Old Whaling Church to Serve as Homeless Shelter This Winter

The Old Whaling Church in Edgartown has been secured as a temporary winter shelter for homeless individuals, Martha’s Vineyard Hospital officials announced Wednesday.

The Old Whaling Church in Edgartown has been secured as a temporary winter shelter for homeless individuals, Martha’s Vineyard Hospital officials announced Wednesday, capping a months-long, multi-agency scramble to find a Covid-safe shelter facility in the wake of the pandemic.

At a press briefing Wednesday morning, hospital president and CEO Denise Schepici said Harbor Homes of Martha’s Vineyard — the Island’s homelessness advocacy organization — had partnered with the Whaling Church to secure the space, easing concerns that that Island’s small but increasingly fragile homeless population would have a warm place to stay this offseason.

Houses of Grace — the Island’s only winter shelter program — was forced to shut down due to the pandemic last year, leaving the approximately two dozen homeless individuals who rely on a patchwork of churches for winter shelter in limbo.

In an email to the Gazette Wednesday Karen Tewhey, executive director of Harbor Homes, said no lease had been signed yet for the use of the church. “Still looking into our options. We are looking for overnight staff to start up the program,” Ms. Tewhey wrote.

But Edgartown town administrator James Hagerty knew about the plan and said he had suggested suggested the use of the church to homelessness advocates after other options, like the town’s council on aging building, proved complicated.

Speaking to the Gazette by phone Wednesday, Mr. Hagerty said the use of the church as a shelter does not need any specific town approvals, but that it likely has to follow existing board of health regulations.

The church is owned by the nonprofit Vineyard Trust. Vineyard Trust executive director Funi Burdick was out of the office Wednesday and not immediately available for comment.

Multiple organizations, including the hospital and Harbor Homes, as well as the Rev. Chip Seadale, who runs the Houses of Grace program, had worked tirelessly over the past two months to secure a facility, or multiple facilities, that could fill in for church shelters forced to shut down due to Covid-19 safety restrictions. While the organizations raised more than $250,000, including a $150,000 grant from the hospital as well as large private donations to pay for staffing, PPE and other expenses, the search for a facility remained fruitless until this week.

Original ideas included multiple smaller buildings, fire stations, or funding for hotel rooms — although hotels can only service certain segments of the Island’s homeless community.

But with the Whaling Church likely secured, Ms. Schepici breathed a sigh of relief at the press briefing on Wednesday.

“It is exciting,” Ms. Schepici said. “It is getting cold, as you know, and it wasn’t coming together as quickly as we would have hoped. But this is great.”

Final approvals for the church’s use as a shelter are expected soon, Ms. Schepici said, adding that with a space secured, the organizations would now look to staffing needs.

“Many, many thanks to harbor homes for securing the Whaling Church, and for the Whaling Church for offering that space,” Ms. Schepici said. “Now that a space has been identified, there is a need for paid staff and volunteers, for anyone who is interested.”

The large, historic church, which is located on Edgartown’s Main street and is heated during the winter, will likely be open 24 hours a day and provide enough space for approximately 13 to 14 individuals per night, Ms. Schepici said. Houses of Grace, which operated from Jan. 1 through March 31, averaged around 10 individuals per night, according to Ms. Schepici.

The pandemic also forced the closure of the Island’s winter warming shelter — a need that the Whaling Church could fulfill as well. The building contains a 470-seat sanctuary filled with pews, as well as a large lower level that includes a commercial-grade kitchen.

Dating to 1843, the Old Whaling Church has served as a sanctuary over the course of its 170 years, housing everyone from lost seafarers to parishioners, hosting religious services, potlucks, piano concerts, weddings, town meetings, lectures and more. The iconic Greek Revival building was given to the Vineyard Preservation Trust, now the Vineyard Trust, in 1980. The town of Edgartown owns the clock and clock tower that sit atop the church.

Ms. Schepici offered her thanks that the church would be able to service a new population of Islanders on Wednesday.

“This all happened because of the generosity of the Island, and all involved,” she said.

