Diverse, historic stretch of north shore in West Tisbury was once owned by Washington Post publisher Katharine Graham.
Mark Alan Lovewell

Storied Graham Estate Goes on the Market

<p>The majority of the storied north shore estate once owned by legendary Washington Post publisher Katharine Graham is on the market.</p>

The majority of the storied north shore estate once owned by legendary Washington Post publisher Katharine Graham, a diverse and historic stretch of waterfront property in West Tisbury, goes on the market for sale today.

The asking price is $39.5 million for 186 acres that includes the home of her son William W. Graham, a cottage fronting Lambert’s Cove Beach, a barn and caretaker’s home.

The heart of the property — a 50-acre parcel at Mohu — is not included in the sale and remains family held.

The property is one of the last large parcels left on the north shore.
Mark Alan Lovewell
The property is one of the last large parcels left on the north shore.
Mark Alan Lovewell

Mrs. Graham, a longtime summer resident of the Vineyard, bought the original property at Mohu in the 1970s, saving it from development. Mrs. Graham first bought what was then approximately 217 acres in 1972 and summered on the Island for nearly three decades until her death in 2001. The sale follows the death last December of Mr. Graham, a Los Angeles lawyer who had his own investment company, and who returned frequently to the Vineyard and enlarged, restored and carefully tended the land.

LandVest Martha’s Vineyard is the exclusive broker for the sale of the property, which is in the hands of a trust controlled by two trustees who are administering a portion of his estate. Proceeds from the sale will go to two beneficiaries of the trust — both are charities that have not been named.

“It’s an incredible piece of the Island,” said Tom LeClair, who is handling the sale with his partner Gerret Conover at Landvest. “Certainly, one of the most important pieces of property because of its size, [and] historically it’s been so very important.”

The 186 acres for sale are actually seven parcels that are to be sold together and feature diverse habitats of shore, wetlands, woodlands and meadow, combining to form a property that Mr. Graham painstakingly maintained, including its network of roads, trails and landscapes.

“Bill devoted a large portion of his later adult life to maintaining and beautifying the property, and it was very important to him,” said Fred Cohen, one of the trustees and a friend since college. “It was a very important part of his life.”

The property is said to have significant conservation value.
Mark Alan Lovewell
The property is said to have significant conservation value.
Mark Alan Lovewell

Robert Shuwarger, the other trustee, added: “One of the things I know that he really enjoyed was getting up on the tractor [to] work on the land. He really enjoyed that aspect, but he was fully engaged.”

Seen from the air, the property features carpets of waving field grass, bracelets of stonewalls, belts of wandering plank walkways and swatches of billiard-table green manicured grass studded with boulders. It is believed to be one of the most ecologically significant areas of the Island.

“This is one of the last large parcels left on the north shore, representing the ancient morainal woodlands, multiple wetlands and wonderful deeply forested land,” said Tom Chase, director of conservation innovation for the Nature Conservancy of Massachusetts. “Coupled with its high elevation, it is a beautiful property with a lot of contrast.”

There are no conservation restrictions on the property.

Active for many years on the Vineyard, Mr. Graham played a critical role in helping rescue Martha’s Vineyard Hospital from dire financial problems in the 1990s. He served as interim board chairman as he and others helped guide it through what some described as its darkest hour. He also was a champion of conservation efforts on the Island and quietly contributed to many causes large and small.

By the 2000s, the Graham properties consisted of about 236 acres and were embroiled in the longest running residential tax dispute in Massachusetts history. Mr. Graham had contested West Tisbury’s valuation of $50 million, but the dispute finally ended in 2008 when the state Appeals Court affirmed an appellate tax board decision against him.

Mr. Graham enlarged, restored and tended property.
Mark Alan Lovewell
Mr. Graham enlarged, restored and tended property.
Mark Alan Lovewell

The property’s significance predates the Grahams, perhaps by centuries. Some have speculated that Bartholomew Gosnold landed at Lambert’s Cove near Mohu in 1602, where his crew were said to have encountered a dozen Wampanoag men who offered deer skins, tobacco and cooked fish.

By the early 20th century, the area was owned by well-known Lambert’s Cove families of Luce, Cottle, Tilton and Norton. From 1909 to 1920, lawyer, businessman and politician William

M. Butler acquired various farmsteads, hills, marshes and even a pasture and beach lot that had been set aside in 1709 for so-called Praying Indians converted by Thomas Mayhew Jr.

