All smiles after voting at consular in Hyannis.

Vineyard Brazilians Praise Outcome in Homeland Election

Martha’s Vineyard Brazilians traveled to a consular polling station set up in Hyannis to help elect Jair Messias Bolsonaro, who won decisively.

Martha’s Vineyard Brazilians who joined more than a hundred million of their countrymates casting votes in a closely watched presidential runoff election Sunday said this week that they were pleased with the outcome. Jair Messias Bolsonaro, a controversial candidate from a minority right wing party, won decisively, making headlines around the world.

“I’m so, so excited. The world is so excited,” said Meiroka Nunes, who is from the city of Mantena in the state of Minas Gerais. She moved to the Island 16 years ago and worked for the Brazilian consulate during both rounds of presidential elections this year. “My family is there in Brazil, and we wish for a better life for everybody like I have here,” she said.

Island Brazilians who participated in the election traveled to a consular polling station set up in Hyannis to vote. Ms. Nunes was one of them. She is the manager of a Vineyard Brazilian Facebook group with more than 8,500 members, a forum that was full of pro-Bolsonaro posts as election results came in.

“He is the man everybody needs now because he was a sergeant in the army in Brazil before. Sometimes he speaks a little like Trump, a little rude, but right now I understand that Brazil needs someone really strong,” Ms. Nunes said.

Mr. Bolsonaro’s supporters hope that his victory will mark the end of widespread violence and corruption in the country, while opponents are concerned about his authoritarian leanings and the possible consequences for human rights.

“For his constituents, Jair Bolsonaro is the figure of the man who will restore the dignity of the nation, even though he has shown prejudice against minorities and [spoken in favor] of torture and military dictatorship,” Framingham journalist Jehozadak Pereira said in an email. Mr. Pereira hosts a radio show and is editor and writer of a news blog, Mündo Yes, about Brazilians living in the United States.

Meiroka Nunes, who is from the city of Mantena in the state of Minas Gerais, moved to the Vineyard 16 years ago.
Meiroka Nunes, who is from the city of Mantena in the state of Minas Gerais, moved to the Vineyard 16 years ago.

In the jurisdiction of the Brazilian Consulate General in Boston, Mr. Bolsonaro won by a landslide. More than 80 per cent of Brazilians voting in Boston, Framingham, Hyannis, Stoughton, and Nashua, N.H. favored Bolsonaro over the Brazilian Workers’ Party (PT) candidate Fernando Haddad, according to data Mr. Pereira compiled. According to his data, a total of 14,186 people voted in the five towns, including about 629 in Hyannis. It is not known how many Brazilians from the Island voted.

“It is unbelievable, off the charts in this area,” said Boston University professor of political science and Latin American studies Dr. Taylor Boas, speaking of the election outcome in Boston. Mr. Boas, who specializes in electoral politics in Latin America and has studied Brazil most extensively, said this election seems like more than a typical swing to the right.

“It’s normal to have a fluctuation in power, but I think what’s happened here is this is probably the most authoritarian president who has ever won an election in Latin America,” he said.

He noted that much of the Brazilian expatriate population in the region left a struggling economy behind.

“People who leave Brazil and come here have made a decision to migrate, and in most instances, it is an economic decision . . . They’re happy with their life here compared to how it was,” the professor said. “And they’re hearing bad news about how things are back home, so the sense of contrast is heightened. They made the decision to leave to begin with, so they are more likely to be dissatisfied with status quo.”

Until the impeachment of Brazil’s last president Dilma Rousseff in 2016, the Workers’ Party had held the presidency since 2003.

Robert Ribeiro of Edgartown once supported the Worker’s Party, but said no longer. Mr. Ribeiro is from the city of Belo Horizonte in Minas Gerais, and he said the level of corruption in the country is unprecedented.

“I think there was no other option because the other candidate, Fernando Haddad, was pretty much the same as what we have had in Brazil for the last 13 or 14 years,” he said. “In my opinion, what caused this situation is the other party, the Workers’ Party, because they messed up so much. People got really mad.”