Comments

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 11/06/2020 - 06:07

Permalink

Charlie Callahan So Boston/Edgartown

Whats wrong with the agricultural hall. Temporary heaters could be installed along with showers and toilets. They have cooking facilities and the rules could be skirted in the case of this covid. Rules are always skirted on this island for the right people. And if enough muffies and buffies opened their wallets it could be done real fast.I'm sure the Nat'l guard or the army would donate cots blankets and other necessities.If those at the top really cared this could be done in a matter of weeks.I would be happy to volunteer to help set things up.

Christine VH

Wow Chuck, Muffies & Buffies? Really? Maybe while your up in Southie you can ask some Jimmy & Johnnies to unvelcro their wallets too? If Edgartown is generous enough to provide a warm safe place let them.

Lorraine Edgartown

Charlie, I agree with you. When I first read the article I knew I wanted to think on it...right, showers, toileting, cooking and a more central location. That seems better than the O W C......are we muddying the entities that are set up for each building? Do all the homeless come from the entire island? surely not just Edgartown village? It seems to me a central location is much better for this.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 11/06/2020 - 08:38

Permalink

Elizabeth Edgartown

I feel compassion for people who lack housing this winter, truly. However, the Martha's Vineyard Preservation Trust is a 501c3 whose mission is to preserve historic structures and who collects donations from the public for this purpose. When get MVPT into the business of providing housing and meals to the homeless? For the record, I give money to charities who do both - and they have different Articles of Incorporation.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 11/06/2020 - 08:49

Permalink

Joseph edgartown

This is a poor use of an MV treasure. Of course I feel for the homeless but, if I were homeless, I would not seek shelter on an Island where there is an acute housing shortage. Between running a homeless shelter and introducing a recreational marijuana store in Edgartown, we are changing the tone of the town and the Island whether or not we realize it.

In the midst of the pandemic in NY, in the middle of winter, the Army Corps. of Engineers set up working shelters to house sick people. Since the hospital's leadership is such an advocate for the homeless, why not house the homeless on the hospital's grounds? They have the space. And doesn't it make sense to place the homeless closer to medical facilities since the homeless population is often in greater need of this care?

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 11/06/2020 - 10:57

Permalink

Dennis McAndrews Wayne Pa,

God bless all those who are working so hard to meet these challenging needs They need our support and gratitude.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 11/06/2020 - 15:12

Permalink

Nora Oak Bluffs

Well godbless there are kind people who care for the less fortunate. They really make a difference.. Caring for others

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 11/06/2020 - 15:37

Permalink

Carla A Cooper

What a sad commentary on our society when people are complaining that a church is being used to help out our fellow man during a global pandemic. Shameful.

Steve Vineyard Haven

This building WAS a church. It is now a historic property managed by the Vineyard Trust which is a non profit dedicated to historic preservation - NOT management of homeless populations. Public and private funds support these non profits which enjoy tax free status. Non profit funds should be used for the purposes intended, or else pay taxes like the rest of us. As a donor to Vineyard Trust, I was told that I would be supporting historic preservation, not the use of landmark properties to house the homeless. I imagine that I am not alone in this sentiment.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sun, 11/08/2020 - 22:03

Permalink

John Edgartown

It is difficult for me to understand the comments that seem to be opposed to the generous offer from the Vineyard Trust. The location seems perfect since it is located right next to the Church Street bus stops, meaning easy access from all over the Island. The space is ideal since it is already heated, has a kitchen as well as two bathrooms.
It will be used when it is not being used for any other purpose during this COVID winter. I also am a donor to the Vineyard Trust and am proud of them stepping forward to address a pressing need on the Island. The whole issue of being a 501C3 is a red herring since as I understand things the Hopital and other funders are covering the costs and not the Trust.
The whole relationship sounds like a win-win to me.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Mon, 11/09/2020 - 08:50

Permalink

Susan of OB West Hartford

Humanity where are you? To the comments made by those who are concerned with the tax implications, vs. the reality of homelessness on the island -- the location, with public bus service access, is central. Kudos to those who thought outside-the-box and will make a positive difference in the lives of those others.....as too many of us are just one illness, one loss of income away from the need for shelter.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 11/12/2020 - 12:33

Permalink

Audrey Loggia Los Angeles ( formerly Edgartown)

Bravo John ( Edgartown) ... Beautifully said... Unfortunately, there will always be narrow-minded, selfish and self-serving people in the world . What ever happened to ... “there but for the Grace of God”...

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.