VTA buses carry more than 1.3 million passengers every year on 14 routes around the Island.
Mark Lovewell

Transit Authority Unveils Plan to Go Electric

The Vineyard Transit Authority (VTA) is moving full-speed ahead to transform its bus fleet to electric battery-powered buses, administrator Angela Grant told the Edgartown selectmen Monday.

The Vineyard Transit Authority (VTA) is moving full-speed ahead to transform its bus fleet to electric battery-powered buses. The VTA board of directors voted in December to begin the transition, and the agency is seeking state funding in the next fiscal year to begin replacing the current fleet of clean diesel buses with electric vehicles.

VTA administrator Angela Grant told the Edgartown selectmen this week about plans to replace the diesel fleet with electric vehicles, using state transportation money. The transit authority will increase its usual request for funding to account for the extra cost of the buses, estimated at $150,00 to $250,000 more apiece, Ms. Grant said. This year the VTA requested $2.4 million in state funding; next year it will request $3 million, she said.

“I fully believe we can make this work here,” she told the Gazette later. “It’s just a commitment to change. The best path for the VTA in terms of viability, long term, and reduced maintenance, and environmentally, is going electric.”

She said the VTA is slated to replace four buses in fiscal year 2018. “If they only give us funding for the equivalent of four diesel buses, we would just purchase three electric buses,” she said.

The cost of electricity to charge the bus batteries, at current rates is about the same as the cost of diesel fuel.

“The savings isn’t there, it’s in the maintenance costs,” Ms. Grant said. “Diesel buses, there’s nothing cheap about operating them, when you have to replace parts.” She said some components which are part of routine maintenance cost as much as $6,000.

The electric buses under consideration are built by the California company BYD, which stands for Build Your Dreams. Several California transportation systems are already running the electric buses.

The buses are equipped with iron phosphate batteries, not the lithium ion batteries which have been associated with sporadic fires in electric vehicles and electronic devices. The batteries are guaranteed to last the 12-year life cycle of the new buses.

Ms. Grant sketched a picture of the new electric fleet:

The buses are approximately the same size as the current fleet, but can hold more people because they don’t need room for a rear diesel engine.

One of the most difficult hurdles in changing to an all-electric fleet will be installing infrastructure along the routes. The buses have a range of 170 miles. With some routes traveling as much as 300 miles per day, the buses will need to partially recharge during the routes. In some cases, the buses will be charged by a large charging pad which buses will park on during loading and unloading. The pads provide an inductive charge that will replenish 10 to 15 per cent of the battery power during each stop. Other charging stations will provide power by a conventional plug in apparatus.

When the buses return to the VTA garage in the Martha’s Vineyard Airport business park, they will plug in overnight, with a software program determining how to charge the buses when electricity is the least expensive.

The VTA is counting on a variety of grants to pay for infrastructure construction. Ms. Grant has submitted an $18.4 million dollar request for funding from the fines paid by Volkswagen as part of a $2 billion legal settlement that followed the recent emissions scandal. Other funding could come from federal and state agencies which have money available to promote renewable energy resources.

The public will be able to use part of the planned Islandwide charging infrastructure for their own private vehicles, Ms. Grant said. She believes the charging stations will promote transformation of some other fleets, including small and mid-sized delivery trucks.

Martha’s Vineyard is ideally suited for electric vehicles, Ms. Grant said. “Geographically, we’re suited for running transit well,” she said. “A lot of our routes are a half hour. The segment times, we’re blessed with that component.”

Ms. Grant has begun a series of visits to Island government boards to begin the process of explaining the electric bus initiative, and begin discussions about charging stations.

“The towns can have some solid input in terms of how much they want to participate, or if they don’t want to participate,” she said.

At their meeting Monday, Edgartown selectmen greeted the proposals enthusiastically.

The transit authority operates 14 routes through the six Island towns year round. The authority operates a total of 32 buses, with as many as 28 in service during peak summer periods.

Last year the VTA served 1,364,768 passengers. Ridership has grown 23.1 per cent since 2011.

“It’s an exciting time for the VTA,” Ms. Grant said.

Comments

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 02/08/2017 - 07:03

Permalink

TJ Hegarty WT

I think this a great idea.
The VTA building has a large roof area and I am wondering why there has been no mention of installing solar / electric collection panels to help offset the electoral costs of buses and infrastructures?

