Oak Bluffs Fire Chief Resigns

John Rose, the embattled Oak Bluffs fire chief who has been under pressure for months following allegations of misconduct, has agreed to resign.

John Rose, the embattled Oak Bluffs fire chief who has been under pressure for months following allegations of misconduct, has agreed to resign, the Oak Bluffs selectmen said in a brief statement Friday afternoon. Chief Rose will step down at the end of April, the statement said.

“Chief John Rose and the Oak Bluffs board of selectmen have mutually agreed to part ways so that the fire department and EMS services can begin their next chapter,” the statement said in part. “The town will start the process of finding a replacement in the interim.”

The fire chief’s resignation comes amid a swirl of controversy that has enveloped the town fire and ambulance department since early this year, when an FBI inquiry into ambulance finances and sexual harassment allegations against the chief came to light in the same week. Executive session meeting minutes from last summer released recently showed that selectmen were torn over whether to fire the chief after sexual harassment claims were filed by the fire department administrator who was Chief Rose’s subordinate. Eventually a settlement was reached that included a $97,000 payment to former administrator Cynthia Hatt, and no admission of wrongdoing on both sides.

The FBI inquiry into the town ambulance department’s billing practices remains ongoing.

Some current and former members of the fire and EMS departments have received subpoenas to appear before a federal grand jury this month.

In recent weeks selectmen have scrambled to contain the fallout, holding lengthy closed-door meetings, issuing tight statements, and releasing a five-point performance action plan aimed at rehabilitating the chief’s professional behavior. As public pressure continued to mount, maneuvers reached a crescendo Friday afternoon.

The statement said the town had reached a mutual separation agreement with Chief Rose that includes payment for accrued leave time, cooperation if requested, and a non-disparagement agreement. It also said the town and Mr. Rose would not comment further on the matter.

“This is a stressful time and both parties have agreed to limit their comments to this statement,” the statement said.

On Saturday, Oak Bluffs selectmen held an emergency session to meet with some the Oak Bluffs fire and EMT staff.

Chief Rose informed members of the department of his resignation in an emotional email Friday that was obtained by the Gazette.

“I have spent many years of my life growing up in this department and carry a deep respect for all the positions I held in that time and the people who helped and taught me along the way,” he wrote in part. “I know the rebuilding process may be difficult for the department in the near future but I am confident that the captains and lieutenants alongside the chiefs will carry the department in the right direction.”

The fire chief acknowledged his own 30-plus years of service, thanked the volunteers and staff, and apologized for not being able to tell them in person about his departure. He noted a deep appreciation for camaraderie of his department and described how he had come up through the ranks.

“It has been a pleasure working alongside all of you over the span of my career, from when I first started out as a volunteer firefighter in my teens, to being the captain of Engine 4, becoming an EMT/paramedic, captain of the ambulance, assistant chief and eventually the chief of the department,” he wrote. “For those of you who know me personally, you know that I put my blood, sweat, tears, heart and soul into my job.”

A longtime town employee with deep experience in firefighting and emergency response, Mr. Rose has been fire chief since 2013, when the town decided to merge the fire and EMS departments following an external review that recommended the change. Prior to that he headed the town ambulance department for a number of years and was active as an EMT.

His current salary is $131,736. He has no contract; in Oak Bluffs, the fire chief position is governed by the town personnel bylaw.

He was named permanent fire chief by the selectmen in 2014, after serving as interim chief following the resignation of former chief Peter Forend. As part of the decision, selectmen decided to promote from within over conducting an outside search for candidates on and off-Island. His promotion marked the first time the town had moved from a part-time to a full-time fire chief.

A year later, in March 2015, Mr. Rose was cited by the state ethics commission, which said he had violated conflict of interest laws by hiring and supervising four members of his family. Ultimately, the ethics commission declined to fine Mr. Rose, choosing instead to send a public letter disclosing details of what had happened and explaining requirements of the law.

In the statement issued Friday, selectmen said the chief’s resignation and retirement would be effective April 30.

