Island restaurant and hotel owners reacted with frustration Monday after Gov. Charlie Baker announced his ultra-slow reopening plan for the commonwealth.
Island restaurant and hotel owners reacted with frustration Monday after Gov. Charlie Baker announced his ultra-slow reopening plan for the commonwealth, with many worrying about having to stay closed for the Memorial Day weekend and wondering when they would receive more guidance from the state.
With a statewide stay-at-home order set to expire at midnight, the governor outlined the first baby steps of a slow, phased reopening process for the state Monday, as coronavirus cases begin to see declines.
On the Island cases remained steady.
“We’re playing this game, and it’s a real one, with the virus and the economy at the same time,” Governor Baker said at a much-anticipated press briefing Monday. “And it’s really important for people to step up, and recognize, and understand that this game is not over.”
Striking a cautious tone, Governor Baker said starting Monday, manufacturing facilities, construction and houses of worship would be allowed to reopen immediately, with severe restrictions. But most non-essential businesses will stay shuttered until at least May 25 or later, leaving question marks for Island restaurants and hotels as Memorial Day weekend fast approaches.
Some business owners on the Vineyard expressed dismay and disappointment, including Michael Santoro, an Oak Bluffs selectman who owns the Lookout Tavern and Fishbones restaurants in Oak Bluffs, as well as The Net Result in Vineyard Haven. Mr. Santoro described the governor’s plan as “beating around the bush” and said he wished the governor had released guidelines keeping restaurants and hotels closed earlier in the month.
“I’m very disappointed,” Mr. Santoro said. “I know what he [the governor] is doing. He’s doing this to prevent people from coming to the resort areas for Memorial Day weekend. And I get it. But I’d rather him be up front and say that instead of this.”
He said it would be difficult to plan for the coming weeks without any sense of how the governor planned to limit capacity at restaurants and allow for outdoor seating, or other restrictions regarding phase two businesses.
Diane Carr, general manager at the boutique Hob Knob Inn in Edgartown, said she was happy that hotels were included in the second phase of the reopening rather than the third phase, but echoed Mr. Santoro’s feelings of confusion about the guidelines, especially with the start of summer approaching. Ms. Carr also serves on the Edgartown board of trade.
“Memorial Day is a big weekend. We are usually full,” Ms. Carr said. “I feel badly for all of us in that boat, because we don’t know anything. We really don’t know more than ‘you’re going to find out soon.’ And that’s it.”
According to the four-phase plan the governor detailed Monday, retailers will be allowed to open for curbside service starting May 25. Hairdressers and salons, as well as car washes, will be allowed to reopen as well, with appointment-only service following strict social distancing protocols. Enforcement of the regulations is left to local boards of health and health agents.
But the opening of restaurants, lodging and hospitality businesses, nail salons and day spas, as well as camp grounds and youth sports, will all have to wait until the second phase of the reopening — meaning many businesses on the Island will remain closed come Memorial Day and beyond. Governor Baker said each phase of the reopening would last for a minimum of three weeks, and it could be longer depending on public health data and hospitalization metrics.
“With respect to the time frame around this . . . that is going to be a function of the data,” Governor Baker said. “The move to a next phase is going to be a function of a review of how we’re doing in the phase that we are in.”
Massachusetts has been one the hardest-hit states in the country with Covid-19, ranking third in the top five states for the number of confirmed cases per population size, behind New York and New Jersey and ahead of Illinois and Michigan.
In one week, office spaces will be allowed to open at 25 per cent capacity, and hospitals were given the green light to provide preventative care, pediatric care and treatment for high risk patients effective immediately. Officials at the Martha’s Vineyard Hospital previously described their plans to re-open certain parts of the facility by June 1.
The first phase of the plan also offers guidance on beaches, parks and other outdoor recreation throughout the state. Beaches are allowed to open immediately, but ball games are banned and all beachgoers must maintain a 12-foot distance between parties. On the Vineyard up-Island beaches, such as Lucy Vincent, Philbin and Lambert’s Cove, have already limited parking. Other non-contact athletic complexes, like tennis courts, are allowed to open, as long as there is no shared equipment.
The state stay-at-home advisory has been rebranded as a safer-at-home advisory. Governor Baker described the differences as basically semantic, with the recommended regulations and guidance for the state remaining largely the same. Gatherings are still limited to 10 people or less, and people over 65 years of age are still encouraged to stay at home unless shopping for groceries or receiving necessary medical treatments.
“This is something no one has ever done before — shutter, and then reopen everything,” the governor said. “I ask everyone to keep this in mind.”
