Tisbury, Edgartown and Oak Bluffs fire departments responded to the scene. West Tisbury fire department covered the Tisbury station.
Mark Alan Lovewell

Tisbury House Fire Reveals Unsafe Living Conditions

Tisbury firefighters responded to a fire in the basement of 209 Franklin street Friday afternoon. The house has since been condemned by the town Board of Health.

This article has been updated to include a response from Roni Deluz, the homeowner, and again to include information from the fire chief’s preliminary report.

Tisbury firefighters responded to a fire in the basement of 209 Franklin street Friday afternoon, resulting in the discovery of unsafe living conditions, fire Chief John Schilling told the Gazette.

A preliminary report released Wednesday said the origin of the fire was likely a clip-on work light connected to approximately six extension cords. According to the report, the plastic wire covering on a cord was “melted and deformed where it entered a socket.” The tenant living in the basement room where the fire began reportedly had filled the room with debris three to four feet deep, according to the report.

The house has been condemned by the town Board of Health.

Firefighters had to dig debris out of the basement to get to the burn.
Courtesy Tisbury fire department
Firefighters had to dig debris out of the basement to get to the burn.
Courtesy Tisbury fire department

Neighbors noticed smoke after a fire was caused by an overload of extension cords, Mr. Schilling told the Gazette Morning morning. He said the cords sparked some debris in a crowded basement space, and the volume of clutter made it difficult for responders to access and control the fire from the basement entrance.

“Access was impeded by the [debris] from the outside, and we weren’t able to access that room from the inside because of a tremendous amount of unpermitted construction subdividing it off to unpermitted bedrooms, closets and storage areas,” Mr. Schilling said. “We literally had to form a line of firefighters digging the debris out of the basement to be able to get in there enough to be able to open the door.”

Firefighters piled the debris outside the house to get to the burn and extinguish it.

Oak Bluffs and Edgartown fire departments also responded to the scene. The West Tisbury fire department covered the Tisbury station. Tisbury police temporarily blocked off the road. Tisbury, Oak Bluffs and tri-town EMS all responded along with the Red Cross, Eversource, the Tisbury department of public works and Tisbury Water Works.

Mr. Schilling said a follow-up investigation with the town’s Board of Health on Saturday found multiple violations of safety codes, especially in the basement, where the space had been illegally subdivided into multiple windowless living spaces. The sizable house, originally approved for eight bedrooms, had been modified to create 13 bedrooms. Three outdoor sheds also appeared to be used for year-round housing, Mr. Schilling said.

“There were portable heaters and clip-on work lights attached to multiple extension cords,” Mr. Schilling said. “Hallways had been chopped up... Every bedroom had a portable heater, hot plates, microwaves, mini-fridges.”

House has been condemned pending safety modifications.
Holly Pretsky
House has been condemned pending safety modifications.
Holly Pretsky

He added that in the basement, there were no functioning smoke detectors to alert tenants of danger.

“With no windows or [means of] egress, had something happened in the night, these people weren’t getting out,” he said.

He said one tenant estimated that 18 people were living on the property. According to the report, neighbors estimated there were 11 tenants.

Mr. Schilling said utilities at the property had been turned off, and tenants had been told they need to find other housing. He said the Red Cross was coordinating temporary shelter.

The owner of the home is Roni Deluz, according to land records. Ms. Deluz sent out a statement thanking first responders and saying she was in the process of legally compelling the downstairs tenant to leave.

Reached by phone, Ms. Deluz said 11 people lived on the property, including herself and members of her family.

“If there were 18 people, I would like to know where they were,” she said. “I’m there everyday.”

She also disputed that the basement had been illegally subdivided, saying there is a spa space on one side, and a basement space on the other.

Town health agent Maura Valley said the building had been condemned pending safety modifications. 

“We went with the condemnation order because there was a lot of overcrowding,” she said.

 

Comments

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Mon, 01/14/2019 - 19:08

Permalink

Lorraine Edgartown

This is unacceptable. This puts everyone in the town, at the very least in the neighborhood, at risk. Will this be followed and fines handed out? Or will it be forgotten? This is frightening absolutely frightening to people living nearby.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Mon, 01/14/2019 - 20:34

Permalink

Mr. B Chilmark

I hope the reporter will continue to follow this story--and pursue the question of how many similar situations exist on the island.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Mon, 01/14/2019 - 22:15

Permalink

Dizzy Tiz Tisbury

Sadly, how many of these potential death traps are on our island now? The housing crisis will claim victims before it's solved.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Mon, 01/14/2019 - 23:58

Permalink

Mike Marcus West Tisbury

The Landlord should be put in jail...and she calls herself some kind of ‘Health’ professional. Shame on you for putting those people in harms way.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 01/15/2019 - 08:58

Permalink

James Edgartown

The fire puts this on the front pages, but neighbors and local officials know this goes on, not just on Franklin Street. Selective code enforcement on Island ?

