If you navigate to the LB website and click the affordable housing link in the left column you can read the LB policy which has resulted in important affordable housing projects in every Island town. The folks at IHT will be happy to tell you that the Land Bank has been one of the most positive forces for affordable housing ever to come down the pike in recent Vineyard history. They don't get nearly the credit they deserve on this front! (link is here: http://mvlandbank.com/documents/20190612101539846.pdf)

T Bone Oak Bluffs

It's not the Land Bank's job to solve the affordable housing crisis. Their role is to preserve land/return it to original condition, and they do it very well. Why don't you help/get involved with solving the housing crisis instead of telling others to do it?

Nettie Kent Ruel Chilmark

"T Bone"
I know what the role of the land bank is and I know they have sometimes worked with affordable housing. I'm not "telling others" to do anything, I am just sounding the alarm, who will be left to enjoy all this "preserved land" when local islanders can no longer afford a home here to raise their families?
And please don't make assumptions about my civic duties and involvement in the housing crisis, since I don't hide behind a fake name please feel free to reach out and ask me, my name is right there.

T Bone Oak Bluffs

Ms. Ruel, my many friends on the Island have called me T Bone for decades. If you don't know who I am that's not my problem, plenty of others do. My point is let the Land Bank keep preserving land on our island. They are good at that mission. Over development is a deep concern of mine. There are plenty of other fine organizations trying to deal with affordable housing issues. Don't add those issues to the Land Bank's primary mission. I wouldn't ask the food bank to address addiction issues.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 12/03/2020 - 18:21

Permalink

TisKid VH

It's a win for the End Beach Apartheid guy....pending the public comments. This is exciting.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 12/03/2020 - 18:44

Permalink

gina Menemsha/NYC

Money well spent IMO. resulting in more public access.. Not knowing what condition the existing structures are can't comment on their usefulness.. but affordable housing isn't part of the LandBank agenda.. Many other Island agencies working on that ..

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 12/03/2020 - 19:19

Permalink

Mary Edgartown

This is great news!!! It always upsetting that Chilmark can close its beaches to the public.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 12/03/2020 - 19:36

Permalink

Enough

How many more millions are the land bank going to spend while their are families that are homeless due to lack of affordable house. Over $20 million spent this year when people are going to food banks for their next meal. It is sickening.

L Edgartown

The Land Bank is funded through MV house sales. Home buyers (except for first-time buyers) are required to pay 2% of the total house sale to Land Bank. So perhaps it is time better spent to appeal to the multi-million dollar homebuyers to financially support food equity organizations or housing organizations rather than attack MV Land Bank for doing what they were chartered to do: use the money that comes to them through house sales to conserve land and make it accessible to all.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 12/03/2020 - 20:19

Permalink

George Stein Oak Bluffs

Building a parking lot is top of the list. Unless you are doing construction no way this is housing spot. Rent the homes for $5k weekly to generate covering maintenance costs. When are caretaker resumes being taken ?

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 12/03/2020 - 22:41

Permalink

Island Family Vineyard Haven

Hallelujah! We don’t have to feel like second class next door neighbors anymore. We will pack our lunch box and blankets at 9:00 and see our friends from West Tisbury at the beach when the sun is shining. We will go swimming at noon and not wait til 5:00. Must have been an interesting meeting up in West Tisbury. How long has Land Bank been waiting to solve this? I vote the gentleman who kept “end beach apartheid” in all our minds (like it was actually a possibility) gets the Caretaker’s cottage.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 12/04/2020 - 08:04

Permalink

Lupe Edgartown

Thank you to the Land Bank for preserving nature sites. Too much construction is diminish the green spirit of the island. The island needs to maintain its beauty!

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 12/04/2020 - 08:44

Permalink

fact checker edg nyc area

thanks to the rich summer people willing to pay inflated property prices for real estate the land bank is flush with cash.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 12/04/2020 - 08:48

Permalink

Bob Edgartown

According to this article the Land Bank has been involved intaking over 360 acres of land off the tax roles of MV this year alone. At some point the towns will start to suffer from the loss of all that revenue. Using the purchase price as a guide the island has lost over $150,000 of tax revenue every year for ever on these few properties. That money is never coming back. The Land Bank does some good but does not give back enough and smarter people than I need to see how we fix this monster we created. Time to start the process of going to the State House and adjusting the rules they have to follow.

Mark Edgartown

You're missing the most important part of the tax equation, property values...assessed value in Edgartown is over $10bn and nominal tax rates declined in 2020.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 12/04/2020 - 08:58

Permalink

Aron WT

I am an abutter, and while I adore that Lambert's Cove is so quiet compared to other beaches, this purchase fills me with joy.

Thank you for doing such wonderful things, Land Bank!

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 12/04/2020 - 11:53

Permalink

Nancy Vineyard Haven

This seems like a great opportunity to resolve the existing parking problems at Lambert's Cove beach. I hope the Landbank will consider building more parking than they normally do. This would greatly benefit the neighbors in that area and return the streetscape along Lambert's Cove Road to the two lane country road it once was.

Mvgirl West Tisbury

Nancy, I don’t think they could build enough parking to take care of that issue. The amount of cars parked up the road was staggering. People trespassed on our property all summer and continue to do so. Hopefully, the creation of public access will slow this trend.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 12/04/2020 - 12:52

Permalink

Wendy wolf Chilmark

It is my hope that the land bank can work with the island housing trust to ensure some land is carved off for affordable housing.

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.