<p>Administrators defended their policies this week as a parent group raised concerns about the rising number of suspensions at the regional high school. </p>
A parent group is raising concerns about the rising number of suspensions at the regional high school.
Spokesmen for the group calling itself ACROSS (A Committee to Reduce Out of School Suspensions) appeared before the district school committee Monday night.
In a statement, representative Suzy Cosgrave said more than eight per cent of high school students received out-of-school suspensions this year, up from 4.8 per cent last year.
“This trend is one that cannot continue. We need clear directives from the school committee in order to stop this push away from the school setting for students who live on our Island,” she said.
Ms. Cosgrave, a parent of two high schoolers, cited research that shows out-of school suspensions are ineffective in helping students reach their educational goals.
She also said the regional high school’s numbers are higher than the state average of 2.9 per cent. Numbers for incidents of violence, meanwhile, are lower than the state average.
“I believe that MVRHS belongs to all of us on this Island. It is my school and it is your school. Most of all it is our students’ school, and they belong in the classroom,” Ms. Cosgrave said. She was joined by about a dozen other group members.
Data provided by school administrators at the meeting showed there were 54 out-of-school suspensions this school year. More than 20 were for possession of a vaping device or paraphernalia. Fifteen were for behavioral issues. Eight were for possession of a controlled substance. The percentage of students suspended at the high school has increased in recent years, but not to unprecedented levels. The numbers have varied since 2012, spiking at 8.4 per cent in 2013-2014 and falling to 1.9 per cent in 2015-2016.
Superintendent of schools Dr. Matthew D’Andrea said part of the increase can be attributed to the vaping trend that has swept through schools across the country, alarming public health officials, educators and parents alike.
“Vaping is something that caught us off guard,” Mr. D’Andrea said of the e-cigarette craze. The nicotine devices were supposedly conceived as a way to help adult smokers quit smoking, but they rapidly gained popularity among younger users.
The superintendent said while there is always room for improvement, he strongly backed the discipline policies of principal Sara Dingledy and her administration. Mr. D’Andrea said when Ms. Dingledy was hired in 2016 he charged her with changing the culture at the high school. Among other things, she revised the student handbook and code of conduct, created a clearer attendance policy and outlined tiered consequences for different offenses. Last year she hired a new administrator of student affairs, Dhakir Warren.
“There were many challenges around the structure of this building,” Mr. D’Andrea said, describing the school culture Ms. Dingledy had inherited from previous administrators. “There were students wandering the halls during classes, students in bathrooms congregating, students leaving the building, students on their phones constantly,” he continued. “When I hired Sara, I tasked her with, we have to bring structure to this building. The momentum of this building was going in a direction that was going to lead to real problems, and turning it around is a monumental effort, and I’ll tell you, this building is safer. As a parent and a superintendent, I am pleased with the direction this school is going.”
Ms. Dingledy also defended the data on discipline. She noted that while the numbers exceed the state average, they are in line with the numbers of similar schools.
“I’m happy to look at data and to share it and I think we should kind of peel back the onion and see what sort of measures we are hoping to do,” the principal said. “A lot of the changes we’ve made in the last 18 months I’m hoping will bear out in the data that we see.”
For example, she said incidents of vaping decreased between the first and second semesters this year.
And she echoed the concerns about the troubling e-cigarette trend. Students who come forward for addiction support are not penalized at the high school, Ms. Dingledy said.
“We’re not talking about vaping out of school [as a discipline issue], we’re talking about vaping in the building during the school day — that that is a behavior that if there is no perceived risk we have seen it becomes a pervasive part of our culture,” she said.

Comments
This is the tip of the
WashAbhorred EdgartownThis is the tip of the iceberg. As much as they resent and deny it the law does apply to schools on Martha's Vineyard.
ACROSS ?
Joe D. Ma.ACROSS ?
As a parent I am totally on
bs Oak BluffsAs a parent I am totally on board with the stricter disciplinary protocols. Money well spent. Finally!
The article is missing the
Island Mom Vineyard HavenThe article is missing the point . The school wasn't ready to combat the Vaping epidemic and reacted by suspending kids with any kind of vaping smoking infraction instead of educating them as to the dangers. They are only now coming up with plans to educate leaving the current seniors, juniors, sophomores as the test cases for the new discipline policies initiated in 2016/17. Kids should be accountable for making mistakes but dont deny them their education. The current policies has left a wave of student feeling resentful and unfairly treated, resulting is a divided culture in the school. keep them engaged and motivated to learn and let them make a mistake and learn from it in a non punitive way
Educating students about the
Ted VHEducating students about the dangers in life is the job of a parent, not the school system. Setting policy and enforcing it on school grounds is.
You got to have Rules.Smoking
Left for Good MaineYou got to have Rules.Smoking in school....Out, don't call us ,we'll call you....Mr Reagan
As with many high schools
Marty Milner TallahasseeAs with many high schools around the country the issue of parents supporting the role of discipline in education is always on the table. The learning environment if allowed to proceed with the discipline the teacher requires,can achieve FANTASTIC results. The tolerance for distractions must be addressed by all the stakeholders. Behavior has consequences. As personalities emerge they will be formed, one way or another. Everyone needs to decide what the purpose of education is, and how much respect it deserves. One must wonder why teachers were not interviewed in depth on the issue brought up in the article? No doubt they have thoughts on the support they are being given to actually do the job of educating. It appears teachers aren't expected to fix this, but just live with it.
ZERO sympathy for kids
Al Reis TisburyZERO sympathy for kids suspended for thumbing their nose at common sense rules. And zero sympathy for these oblivious parents who are enabling this foolishness.
Smoking has never been
Ken EDG.Smoking has never been allowed in schools. Vaping is just another form of smoking. I hope the system allows for warnings before the suspensions, Zero tolerance never works.
I'm not understanding how
Moved to Maine USAI'm not understanding how parents can be negative about suspension for vaping. Correct me if I'm wrong but vaping is against the law if your under the age of 21. Unless your precious has stayed backed for multiple years they're not only violating school policy they're violating the LAW. Consequences must be faced if you decide to do something stupid. This should be a problem dealt with at home. Time spent on math, science and history or time spent teaching little Johnny that is bad to vape? Parents/parent need to step up and teach your child if they screw up, you as a parent will back the school policy and not riddle the school with negativity for teaching what you should have. If your kids think school is like a prison educate them on what the real world is like so they're not chewed up and spit out when they enter it.
Add new comment