Mailk Washington Vineyard Haven

Hello let's be clear A lot of us live in glass houses so why are we the first ones to throw stones come on people let's look at our own back doors before we lookout and judge our neighbors it starts at home

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 01/15/2019 - 09:57

Permalink

Susan Desmarais Oak Bluffs

This landlord did the same thing in OB. Time to stop and prevent landlords from creating and allowing this dangerous, possibly fatal situation to continue.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 01/15/2019 - 10:06

Permalink

Kara Maine

Im born and raised on MV, But the housing situation for othersis very very limited especially for year round, but this is very very unacceptable. Theres no need to have 18 people living in one house. And for all those plugged in is sooo not safe. But everyone has a point when will this all be solved on marthas vineyard?! Hopefully soon

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 01/15/2019 - 10:23

Permalink

David Oak Bluffs

Not for nothing, but didn't any of the neighbors notice 18 people coming and going?

Mailk Tisbury

No because there were 18 residents living there Come on people let's not fabricate the truth let's stick with the truth the fact And stop being haters

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 01/15/2019 - 11:04

Permalink

John Gault Oak Bluffs

Surprise, Surprise, Surprise, over 18 people living in a home and NO ONE noticed this going going on. People coming and going sheds in the back yard used as housing and NO ONE noticed.What we have is an Illegal Alien problem here on the Vineyard. NOT only housing but people driving around without a Driver's license and the police see them and do nothing or afer a stop the judges let them go,if they are here legally fine, if not call ICE.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 01/15/2019 - 11:08

Permalink

Les Holcomb Edgartown

All this means is that more working people will be dumped onto the streets with no alternatives, and that in April all those will not be available to do the work that most adult Islanders and students on summer break can't do or wouldn't want to do. Those who can't couch surf or floor-surf are welcome to come to the night shelters for the following 9 weeks, unless we opened our island-wide emergency shelter. I didn't read the whole article. Most everyone local knows that this exists. It probably means that we can't continue to treat these workers as what I labeled "The Spigot People" who some of us worked with in the Oil fields ( who were expected to show up and disappear in a flash when the price of oil made wide swings) and the big farms in the Central Valley, who have seasonal crops (and more recently plowing the almond trees under, because the water underneath their farms is free and worth more than their crops.) I wonder if unemployed people in CA will be arrested if they try to escape and go south and crawl over the new wall?) We can't have things both ways guys! The sad thing is that some of the people who get bounced, will be arrested if they try to sleep in a car, or an unheated building and will never have a chance to get affordable housing, or, as I've heard might even lose some of their veteran' benefits. Somewhat else should be thinking of this, and talking about this,not me. Maybe the business owners could contract with the landlords to make their basements safe enough to stay in winter in return for not raising their rents and tossing them out for summer workers. This problem is nothing new. Isn't that why we have a Chamber of Commerce as a forum? One thing I learned about the migrating workers in California is that they came there to work.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 01/15/2019 - 12:03

Permalink

Ken Edg.

This is a bad time of the year for everyone. The shelters are loaded and most people have their homes set at 60 or below to heat their homes of glass. I suggest you help the home owner get his mess cleaned up or get lost. Any home owner willing to rent here is a blessing.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 01/15/2019 - 12:42

Permalink

AJS Montauk, NY

In the Town of East Hampton,NY we have had the same issue but the Town stepped up with improved enforcement and started arresting home owners who were responsible.

Island Thyme MV

Added enforcement comes with a cost that most towns are unwilling to pay. At least in the Hamptons workers can commute from less expensive communities. Where are displaced people going to go on this island? To another basement is my guess. I’d expect this in the summer. The fact that it is happening in January highlights the urgent need for rental apartments.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 01/15/2019 - 14:09

Permalink

JAMc VH/NOLA

Worst nightmare for so many reasons, but most importantly, how can someone willingly put so many people in danger, particularly when it is probable that they are compromised by seasonal living, less jobs, etc? Such criminal disregard.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 01/15/2019 - 14:35

Permalink

Jane Edgartown

This home owner is none other than "Dr." Roni Deluz, author of "Martha's Vineyard 21 Days Diet Detox" and has appeared on theToday and the Wendy Williams show. "Dr." Deluz has a colorful past --- the house mentioned here is advertised by her as "The Martha's Vineyard Inn" - a "retreat". I suggest the authorities take a closer look at her.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 01/15/2019 - 16:15

Permalink

Lorraine Edgartown

Addendum to my previous comment: I am concerned about the danger to our wonderful first responders....they have to enter into unknown and dangerous territory.....these historic communities of old wood fame buildings are fragile; not so much the human body....let us all think of them and let us all thank them....

Jamie West Tisbury

Now this I statement I support 100%!! I like how you made an addendum. I too commend our first responders and firefighters for a great effort!!