On Monday the Vineyard entered the second phase of its relaxation of construction guidelines on Monday, allowing 10-person crews to work on jobsites. Island towns had instituted a stricter version of the governor’s non-essential business closure in early April that put a stoppage on all construction work. Towns have slowly phased in work over the past month, allowing first for two-man crews, then five-man crews, and now the most recent 10-man crews.
At the Edgartown selectman’s meeting later Monday afternoon, town administrator James Hagerty said the governor’s reopening plan left many question marks for local businesses, especially those on Main street.
He also said the town hall wouldn’t be open to the public anytime soon.
“A lot of moving parts after the governor released his plan earlier today,” Mr. Hagerty said.
“I think every town is still trying to digest it.”
Meanwhile, the hospital and Island boards of health reported no new cases on the Island Monday. The hospital has tested 685 people for the virus since the outbreak began, with 25 positives, 659 negatives and one pending. The total case count Islandwide is 31, with 27 laboratory confirmed cases (two from testing off-Island) and four presumed positives as a result of antibody tests.
No one is currently hospitalized with the virus.
Home page picture, Coop de Ville, by Albert O. Fischer.

Comments
What a disaster!
Shelley EdgartownWhat a disaster!
Death is a disaster. This
Tony EdgartownDeath is a disaster. This going slow approach to re-opening is not.
Judging by compliance with
ZephyrJudging by compliance with existing regulations I don't expect these "severe restrictions" to be observed by most. I don't think I've yet seen a work crew at any construction site fully compliant to my casual observations--there are always people working unmasked, multiple people in work trucks, etc. Same on the trails, parking lots, beaches, you name it. Half the public goes unmasked, lets their dogs run off leash, etc. A lot of people have no visible mask around their necks or in their hands, so apparently they are not even prepared if they come face to face with someone.
Agree, this new reopening
Concerned resident EdgartownAgree, this new reopening phase will not change much of how things are already looking. Most construction sites I’ve seen, no one is wearing masks or following social distancing. I have noticed a lot of summer residents riding bikes and walking through town in big groups with no masks or sitting out on the beach in big groups with their dogs unleashed. Unfortunately, people are just going to do what they want no matter what the governor says, especially when everyone is coming for the summer.
Concerned Citizen, our
Sarah EdgartownConcerned Citizen, our primary home is in Edgartown but I have a small place near the Boston hospital where I work. My husband’s businesses are on the island, and I am
NOT sure if you live on a different planet than me but here goes: I have to wear a mask at work 24/7, everyone I see in Boston has on a mask, when I was “last” (2 weeks ago) in Edgartown at Stop & Shop - I was proud to note all wearing masks. I DO NOT see unleashed dogs Running amuck and don’t the majority of construction workers reside on OUR island???. Get over “your island v. the intruder’s” island. Trust me, when you come to MY hospital, we treat you regardless of your residence with care and dignity. And let’s also think about the plight of OUR small and ALL MV businesses. If YOU see individuals not social distancing - kindly say something and that goes for the masks too.. Complacency will get you no where and your attitude of blaming summer residents WILL bankrupt this island. See something - say something. And be kind! We have 40 therapeutics in clinical trials (the holy grail), we are working tirelessly on a vaccine - it will come! But this underlying finger pointing and ME, ME, ME attitude will linger. Perhaps you need to volunteer - put your mask and gloves on and drive for Meals on Wheels or help at the good pantry. And EVERYONE please abide these rules in support of our friends, neighbors and businesses so we remain healthy and hardworking citizens can work. Have a nice evening, citizen.
Whenever I am in a building
Mr. B ChilmarkWhenever I am in a building or approaching to enter a building, the compliance seems very good to me. Same on picking up products at take out and the like. My only concern is that some people--consciously or not--seem to feel that wearing a face covering is a substitute for social distancing. It's not. As for outdoors matters, I see less compliance though not as distressing as what you report.
Actually, under the governor
EDGActually, under the governor's statement regarding masks "...are required when you cannot MAINTAIN social distancing". This means that if you cannot stay more than 6 feet away and maintain that distance (which means not just passing by someone on the sidewalk), you have to have some sort of face covering on. They recommend the mask and 6 feet away, but in reality masks are for when social distancing is not obtainable. You do not need a mask if you are going to pass someone on the bike path, it is almost impossible to get the virus outdoors for one, and you have to be exposed longer than a simple passing in order to contract it, assuming you do not put your hands inside your mouth.
Baker is a follower, not a
Lifesaver OBBaker is a follower, not a Leader
I agree! So many dogs off
Kati EdgartownI agree! So many dogs off leash and so many people walking the trails without masks! Get your masks on....
At least in sight and make us feel as though you care!!
You don’t understand the mask
Jack EdgartownYou don’t understand the mask rule. You only need a mask if you CANT social distance. You do NOT need to wear a mask walking in the woods unless you come upon someone. And you do NOT need a mask driving in your car ALone !