“The town thanks him for his service to the town’s fire and emergency needs for the last 30 years,” the statement said.

Comments

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 01/31/2020 - 15:48

Permalink

OB FIRE-EMS OB

So he remains a liability to the town and a morale drain to the Department for 90 more days? Take his keys, change his access code, and assign his vehicle to the Deputy Chief immediately! So horribly mishandled by the Selectmen right down to the very literal end.

Me

Right!! Sad to see you go chief. Happy to be a part of the department while you were in charge. Retirement will be fantastic for you. Wishing you nothing but the best!

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 01/31/2020 - 18:21

Permalink

Ob emt Oak bluffs

If you work for the department and your attitude is this you speak for few and you should do yourself a favor and please leave. Maybe we could trade you leaving for the Chief back? I’m sure you haven’t done half as much for the community that he has. This is such a loss for the town of oak bluffs. I like how the reporting on this is so bias....sad world we live in that the headlines reads “embattled Chief” and not “Chief retired after 30 years helping saving lives and sacrifice his emotional health and mental health as a public safety official to help others” the world is so unappreciative of the good people do.

Born and Raised MVY

Bias? This guy violated about every leadership responsibility there is. It’s not a story about his retirement; it’s a story of civic abuse of power. Perhaps his 30 years should have resulted in better judgement.

Amazing

It’s over, enough with the act. Everyone in the public safety community knows who he is and what he’s done to these poor women, and his continued abuses of his powers and neglecting of his responsibilities. If you’re so disturbed by the idea of a positive change coming to the department and the prospect of it no longer being toxic, you’re free to resign as well.

Oldtimer Edgartown

Neglecting of his responsibilities? This my friend just proves your arrogance. John has a stronger work ethic than anyone I know. He is known around this Island for being a hard worker and for his devotion to his job. You’re the minority here my friend.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 01/31/2020 - 19:22

Permalink

Gabrielle West Tisbury

Disgraceful. He retires with full petition and tax payers are stuck with a bill for 90k. What a profound lack of leadership on all sides, and moral courage is severely lacking.

Oh come on now Edgartown

Do you need someone to explain this to you again? Taxpayers are not paying the settlement. The insurance company is. Outrageous that anyone has to pay a dime.

Really? Oak bluffs

As stated so many times previously, the towns insurance policy that they have for exactly this reason, and every town has, paid the bill it’s not coming out of taxpayer pockets. I’m not sure how much the premium will go up, but I can assume it won’t cost the taxpayers much. Please get your facts right before spreading misinformation.

Barry OB

I don't care who paid. It's disgusting. Sex in the Firehouse with a subordinate? Really? Leaders are judged by how they lead. This was beyond poor judgment.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 01/31/2020 - 22:19

Permalink

T Bone Oak Bluffs

I'm hopeful an outsider will be picked and is given the power to clear out Rose's leadership team as he or she sees fit. A complete fresh start is needed. Nepotism should never be tolerated.

Oh come on now Edgartown

Yes, an outsider, who knows no one here and has no investment in this community. That's the ticket! Get somebody without any pesky experience weighing them down, too. Who needs it?

Ob EMT Oak bluffs

Nepotism? Seriously that’s where you’re going with this? The Rose family has done more good for this island and helped saved more lives than any family from here. With people as ungrateful as you, the whole family should leave public service. You don’t deserve their skill or talent for their jobs. Such arrogance. Shame on you. And for all those saying Johns leadership was poor aside from the three or four unhappy off-island medics, ask a firefighter or any EMT around the islander what they think of his leadership, his talent, his knowledge for his job, how well he runs a scene and take command.

Stop It OB

Arrogance ? Shame on you Ob EMT. The Rose family has helped save more lives or done more good than any family from here. What an absolute insult to the Amarals, Alleys, Alwardts, Billings, DeBettencourts, Moreis, Nortons, and the MANY other multi-generational families on this Island who dedicated themselves to protecting their community and building a respected fire department, only to be mutilated by the present regime. Three or Four unhappy off-island medics? What about the MANY other Islanders who have left? And yes, lets ask firefighters and EMT's around the Island what they think of John's leadership.

