Calling it a “bitter pill” to swallow, Steamship Authority governors said Tuesday they would back an operating budget for the coming year that will include across-the board rate hikes.
Calling it a “bitter pill” to swallow, Steamship Authority governors said Tuesday they would back an operating budget for the coming year that will include across-the board rate hikes.
“It is what it is,” Nantucket governor Rob Ranney said after senior managers presented the proposed $112 million operating budget.
A formal vote on the budget is expected next month.
Meanwhile, with traffic numbers showing improvement month by month, SSA general manager Bob Davis painted a much rosier picture of formerly dismal year-end revenue projections, hinting that the ferry line may not even need to request state aid as previously planned.
The projected deficit for this year — pegged early in the season at around $60 million — is now closer to $10 to $12 million, boat line treasurer Mark Rozum estimated. The reason is increasingly strong traffic numbers, Mr. Davis said.
“If traffic continues to hold up the remainder of the year, there is a possibility that the state would not have to be covering any deficit,” he said.
But with the coronavirus pandemic still affecting travel, substantial unknowns remain regarding the boat line’s financial future, officials said. At the monthly board meeting Tuesday, Mr. Rozum and Mr. Davis explained the rationale behind the proposed 2021 operating budget, saying they expected car traffic to normalize to its pre-pandemic levels and passenger traffic to sit at 90 per cent of regular numbers. The expected decline in passenger traffic would necessitate an approximately 7 per cent rate adjustment, leading to the substantial fare hikes in every category.
“No surprise, the Covid-19 is playing a significant role in our forecast for 2021,” Mr. Rozum said.
After traffic crashed in April and May, automobile traffic has either reached or exceeded pre-pandemic levels in recent months. Passenger traffic continues to lag slightly, sitting at about 85 per cent of its normal levels in September.
The rate adjustments would mainly be felt in summer peak vehicle pricing, with $15 one-way increases. But there are also proposed rate increases for normal vehicle fares, as high as $6 one-way, and passengers.
Governors posed questions to senior managers regarding the methodology, but in general accepted the rate increases with a mix of deference and understanding.
“You’ve done a nice job pulling this whole thing together,” Barnstable governor Bob Jones said. “We’re really kind of locked in with our fixed costs . . . I think we’re just caught between a rock and a hard place.”
Vineyard governor James Malkin agreed, saying that the varied unknowns caused by the virus made conservative budgeting necessary.
“People want to get back and forth, and are using the boats. The day trippers are not. And if we’re going to keep things running for the people who need to get on and off, and the goods and services that need to get on and off, we have to do what we can to keep the boats running and we can’t stop maintaining them,” Mr. Malkin said. “This is, unfortunately or sadly, the only reasonable and sound, prudent way to deal with it.”
SSA spokesman Sean Driscoll said public forums will be scheduled to discuss the rate adjustments in anticipation of a vote to approve the 2021 operating budget at the November board meeting.
Looking at revenue and traffic numbers for 2020, SSA managers said springtime fear of a massive budget shortfall appears to have been averted.
Under the SSA enabling legislation, taxpayers in the five port communities can be assessed in the event of an operating deficit. But in light of the pandemic, earlier in the summer the state legislature approved an amendment to the state budget that would temporarily shift the burden of any operating deficit onto the state on a one-time basis.
Four months later, and ferry traffic — particularly vehicle traffic — has rebounded steadily, buoying the boat line with a strong late summer and fall and potentially rendering state aid unnecessary. If the deficit is small enough, Mr. Davis said it could be offset by an influx of approximately $10 million in federal CARES Act money that the boat line received early on in the pandemic.
The SSA also secured a $10 million line of credit from MV Bank that it has not yet used.
September saw a 15 per cent increase in vehicle revenues, Mr. Rozum said, while October has seen a 39 per cent increase over projections. Even passenger traffic has matched projections in October, and bookings for November are on pace with projections, Mr. Rozum said.
“Right now, I think we still would be in a position where the state would need to come up with a portion of this,” Mr. Davis said. “But the hope is that things continue to improve here and that we’re able to avoid that situation.”
In other business Tuesday, governors heard updates on a variety of vessel maintenance, dry dock and capital improvement projects.
The Oak Bluffs terminal is scheduled to close Wednesday, after which phase two will begin on a series of wharf repairs, including piling replacement.
A report from a consulting company found that the Thomas B. Landers lot in Falmouth could work as a site for a solar array. The SSA could rent the space for between $175,000 and $350,000 and generate nine megawatts of energy, the consultants said. Mr. Davis had requested the proposal.
The board also licensed the SeaStreak fast ferry to provide inter-Island on Thursdays, Fridays and weekends through Jan. 3, 2021, running from New Bedford to Oak Bluffs to Nantucket.
Mr. Davis began the meeting with a moment of silence for former Barnstable governor Bob O’Brien, who died last month. Mr. O’Brien had served on the board for 30 years and overseen the construction of at least four new ferries, as well as a new Hyannis terminal.
