Governor Baker Urges Second Home Owners to Stay Away from Islands
The Steamship Authority on Sunday released statistics showing a modest increase in out-of-state vehicles coming to the Vineyard in the first half of March, as Massachusetts Gov. Charlie Baker urged residents with second homes on Nantucket and Martha’s Vineyard to stay home.
The Steamship Authority on Sunday released statistics showing a modest increase in out-of-state vehicles coming to the Vineyard in the first half of March, as Massachusetts Gov. Charlie Baker urged residents with second homes on Nantucket and Martha’s Vineyard to stay home.
The preliminary figures for March 1 through March 15 show that 102 more vehicles with a New York or New Jersey address in their vehicle profile arrived on the Island than during the same period in 2019. There was a net increase of 264 more vehicles with a Massachusetts address and 21 fewer vehicles from New England states other than Massachusetts compared with last year.
The figures were released by boat line communications director Sean Driscoll Sunday afternoon, following persistent concern that the Islands have become a magnet for out-of-staters seeking refuge from the coronavirus pandemic.
Speaking to reporters in Boston, Governor Baker addressed the issue of second-home owners opting to come to both Nantucket and Martha’s Vineyard. Both Island hospitals have urged people to stay away, saying the health care system is ill-equipped to deal with a large influx of people in the off-season.
“We would prefer they not do that and that they stay on the mainland and don’t create additional issues for both of those Islands at a point in time when they don’t have the level of service capacity in place they typically would have in the summer,” Governor Baker told reporters, according to Boston news station NECN.
The statement came as Nantucket announced its first confirmed case of Covid-19. So far, only one case has been confirmed on the Vineyard, a 50-year-old Vineyard Haven homeowner. Nantucket Cottage hospital said Sunday the patient was quarantined at home, but gave no other details. A stay at home/shelter in place order has been issued for all of Nantucket, to take effect at 5 p.m. Monday and run for two weeks, through April 6.
Statewide, cases of the coronavirus continued to climb. The Massachusetts Department of Public Health reported 646 cases on Sunday, up 121 from the day before. Four more people in Massachusetts have died from the pandemic, bringing the toll to five.
On Saturday, West Tisbury and Chilmark became the first town Island towns to adopt emergency construction bans, out of concern for public health and safety. On Sunday, the Aquinnah Board of Health announced a more modest restraint on construction.
Adopted by a unanimous vote of the two town boards of selectmen and health at meetings Saturday, the emergency orders are nearly identical and effectively ban all construction activity beginning Monday and running until April 6.
Effective Monday at 9 a.m., the towns will begin the process of halting all regular activity at construction sites and all work authorized by building permits.
Construction sites must be secured and any work wrapped up by 5 p.m. Wednesday, according to the emergency orders. Only skeleton crews will be allowed after that. Emergency work will be allowed on a case-by-case basis.
The Aquinnah board of health, by contrast, said that construction sites employing five or fewer workers could proceed with no restrictions provided reasonable precautions are taken to guard against transmission of disease. Any site employing more than five workers must submit a written mitigation plan to the board of health. The policy was approved unanimously by the three members of the board of health, James Glavin, Sarah Saltonstall and Gerald Green.
The Chilmark and West Tisbury votes followed a series of meetings over the hectic past two days among town officials during the rapidly escalating emergency around the pandemic. In both towns there was broad discussion about the scope of the ban, including whether it should include landscape workers, painters and other non-permitted work. In the end it was decided that most large landscape projects are on work sites and would be shut down anyway under the construction ban.
“I’m sure the document is not perfect . . . but it shows that the town is trying to stop social interaction,” West Tisbury selectman Kent Healy said at that town's meeting, the second of the day on Saturday. “And that is the primary goal.”
Stemming disease transmission is the reason for the ban.
Signed by the selectmen and board of health members, the full emergency order is posted on the town website.
At a meeting Friday, West Tisbury health agent Omar Johnson called the decision fraught but vital.
“We are all united in this effort,” Mr. Johnson said.
Chilmark selectmen and board of health members, who also had been debating the issue for days, also took action Saturday to enact a ban in their town.
Excavating contractor John Keene pushed for including landscapers, said he had already begun layoffs at his company and suppported the ban despite the ramifications. “It is just time to stop and I say that knowing that I just shot myself in the foot,” Mr. Keene said.
Longtime Chilmark real estate broker Deborah Hancock concurred.
“I think it is awfully important that we do this,” she said. “I think it is going to hurt an awful lot of people, but it is going to hurt an awful lot more people if we don't.”
Selectman Warren Doty, who had been reluctant to support the ban out of fear for the economic repercussions, joined the vote of support in the end.
“Here we go, we're going to destroy our economy and move into a recession,” Mr. Doty said. “But what the heck, let's go.”
Enforcement of the orders will fall under a combination of the boards of health, the town building inspectors and police, town counsel Ron Rappaport said.
There has been one confirmed case of Covid-19 on the Vineyard.
The Tisbury board of health confirmed the case in a press release Friday.
Health agent Maura Valley said the patient, a 50-year-old male, is a Tisbury homeowner who is under quarantine at home and appears to be recovering. Ms. Valley said in a follow-up email that the circumstances of the virus’s transmission were unknown.
“The patient’s family and close contacts have been identified and are in self-quarantine and taking all recommended precautions,” the statement said.
Due to privacy concerns, no other identifying information will be released, the statement said.
Hours after the first confirmed case was reported on the Vineyard Friday, the screws began to tighten on the Islandwide shutdown. Using the Steamship Authority website, the Vineyard and Nantucket hospitals issued a joint statement strongly advising people — on both sides of Vineyard Sound — to stay at home and avoid travel unless absolutely necessary.
“If you come to the Island — you will only strain our limited resources, putting your life and others at risk," the statement says in part.