Ob emt Tisbury

If all those other families were being attacked by ppl who had no idea what there talking about i would be saying the exact same about those families, that they’ve done more for this island than any other families and they do not deserve to be attacked like this, but there not being attacked and tha Rose family is right now and it’s just not right. They have done so much good in all of there careers this old stuff doesn’t need to be dredged up. Now I need be done with this comment section what’s done is done.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sat, 02/01/2020 - 08:36

Permalink

OB4Life Oak bluffs

Thank you to the leadership of Oak bluffs! The Chief is a good firefighter and EMT, but far from qualified to be in a leadership position. Hopefully we can stop pouring resources into a broken individual and start putting resources into a department!

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sat, 02/01/2020 - 09:14

Permalink

Disgrace Edgartown

Why does the gazette feel the need to bring up things that happened way in the past that were settled and let go and moved past, when discussing someone’s retirement from a position they spent years in. Doing so much good for our community, yet they don’t write about any of those things? This is appalling how the reporting is being handled on this. We as a community need to do something about the papers that represent us, this could be our family member or loved one at some point. I used to have great respect for the Gazette and none for the Times but they are one in the same now.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sat, 02/01/2020 - 09:19

Permalink

Bob Shaw Oak Bluffs

Fire chiefs and police officers need to be kept to a higher standard than the average Joe, yet in OB unscrupulous officers are often protected by omerta. After so many misdeeds, a judicious pruning of the head of the Fire Department was long overdue. Lets use this morass as fertile soil to restore the integrity and public trust forfeited by the Department under the Rose regime.

Justaguy Tisbury

Rose regime? Are you off your rocker. You mean the Regime that started the transports to hell our family members get off the island when sick? You mean the regime that brought the department up in so many levels technically and professionally? You mean the Regime that always gave back to his employees and fought for all his employees to have great pay that they deserved and the best equipment possible? The regime that’s responsible for helping forefront that beautiful new fire station? The Regime that with the volunteer department have saved many lives, put out many fires in our community? The Regime that has tirelessly worked to protect our town during the fireworks and illumination night? Do you have any idea how much work goes into this position. And all gone for what? One “accusation” and “allegation” made towards them that was dropped. Chief Rose you will be so much better off in retirement, these people will never stop complaining.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sat, 02/01/2020 - 16:54

Permalink

R Scott Patterson Edgartown

Shout out to the commenters brave enough to attach their names to their comments, the rest of you lacking said bravery should keep you opinions to yourselves.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sat, 02/01/2020 - 21:48

Permalink

Al Reis Edgartown

All of us have done things that, if splashed across the newspaper, would make us feel mortified. Unfortunately, when you take a leadership position you have to accept that the consequences will be different than if you are anonymous. Me. Rose will now have to live in a small community with this stain of ignominy due to the public exposure- he will pay his pound of flesh with interest.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sun, 02/02/2020 - 06:20

Permalink

Ob4ever OB

People move on, spend your time and energy on something worthwhile this situation has reached its end. Allow John and the town to move forward. There’s no point in beating it like a dead horse. John helped a lot of people in his career regardless of his personal lapse in judgement. The rest is opinion based and not worth arguing over, some love him some don’t as with any leader. Let’s all focus our energy on moving the department forward, and stop it with the who’s family has done more debacle. There were lots more names left off that list that have done good for this town, the Rose family just as deserving as the rest for their contribution to public service. None deserve to be discredited.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Mon, 02/03/2020 - 18:21

Permalink

Nathalie Woodruff Oak Bluffs

Middle managers who abuse their positions of power to commit nefarious acts are more often asked to ‘agree to resign’ and are offered generous exit benefit packages. Bottom-of-the-ladder workers are more likely to be summarily fired for lesser offenses without being offered any such consideration. Equal justice is a myth.

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.