“The list of projects that were undertaken during his tenure is staggering,” Mr. Davis said. “It’s not an exaggeration to say that the Steamship Authority would not be the organization is today if it wasn’t for Bob’s guidance and oversight.”

Comments
So they opted out of bailout.
Gabrielle West TisburySo they opted out of bailout...gotta wonder if the "gift" came with oversight?
Wow... way to screw the
Local West tisburyWow... way to screw the people that support this island by living here year round.... this Island doesn't have resources to support us.... getting off island is some times necessary not luxury
Dense fog... Can't see 100
Frank Brunelle Vineyard HavenDense fog... Can't see 100 feet.
The fog that surrounds the island appears to have entered the brains of the boat line board. What is happening is a steep increase in fares for all islanders due to the budget deficit. This deficit is the result of changing the operating mandate from serving the island to increasing tourism and hence all new boats are maximized for tourism purposes requiring increased fuel, maintenance, and employee costs - all due to changing its operating mission.
All well and good if islanders are still kept as the primary reason for the Steamship Authority but we are not. We are hit two ways. The port towns are STILL on the line for any deficits and this means that aside from fare increases affecting everyone that Vineyard Haven and Oak Bluffs could still see their real estate taxes increase to support tourism for all of the Island and for the world who come to our door via the SSA.
That this is so patently wrong is not seen as a problem by the boat line board including our member. This is more of the same old same old we hoped a new member would change. Has the fog of the island entered into all of the board once again?
No mention of cutting the
R Scott Patterson EdgartownNo mention of cutting the budget. Just pile more costs on us. Typical.
Why would you avoid taking
fact checker edgWhy would you avoid taking state money? Take it and skip the rate increases. MV sends WAY more money from all kinds of taxes to Beacon Hill than we get back. MV is a CASH COW for the politicians in Boston and we get VERY little back.
The State money was approved
JOHN Cape CodThe State money was approved as a one time event only to cover the operating deficit due too the pandemic. This was enacted by State government so the port towns would not be responsible to pay it as mandated by the charter. It's not a blank check to subsidize the regular operation of the SSA as it solely relies on revenue generated by those who use it. Over the past decades MV has become a commercialized / overdeveloped / heavily marketed tourist destination and the service needed to support the Island is vastly different than 10 - 20 years ago.
Fare hikes in the end will
Nat Trumbull Woods HoleFare hikes in the end will have to pay for the ballooning costs of the Woods Hole terminal reconstruction. An example. The first glass/map canopy at WH Terminal cost at least $2.2 million. This glass/map canopy appears to have cost 10 times more than the traditional wooden canopies at Vineyard Haven Terminal. Aesthetics aside, the traditional canopies at Vineyard Haven Terminal seem more functional. The cantilevered glass of the new canopy in WH as protection for passengers from the elements is a question mark. The glass canopy leaks rain down the canopy's concrete columns at the moment. Another full glass/map canopy and a half are still to come to WH Terminal. The WH terminal building construction has not yet begun.
Just sold my house in WT.
Mark West TisburyJust sold my house in WT. Paying $230 to drive my car to my vacation house was one reason. How much will it cost in 5 years? $500?
Amen!
Robby K Oak BluffsAmen!
Competition, folks, that is
Lorraine EdgartownCompetition, folks, that is the remedy. Always works, the rate payer is the winner.
the WH terminal is a money
Islanddog Edgartownthe WH terminal is a money sucking project, too bad I don't have any investments in that project.
Is anyone surprised they are raising the rates AGAIN? We just have take the abuse they dish out or move off island.
I can appreciate the SSA
Robby K Oak BluffsI can appreciate the SSA looking at employee labor agreements and then saying we need this much to cover, and have a small contingency fund in place. I do strongly object a rate increase. Because I own a home on island, and I love to spend time on the island, probably close to 3-4 months per year, I use the SSA a lot. However, because my car is not registered on island, that trip to my home will now cost me $230. I don't get a discount, preferred rate, NOTHING. Please SSA, consider a change to let out of state homeowners have ONE car that can get a discount. You're pricing us out of our own homes.
This is a great point,
Mark EdgartownThis is a great point, seasonal home owners are critical to the infrastructure of the island given the massive tax subsidy they provide. They should be entitled to the same benefits as year round residents.
I agree on the idea to
Mike Vineyard HavenI agree on the idea to provide seasonal homeowners with a discount on one vehicle. Seems like a good idea considering we pay a lot of taxes and use few services the balance of the year.
We've never seen more
Katie Oak BluffsWe've never seen more visitors than this summer, the steamship increased the reseveration only weekends from May - through mid Cctober which caused massive challenges getting off in the "offseason" only to find that after waitlisting (sometimes multiple times) the boats that were "full" were not. Now increases.
While public opinion "welcome" in Nov - can anyone share a time when they were actually put into account. The Board has made their decision it won't matter what the public says. Discouraged and disenchanted with the SSA that touts the "lifeline" that is no life support for islanders.
Add new comment