Signed by Denise Schepici, president and CEO of the Martha’s Vineyard Hospital, and Gary Shaw, president and CEO of the Nantucket Cottage Hospital, the statement went up on the SSA website early Friday evening.
Also Friday, the SSA announced that it would eliminate trips in response to a drop in ridership over the past two days. Schedule reductions will begin Sunday.
The hospital said it has no patients hospitalized with Covid-19.
The hospital also said it currently has adequate stock of protective masks, suits, gloves and testing equipment, but that they do not have unlimited bandwidth for virus testing or supplies.
“We have appropriate personal protection equipment (PPE) but as other hospitals are experiencing, our supplies are limited,” a spokesman said.
The hospital also noted that coronavirus testing does not require documentation of immigration status.
Around the Vineyard Saturday, an emerging new way of life was apparent. On quiet streets in downtown Edgartown walkers were out enjoying the abundnant sunshine, albeit in small groups of three or less. At Ghost Island Farm in West Tisbury, where a new outdoor ordering and pickup system had begun, cars lined up and people bought fresh greens, frozen summer tomatoes, Island meat and other provisions. Elsewhere home gardeners were outdoors puttering, and indoors sharing posts on Facebook with fellow gardeners about seed and flower swaps.
Susie Middleton and Will Sennott contributed reporting.

Comments
I think halting construction
Adria Weatherbee EdgartownI think halting construction is a bad idea. The island will die. They should be able to have a safe workaround, closed crews, no new hires and making sure your guys practice safe protocol when not on the job. Especially on an island they can't shut everything down and expect people to survive.
Island Girl refers to us as
Elizabeth Greenwich CTIsland Girl refers to us as "seasonal guests". We are not seasonal guests. Seasonal guests don't read this paper in the winter, if at all. We are homeowners, tax payers, employers, donors, dreamers and doers. And don't worry, none of us are dumb enough to "invade" YOUR island when we have options. Those of us with any decency are staying where we are. What we object to is being told that somehow our sacrifices which make us able to own a home on MV somehow just happened to us. We are tired of your obvious contempt. We work just as hard for our homes as you do. MV may or may not come back from all this.
Yes this virus we must take
Mike Oak bluffsYes this virus we must take Serious but it's hard enough living on this island in the winter and trying to survive year-round with the prices and rents and people in the landscape and tree industry will be affected just as much is all the restaurants. it's tough enough to survive. And now the lock down and of course no one's going to be spending money I've been a resident here 30 years and I've had my business for 15 years each year gets tougher and tougher with more competition. And I don't believe anybody is going to be spending money because the economy so once again I believe another company Bites the Dust and with that how do you reinvent yourself at 57 years old. Covering rent food and all the insurances needed to run a business is what's killing most of the small guys all I can say is when this is over please support the little guy trying to survive before we all disappear
These arguments are all for
Jennifer EDGThese arguments are all for naught.
Right now, second homeowners are within their rights to come to the island.
Unless and until Gov Baker or some other entity with authority issues or order or makes a statement or whatever, that travel is forbidden, people who have the desire to come will come. And it will be their right.
That’s the sad fact.
I was wondering those of you
Michael EdgartownI was wondering those of you saying that many of us can't use our homes on the Vineyard will be mailing me my rebate check for my taxes duringthe period of time you tellI me cannot use the house I own ? I think a lot of us that pay our year round taxes are not going to be too happy being told we don't count ! It sounds very xenophobic and probably not constitutional.
Newsflash – not all of us can
Al Reis EdgartownNewsflash – not all of us can do everything we want during this time. The governor, state representative, and head of the hospital have all declared that second homeowners need to stay put where they are not come here. It’s nothing personal. Some of you seasonal residents are lovely, some are not. Some of us locals are pleasant, some of us are not. Nevertheless, we are dealing with science and public health, not emotions. Please don’t drag out the “we support you with our money“ argument. We are not serfs. Yes, you play a part of the economic picture, a not insignificant one, but that does not entitle you to override common sense and public policy
Again, the comment "you
Elizabeth Greenwich CTAgain, the comment "you seasonal residents" - packed with contempt. And no one says your are "serfs" - but you must sadly see yourself this way. Most of us who pay taxes and hire people ARE NOT seasonal residents on MV anymore than we are "seasonal" anywhere. Try to understand, many of us have businesses, properties and investments in multiple locations. We are business people and, if lucky, get a couple of weeks to kick back on Island while paying your wages and funding your schools. Try to be less bias and expand your way of seeing the world and those around you.
I understand it, but people
Vicki DC and ChilmarkI understand it, but people have to stop the "pandemic shaming." We are all in this together and we are all making agonizing choices every day. Our choices reflect what is good for our family and what is good for society. Both are part of everyone's calculation, of course.
Chilmark is my home. I live on the Vineyard 9 months a year and am a full time voting resident. I am active in the community and an elected official in Chilmark. I travel in the winter to see family in NYC, DC and LA. I was in DC when this hit, making my plans to return home to Chilmark.
For now, for my own safety and in the best interests of those on the island, I have chosen to stay in DC. But please know that I am yearning to be in my Chilmark home.
Our mental health is part of our overall health. I want to come home. Don't shame me if I do.
Vicki,
Al Reis EdgartownVicki,
This is not about establishing a purity test of who and who doesn't belong here. You are a member of this community who has been separated from your rightful residence through unfortunate circumstances. You absolutely should be here. The issue concerns people with seasonal homes who are disregarding the directions of the governor, state representative, and hospital leadership to remain where they are and hauling out the money argument. This is shortsighted as it is crass. We are dealing with science and health policy here, and bringing out the age-old "We Pay Your Wages Through Our Taxes" argument at this moment is inappropriate.
Add new comment