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 02/08/2017 - 08:07

Permalink

David Welch Edgartown

Very exciting. Maybe there's room on the garage roof for solar. Finding a way to charge the buses from on site power generation. That's magical.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 02/08/2017 - 08:12

Permalink

Taxpayer OB

$150 to $250k more for each bus? Millions of dollars more for what? To feel good? Nonsense

Dan Ob

. $250k to lessen the impact on the environment sounds like a great investment into our future. Thanks to the vta for having the long sighted view to understand this.

Pragmatist/Ethicist Chilmark

I'm not sure where you're getting your "million of dollars more" takeaway, Tax Payer, but to answer your "for what" question: to save money (via maintenance, and arguably via the cost of electricity long term), increase passenger capacity, and to reduce emissions thereby improving air quality and mitigating environmental impact. You know, because climate-change triggered SLR is slowly but surely sinking the Island. So, for that.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 02/08/2017 - 08:57

Permalink

EH Tisbury

It would be nice if the Gazette could do a bit of reporting on the underlying costs and benefits. After all, we only have so much tax money and there are many competing projects here on MV. Is this one worth it? Report!!

It looks like $1 million upcharge for the buses (4 @ $250,0000) PLUS 18.4 million for infrastructure (which will only work for the buses and which has no other benefit.)

We're spending roughly 20 million dollars in order to get... what? The VTA buses make a de minimis contribution to the overall Island air quality and noise. Seems like we'd be far better off spending 20 million improving 5 corners (there's nothing more inefficient than a mile of bumper to bumper traffic); or using electronic signs to detour folks early when the bridge is up, so they can take alternate routes before they're stuck in line; or hiring SSA folks to prevent idling in the SSA lot, or....

Nathanael

READ THE ARTICLE:

“The savings isn’t there, it’s in the maintenance costs,” Ms. Grant said. “Diesel buses, there’s nothing cheap about operating them, when you have to replace parts.”

Pay more upfront, pay less later. Long term savings.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 02/08/2017 - 11:37

Permalink

deshandra brown mv

Why not have solar panels on the roof of the bus? Just like the battery tender in my boat but a larger panel, like the size of the whole roof? It would be constantly charging.

Islander On Island

Who is going to pay for the removal of the solar paneled roof once the bus' life span is up? By then it should be classified as a hazardous waste and be expensive to dispose of.

Carol formerly Chilmark

Deshandra, Toyota put a toe in those waters with one version of the Prius - it had a band of solar panels across the front of the roof, which kept the AC running when the car was off. Think of how many babies and dogs die in hot cars each year - I think every new car should have that! In the meantime, rooftop solar makes the most sense. My local medical center is entirely solar - it's on the roofs of the hospital, medical building and parking garage.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 02/08/2017 - 12:02

Permalink

TOM West Tisbury

There is a degree of irony here in replacing diesel powered buses that will be then powered by diesel, other fossil fuels or nuclear. And we should keep in mind the extremely high cost of electricity in New England.

Nathanael

READ THE ARTICLE.

The electric buses are cheaper to maintain, so they are cheaper over the long run. So fares should go down once all the buses are replaced.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 02/08/2017 - 13:37

Permalink

Ken Edg.

Its funny they are using fines from diesels that cant pass any emission test because the technology isnt advanced enough. who said life was fair.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 02/08/2017 - 14:06

Permalink

Paul Pimentel Edgartown

First, congratulations VTA and thank you Ms. Grant for this decision to convert to electric. Second, can you drop a hint to the Superintendent about school buses. And third, as an EV owner, I can assure skeptics that it really does save $.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 02/09/2017 - 16:48

Permalink

Bill Katama

Complete waste of money. Why not buy more fuel efficient buses and lower the fare getting more people off the roads.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 02/09/2017 - 22:11

Permalink

Carol formerly Chilmark

This is fantastic news! Great work, VTA! To those gripers (especially in nice flat Katama) - climate change is here, it's happening, and sensible people do not want it to get worse. (We're the ones who passed our high school science classes.)

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sun, 04/23/2017 - 10:59

Permalink

travis

BYD is a Chinese company. Love the idea, but look at Proterra for busses made by an American company.

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.