Senator Butler, who in the 1920s served as an interim U.S. Senator for Massachusetts and as chairman of the Republican National Committee, converted a bungalow into what would become the property’s dominant structure, a 22-room home with three wings and several fireplaces. Calvin Coolidge started visiting the property when he was governor of Massachusetts, and the bedroom he occupied was thereafter called the Governor’s Room.

In Senator Butler’s study was said to be a bronze figure of the long-ago Algonquin chief, Mohu, holding two fish.

Rolling morainal land will be sold, with proceeds going to charity.
Mark Alan Lovewell
Rolling morainal land will be sold, with proceeds going to charity.
Mark Alan Lovewell

His family held onto the property until 1964, when it was sold to Mr. and Mrs. William Mcfarlane and their son and daughter in law. Eight years later, Mrs. Graham bought what was then approximately 217 acres for $1.46 million, at the urging of Gazette editor Henry Beetle Hough, who sought a buyer with the resources to preserve the distinctive property.

Mrs. Graham would summer at Mohu for nearly three decades — interrupting her vacation in 1974 to return to Washington for the resignation of President Nixon, whose Watergate scandal was exposed thanks in part to the Post’s dogged reporting. On the Vineyard, Mrs. Graham played host to friends and luminaries, including Nancy Reagan, Margaret Thatcher and the Clintons.

The land not included in the sale includes a swath of rolling acreage along James Pond, a small bungalow that dates to an earlier era of ownership, a boathouse fronting the beach and a dramatic promontory with two towering stone chimneys, the only remnants of Mrs. Graham’s 10,000-square-foot house that was disassembled in 2005. Fields of lupines are planted around the chimneys, which can be spotted from Vineyard Sound.

Included in the sale is a 45-acre parcel on which Mr. Graham built his own house in about 1990. It features five bedrooms, a detached, three-bay garage with upstairs apartments, and sweeping distant views of Lambert’s Cove and Makonikey Head beyond. Behind the house, an artisanal railing curves up a shaded hill, where a slice of James Pond can be seen.

Five-bedroom home that belonged to Mr. Graham sits on 45 acres.
Mark Alan Lovewell
Five-bedroom home that belonged to Mr. Graham sits on 45 acres.
Mark Alan Lovewell

The one-bedroom beach house sits on a half-acre parcel with 89 feet of frontage on a private section beach. Elsewhere, on a particularly high spot sits a gazebo with vistas of Paul’s Point in one direction, Makonikey headland in the other. Nearby is a stone etched with the name of an old Vineyard friend of Mr. Graham’s, Walter Ashley, who used to hunt in the area.

The 186 acres and buildings were assessed at $35.3 million by the town of West Tisbury this year, with its property tax estimated at $213,912, according to an analysis provided by LandVest.

What remains unclear is whether a buyer or buyers will bring the same sensibility to the property that Mrs. Graham did in 1972, when she was approached by Mr. Hough. In a statement, the trust indicated that the property has significant conservation value.

The 186 acres are seven parcels that will be sold as a block.
The 186 acres are seven parcels that will be sold as a block.

Mr. Cohen and Mr. Shuwarger declined to discuss whether there were any discussions with the trust holding the 50-acre parcel to keep the entire Mohu estate intact, or whether there are any conditions for a sale, beyond an obligation to the derive value for the beneficiary charities.

“Our charge is to get value for the beneficiaries,” said Mr. Cohen. “I look forward to a successful sale,” added Mr. Shuwarger.

Mr. Chase said the importance of the property cannot be overstated.

“If the land were lost to development, to me that would be tragic — not only for ecological reasons but for historical reasons as well,” he said. “The number of conversations between Kay Graham and business and world leaders that took place on the property renders it almost a national monument. I personally always thought that was an important part of our local and even national history.”

In a brief statement, Mr. Graham’s daughter Alice Graham recalled her father’s love for the property.

Sweeping views of Makonikey headland and beyond.
Mark Alan Lovewell
Sweeping views of Makonikey headland and beyond.
Mark Alan Lovewell

“The first trail we made was over a Thanksgiving with my grandmother and we called it the grandparents trail,” she recalled. “My Dad, Kris Lukowitz, Seth, Jarrett and others [who worked for Mr. Graham] over the years created a network of trails linking streams, soft mossy patches of earth, meadows and old stone walls. My Dad’s vision was of a place where people could find peace, and maybe even healing, through interacting with nature.

“His wish for the sale of the land is that it will benefit researchers and clinicians working tirelessly to bring healing and peace to families throughout the country. In that way I hope his vision continues, and that everyone who has cared about or worked on the property can feel part of it.”