I thought dogs had to be
Islander TooI thought dogs had to be leashed always---regardless of corona.
Except in certain specific situations.
I am often struck by how self-centered and clueless dog owners are regarding how annoying their pets can be to others.
It is another "broken windows" type of issue: Being blase and selfish about leashing your dog ("This rule doesn't apply to me and my good doggie!") goes with being blase and and self-centered regarding masks. Even if you personally don't think mask wearing is necessary, your fellow citizens do. So at least have it ready for when you pass others.
Sorry- the whole point of
Don Talbott EdgartownSorry- the whole point of taking a walk in the woods is that it is natural social distancing and fresh air- as long as people make room for fellow walkers and maintain adequate distance, a mask is just an unnecessary nuisance. When the dust settles and we look back, we will be able to see what was sensible precaution and what was overkill.
I'm not sure that mandating
Blake Bath ChappyI'm not sure that mandating that each phase has a 3 week minimum is prudent. Trust your local officials to do the right thing. Frustration will bubble over. That said, Vineyard officials have done a great job, and encouraged vigilance.
I don't understand the
Tash77 VHI don't understand the relationship of COVID19 spread and dogs off leash.
The City of New York recently
Tom EdgartownThe City of New York recently announced that 66% of the new Covid 19 patients were people staying at home. People who are getting crazy about this think they somehow know better than the New York City statistics show. There may be no way to avoid this. South Korea has never had a shut in policy but has preventative measures that are working. People who don’t know what they are talking about are setting arbitrary rules that are not working. It’s just dumb! Maybe Vineyarders in the future will vote for less government after we lose all kinds of small businesses. Very sad!
The 66% included a large
jhkmd EdgartownThe 66% included a large contingent of nursing home residents. By "staying at home" they meant not working or using public transportation. If you stay at home and avoid contact with outsiders, you will not get sick. If you interact with others, you may get the disease. Less government does not mean less illness.
I think the biggest issue at
Reeve Moreau TaiwanI think the biggest issue at hand will be to have mandatory monitoring of all people entering the island via airport and ssa terminals in wood hole Hyannis and Falmouth Vineyard haven and Oak bluffs . By monitoring I mean mandatory temperature taken by a health care worker monitored by police official to eliminate the entry of any infected people’s and impose mandatory quarantines at local facilities. Or cell phone tracking daily monitoring at their homes. If there is a data base of ill people available at entry terminals a forced I’d check should also be employed to quarantine Infected peoples or those in contact with such. This is no joke Taiwan is extremely close to the epecenter of the outbreak of the wuhan viirus and this country has only had a very small amount of infected people and very few deaths . This is a result of very strict entry precautions and mandatory quarantining and forced compliance of all health safety rules and a general respect of one anther . The proof is in the pudding we are a Healthy nation USA is suffering greatly and the island is at great risk unless they employ strict entry regulations and also indorse health practices . The mainland is infested and unless the utmost precautions are taken many islanders will die unnecessarily. I pray all will follow my sound advice!!!•••
Lots of people are searching
ZephyrLots of people are searching for excuses to skirt the rules. They don't wear masks because most of the time they are six feet away from others. They let their dogs off leash because their dog is so well behaved. They wear their mask below their nose because it is so uncomfortable. The same will happen with these complicated new regulations. Those of us trying to be careful to protect others have to be doubly so to make up for the other half that is reckless, and I am not optimistic once the summer season starts bringing in the crowds.
Seeing as the mask rule says
EDGSeeing as the mask rule says "when you cannot maintain social distancing", people who are 6 or more feet away from others do not need to wear a mask. Thats not skirting the rules, that's just not being ridiculous. People need to read more into the orders that come out, instead of just reading the headline.
Unfortunately, taking
Cynthia West TisburyUnfortunately, taking temperatures isn’t a very effective measure against spread of the virus. According to CDC, COVID-19 symptoms can develop anywhere between two and 14 days after exposure. That means you could have the virus and be transmitting it, but a temperature check wouldn't catch it because you have no fever yet. Also, many are asymptomatic through the entire course of their infection, yet they are still able to spread the virus.
More signage from towns and businesses outlining the mandated and recommended protocols with encouragement that we are helping each other and island businesses when we comply is one way visitors will see what MV expects from them.
My prediction is that the
Katama Bill KatamaMy prediction is that the cure is going to be far worse than the illness.
I see that hotels are in
RenterI see that hotels are in phase two, but was is the current status of short-term rentals? Is AirBNB still allowed? I can't find this information anywhere.
Short term rentals are part
ChillMarkShort term rentals are part of lodging, so also phase 2, meaning earliest availability to open will be June 8th.
Add new comment