At Bite on the Go in Vineyard Haven, cashier Dayanne Lino was cheerful as she sold coffee to regulars Tuesday morning. Ms. Lino is from the city of Uberlândia in the state of Minas Gerais. She said her husband used to be part of the PT, but recently changed parties. She said her daughter reported celebrations among Brazilian children at school on Monday.

“I feel happy. I feel like it’s hope,” she said. “It’s going to be a big change, a positive change because the PT, the last party in the government, was there a long, long time. Now, I hope there is no more corruption and a better life and better security.”

Ms. Nunes said she has spent many nights worried about family who still live in Brazil, and she said those worries informed her vote.

“The greatest fear of an immigrant [is to] receive a call at dawn that a dear one has died, was killed by the violence, and that already happened to me,” she wrote in an email. “All my family is in Brazil: mother, cousins, brothers . . .”

Mr. Robeiro, Ms. Lino and Ms. Nunes all agreed: under the circumstances, Mr. Bolsonaro is not too extreme for Brazil.

“Bolsonaro is a right-wing guy, but I don’t think he is far-right,” Mr. Robeiro said. “He just wants things to be done right, to correct things that are not working.”

Comments

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 11/01/2018 - 19:36

Permalink

Mostly Left, Not Corrupt Sanctuary City

Wow. Pull the ladder up much? The irony would have been stunning a few years ago, but now it is just one more lesson in real life. Thanks for the article. It was important.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 11/01/2018 - 21:24

Permalink

ChrisR Oak Bluffs

Bolsonaro is a right wing fascist, worse than Trump. I feel sorry for your country. You are on the wrong side of history. Let's talk in 10 or 20 years to talk about how he ruined your country.

Aron WT

You are so right. It terrifies me that these normally decent folks live among us. Maybe they aren’t so decent after all...

Brazil is in a terrible way, yes. And the left really made a mess for themselves with their extraordinary corruption. But the answer is not Fascism. And that is what Bolsonaro is.

I am terrified to ask my Brazilian friends about their politics. What a sad, sad, sad world :(

R Scott Patterson Edgartown

The corruption on the left in Brazil wasn't any greater than any previous gov, it was ginned up by the right in Brazil and by our government. The carwash investigation uncovered lots of corruption across the spectrum but chose to only prosecute the left. The conviction of Lula is a complete joke, he is a political prisoner plain and simple.

Al Fairhaven

"Maybe they aren’t so decent after all..." is a pretty hateful comment. Much more so than that typical rightwing talking point "They don't share our values," IMO.

Our country (and planet) would be much better off if everyone would simply accept that people who don't share values can still be decent to eachother. Having spent some of my life in another country and then a battleground state, I know it's entirely possible.

Maybe you all should get off the island and explore the country (or world) a little more. You might find different perspectives much less shocking.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 11/02/2018 - 06:57

Permalink

Child of of Immigrants west tisbury

I agree with Chris R. ... except I don't think we will have to wait 10 to 20 years for the newly elected right wing fascist to reproduce corruption .... or "overcome" it by taking over the military and using violence to repress human rights. History does indeed teach us this. Brazil knows this story because it suffered under a military regime for years. Sadly, one of the world's great democracies has moved to the Right. This is not a victory.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 11/02/2018 - 10:21

Permalink

Susanna J. Sturgis West Tisbury

Sobering. I hope this was a vote against corruption, not a vote for Bolsonaro's despicable ideas. Plenty of USians who voted for Trump in 2016 thought they were voting against "the establishment," and that hasn't worked out all that well, has it.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 11/02/2018 - 12:27

Permalink

Faith Ann Lubitz Northampton MA

So..what if these Brazilians are not stupid? What if they’re right about vast corruption on the left ruining their country? What if something analogous is going on here? And what if the media here have a motive to promote the “fascist Trump, fascist Bolsonaro, fascist Assad, fascist Putin...”story? Then who is stupid?

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 11/02/2018 - 14:12

Permalink

Vote! West Tisbury

Thanks for the eye-opening article. Great way to break out of the American bubble and remember that voting matters! I can't say I understand the vote for Bolsonaro, from within Brazil or without. I'd love to know more about the relationship between past Brazilian administrations and people's decision to come to the United States.

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.