Comments

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 08/02/2018 - 23:27

Permalink

J Katama

The obvious question - believe this is exactly why land bank was created ? This is why we paid our 2% fee when we purchased our properties. Buy the property and provide full access to the public.

Ed Edgartown/Katama

I agree. If it happens that the Land Bank can't afford it, this is an opportunity for the Trustees, Sheriff's Meadow, Land Bank and other organizations to pool their resources and keep this property from further development.

Michael Billings Vineyard haven

Hooray to all the comments , all longtime islanders who grew up here certainly can remember a lot more accessible land making it public would be amazing

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 08/03/2018 - 07:56

Permalink

Katherine Scott Tisbury

The Land Bank should move heaven and earth to acquire and preserve this property.
Agree that this kind of opportunity to acquire an incomparable property with ecological, recreational, historic, and sheer beauty values is what the Land Bank was created to achieve.
I hope the Land Bank will initiate a special fund-raising drive to secure the purchase of the property.
There is, simply, no other parcel on the Island---or anywhere!---remotely approaching the value and significance of Mohu. IMHO! The call must go out to preserve this parcel for the public, and not let it be scooped up by a hedge fund manager or oligarch of some kind.

BTW, it was also said of Senator Butler that he was "the man who put Coolidge in the White House."

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 08/03/2018 - 08:26

Permalink

Tim Boland West Tisbury

Bill loved that land and he worked it and had a vision. He could of been a master planner,
or Landscape Architect as he had a gift for creating beauty. He shared his love of the property on walks and talks, always with great pride. To be able to explore the land with him is one of my fondest Vineyard memories, immense oaks, hickories, and amazing biological diversity. Thank you Bill for all you shared over the years! Your spirit remains with that landscape forever.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 08/03/2018 - 08:35

Permalink

Cece Vineyard Haven

Agreed! Where is the land bank?
The “ charge” of the trustees is to “get value to the beneficiaries”, but at what cost?

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 08/03/2018 - 10:10

Permalink

Jeff NYC

The Land Bank absolutely must acquire this, end of story. Why do they exist if they aren't protecting pieces of land like this.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 08/03/2018 - 10:11

Permalink

Joanna Cole Chilmark

Perhaps the Graham family could be moved to donate the land to the Land Bank - as other families have done.

Katherine Scott Tisbury

It is hard for me to imagine a charitable purpose more worthy than that of ensuring that the land that Bill Graham cherished remains as close as feasible to what he envisioned and created and allowing the public to experience this awe-inspiring paradise. There are also, I believe, significant tree specimens on the property

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 08/03/2018 - 10:35

Permalink

Eric Tisbury

Charlie Baker Governor of Massachusetts needs a defining immeasurable act of public good for his tenure as our governor to be complete. I implore our governor to take up the cause of securing these properties and enjoin our legislature to act for us as our fore fathers did, which was to plan for future generations and bequeathed to them in perpetuity to safe guard important and relevant properties to remain in the public realm as part of our state park system.
Now in this time in which we find ourselves with national political strife rife with the relegation of factual knowledge giving way to innuendo, rumor and the absurd. We should elevate ourselves to the purposes of our Commonwealth to which is in its own name.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 08/03/2018 - 10:40

Permalink

Martha Magee

“My Dad’s vision was of a place where people could find peace, and maybe even healing, through interacting with nature.”

May it ever be so. Amen.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 08/03/2018 - 10:41

Permalink

Nancy Edgartown

This should be conservation land - why is it not? The threat of big development is looming large. The people of the Island and those we trust to lead us at the Land Bank, MVC, Sheriff Meadow and everywhere have a chance to do the right thing - or look away. This is a watershed event.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 08/03/2018 - 11:05

Permalink

Ken Edg.

50 million appraised value to the town is alot of tax money. I guess the town will just have to increase rates if its take off the tax rolls. thank you west tisbury.

Carol formerly Chilmark

OMG, the town already has a TON of money, what are they going to do, goldplating on the fire trucks? ENOUGH. This land should be protected, preserved by the Land Bank.