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 01/15/2019 - 16:34

Permalink

209 frankin Vh

I live in a beautiful suite at the 209 Property address and never seen over crowding. It's always clean and safe; she is a very nice lady most of all she helps many people with any problem. I don't understand why I can't go back. This seems so crazy to me. Can someone please help her?

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 01/15/2019 - 17:24

Permalink

Nom Deguerre Vineyard Haven

This is nothing more than an example of the housing crisis not being addressed.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 01/15/2019 - 21:19

Permalink

Elyssa West Tisbury

This is beyond greed. Well everybody knows the housing crisis create situations where houses have more people than their intended occupancies, there's above and then there's beyond. This is completely unacceptable 18 people it's obscene and immoral. Imagine if somebody had died. The property owner should be investigated. Well I do feel bad for the people who have been affected, unless there is some change there'll be more more landlords doing the same.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 01/16/2019 - 11:47

Permalink

Marty Milner Tallahassee

Martha's Vineyard has always been a compressed microcosm of the United States. For every point of view there is a human and spiritual side. The society we create defines who we are becoming; who we are. Obviously the layers of inspection, regulation and common sense were overturned by a decision to make money by any means necessary. The next step in capitalist escalation is enslavement. Find a civil boundary of commonality of social purpose and let it be known. Make it mean something. HINT: Pay a living local wage for local labor; don't exploit the vulnerable.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 01/16/2019 - 17:34

Permalink

Ron Delacourt Tisbury

Yawn..... inept town officials, slack inspectors, desperate tenants, landlords raking as many bucks as possible without caring about safety or sanitation… Nothing new here folks, get on with your day.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 01/16/2019 - 22:15

Permalink

Doug OB

Relax. This is not a big deal and listen in folks - 2 words “ private property “ Clean up 5 corners, address the mess of Stop & Shop and for the love of Pete focus on that pot factory churning away drugs night and day.

Jamie West Tisbury

Pot factory, its a medical marijuana grow site, and a legal one I might add. So because it is legal and will help people its a bad thing?? This island is fueled by massive consumption of alcohol, pretty sure that has no medicinal benefits at all Doug. Sorry you feel that way. It is not a cure all but has helped people like my father who suffers from Parkinson's to get through his days.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 01/17/2019 - 08:58

Permalink

Phil and Ethan Edgartown

Doug, I agree. First of all, this would never happen in Edgartown - and to your point about Stop & Shop - you are absolutely correct. I am embarrassed to have friends come to the island via Vineyard Haven because of the blight and mess of Stop & Shop. I know have them fly in. Also, the Tisbury voters have a bigger problem on their myopic horizon and it will be the deluge of pot seeking patrons who will undoubtedly wreak havoc both coming and going - good luck Tisbury - you won’t be worrying about someone’s private property but you’ll be thinking of ways to protect yours!

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 01/17/2019 - 19:32

Permalink

MV resident MV

This is an important story that sheds light on the off season housing market. We all know people lose housing in season, scramble to find a spot, and break important safety rules to get by. We all sympathize and call for solutions. These are victims of our odd economy, caught off guard and desperate. When it happens now, while more than half the homes on the island are empty, we learn a new lesson. People are living like this, by choice, to save a maximum amount of money to send to their families living in far worse conditions. It really makes you think about your values. As for the landlord, who many claim is a victim of overly liberal landlord tenant laws in this state, I just ask, where were the legally mandated smoke alarms? Did this "hoarder" remove them, or did she not provide them, as required by law. I wonder if this basement apartment was legal at all, or if she just let people live there regardless. She might have tried to have a problem tenant removed as so many say, but did she have a right to rent that space to them in the first place? What a dangerous situation, and thanks to all the voluneer and underpaid emergency responders who prevented a catastrophe. How many are living this way, right now, by choice, and how many are collecting their rents knowing full well...

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 01/18/2019 - 09:01

Permalink

Elyssa West Tisbury

There will always be immoral people who are willing to put the lives of others at risk for their own profit. Laws and fines are designed to prevent this... I'd like town spend money enforcing current zoning. People need to recognize but there's a gradation to this issue, it's one thing to have a few additional people... But we all know that there are places in the heart of the community where people are renting bunks for $600 a month to share a room with four other people, or landlords with subpar septics...just take an evening drive and see how many cars are parked outside of certain houses...Where is the enforcement? The fact is that it's a public safety issue and it needs to be addressed.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 01/18/2019 - 10:51

Permalink

Vineyard Mack Tisbury

The sad sad truth is that until there is a catastrophe - such as people dying in an illegal housing situation, for example - nothing will change on the Island.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 04/03/2019 - 13:21

Permalink

Moved to Maine Maine

So I was interested in hearing the update on this story. Having lived on MV for years I realize this is one of many homes set up this way. 13 bedrooms sounds a bit greedy. I have all the faith in the judicial system on the island to handle this in the correct manner. Can you hear the sarcasm in that?
Looking forward to reading more on this.

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.