Katherine Scott Tisbury

The article didn't mention the extensive work the Dunkls did on the system of ponds, brooks, and dams, which I believe had first been created by Senator Butler.
That subject is worth a whole nother story.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 08/03/2018 - 15:22

Permalink

Kate Eastern Shore Virginia

The conservation importance of this large property is too great to be ignored. The Land Bank needs to somehow step in and do what it’s meant to do.....protect Vineyard resources, conserve open space and the wetlands. If they can’t do it, then they need to join in with the Trustees etc to make it happen. What an incredible place and with the amount of history and ecological importance of this Vineyard treasure , it would be a travesty to see it get developed in any way, shape or form. I think the Vineyard has enough McMansions, overkill gaudy homes and “developments “. This is a piece of local and National history. Help keep it that way for years to come.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 08/03/2018 - 15:24

Permalink

RF WT

That is a lot of bank - pooling will still be a stretch to make that happen. Hopefully some creative financing is being developed.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 08/03/2018 - 21:19

Permalink

Dainer VH

So many times I admired the grounds of the Graham Estate. And to think of how smart it was to remove a house for more land to be appreciated. A continuation of land conservation here is of ut most importance no matter how much of a tax is being removed.
If this land is developed like the Hornblower property then once again we have allowed more land to be violated by back hoes, automobiles and indiscriminate power usages which will increase all of our services in every town. Not only that it will be hoarded away by a select few.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sat, 08/04/2018 - 17:33

Permalink

West Tisburian WT, MA

Imagine this financing project:

A group forms, maybe calling itself Friends of Martha’s Vineyard, as the Grahams have been, and perhaps it works with existing conservation organizations to buy the Graham property for public access. The group would have funding for purchase if...
5 members contribute $1,000,000
20 contribute $500,000
40 contribute $100,000
3,000 (just over the population count for West Tisbury) contribute $7,000 each.

As a service industry, non-trust-funded resident of MV, the following commitment of a little over $60/month would be a significant stretch for me: but were it somehow possible to finance my portion of the balance of about $21,000,000 as a member of the largest group — at say a 5% rate over 15 years, I would gladly come up with my (approximately) $11,000.

This Graham parcel, I’d gladly share as the group see’s fit...to keep it open and available for future generations of visitors to recreate on and for it to be preserved as the sacred piece of nature it is.

This is just one simple vision of financing for a collective and cooperative conservation effort that I’d love to share with at least 3,000 friends, neighbors and caring visitors.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sun, 08/05/2018 - 06:32

Permalink

charlie callahan so boston/edgartown

This would be the greatest gift ever to the problem of affordable housing. This would solve the islands problem with this one nice gift,if anyone is serious about solving the problem, but I doubt it

Bob Edgartown

It took a lot of comments to get to the best use for this land. Thank you Charlie we need more affordable housing and may be a marriage of conservation and housing could be reached. We do not need this all to get taken off the tax rolls I would be against this whole parcel going to conservation.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sun, 08/05/2018 - 06:36

Permalink

deshandra brown edg

It's time for all the limousine liberals up-island to put their money where their mouths are. Create a tax-exempt charitable foundation so their contributions are legitimate tax write offs.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sun, 08/05/2018 - 11:02

Permalink

TAD Chappy

This is an example of why clear and unequivocal estate planning on Martha's Vineyard is so important. The property could have simply been left to a conservation organization. Rather, it is now in the hands of paid trustees and a realtor looking to make a commission.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sun, 08/05/2018 - 11:09

Permalink

Developer NYC, Chilmark

The property is not worth half that amount. asking 39.5mm for 186 acres equals 212k per acre. yes waterfront is worth that and more, not open fields. avg wt 3 acre lot is under 600k. Town zoning min 3 acres. There is nothing for a developers profit.
As for Land Bank comments purchase price of 39.5mm is approx 2x annual budget. Not cost benefit good use use of public money here.

Ken EDG.

"Proceeds from the sale will go to two beneficiaries of the trust — both are charities that have not been named." Its going to a good cause. Mr Graham did everything in his power not to sell parts of the property for taxes, hes to be commended. I hope the island can come through to keep it one piece.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 08/08/2018 - 09:43

Permalink

Diane NJ - but 3x year visitor to MVY

If I had the money to buy the property I would keep it undeveloped , except for adding a trail or two. I would put my sleeping bag out on the lawn in the summer (bugs and all) and just enjoy the beauty.

Sigh.....

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 08/08/2018 - 13:27

Permalink

Maureen Regan Edgartown and NYC

Imagine life on the Island if our predecessors lacked the foresight to preserve the Manuel F. Correllus State Forest or State beach (Joseph Sylvia State beach) among several other priceless public acquisition of large parcels of land. We need to summon their grit, determination and ingenuity to save this for all Islanders!

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.