Yellow House has sat vacant for years.
Mark Lovewell

Edgartown Pursues Plan to Rescue Yellow House on Main Street

<p>Edgartown voters may be asked to decide this spring to spend $3 million to buy the so-called Yellow House, a run-down property on Main street owned by the Hall family.</p>

Edgartown voters may be asked to decide this spring to spend $3 million to buy the so-called Yellow House, a run-down property on Main street owned by the Hall family.

The town community preservation committee will hold a public hearing next week about purchasing or taking through eminent domain the house and surrounding land at 66 Main street, using $1.5 million in community preservation funding set aside for open space and historic preservation. The hearing is set for Thursday, Feb. 2 at 4 p.m. at the town hall.

A separate town meeting article has been drafted that would ask the town to spend another $1.5 million to buy a private parking lot also on the property. The funding mechanism for the article isn’t yet clear.

Pending an affirmative vote by the CPC, both articles are expected to appear on the annual town meeting warrant in April.

Property is in a crumbling state.
Mark Lovewell
Property is in a crumbling state.
Mark Lovewell

The 19th century house located on a quarter-acre of property at the corner of Main and Summer streets formerly housed a bookstore and other retail space but has been vacant for several years. The front of the building is wood clapboard painted yellow, but in recent years it has deteriorated badly.

Owner Benjamin L. Hall Jr. could not be immediately reached for comment Tuesday.

But town plans now call for renovating the Yellow House and leasing it as retail space, turning the lawn between the house and town hall into a small park, and converting the gravel parking lot into public parking. Part of the parking lot could also be used for a future expansion of town hall.

“It’s just been an eyesore too long and we’re always being asked, what are you going to do about the Yellow House,” selectman and community preservation committee chairman Margaret Serpa said Tuesday. She said the town hopes to be able to purchase the property and then work with another party to renovate the building. She said a committee would probably be appointed to move the project forward if the purchase is approved.

Mrs. Serpa said she is not aware that there has been any communication with the Hall family, but she expects pushback.

“I’m sure there will be some opposition,” she said. “Hopefully the townspeople will see what we want to do and approve of it and we’ll be able to move forward and take care of that eyesore.” She said the town has tried to work out arrangements with the owners in the past that haven’t panned out. “I just hope that people will support this because I think it will be such an improvement, and make it something that we’re all proud of,” she said.

The community preservation committee voted in 2014 to allocate funding for the purchase of the house, but then quickly abandoned the plans.

Town records state the house was built in 1805 by Capt. Chase Pease, the county jailer and an early Methodist. An addition to the house served for a time as the town’s first Methodist meeting house. The building was originally one story, and the structure was later lifted and a new first story built underneath, according to records. In more recent memory it was the home of Bickerton & Ripley bookstore until the early 2000s.

Comments

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 01/24/2017 - 16:05

Permalink

James PI3 Edg/New Haven

Why don't they allow a private buyer to purchase it? Would be a great place for an upscale restaurant.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 01/24/2017 - 18:36

Permalink

deshandra brown mv

That's very generous of the town. The assessment is 1.933 per the link below, which would not take into account the obvious poor condition. So 3m is 1.5 times assessed value without discounting that the place is a dump. Owner should take the deal before an 'eminent domain' taking, which would be at a MUCH LOWER NUMBER. We DO need parking (wink wink)

http://gis.vgsi.com/edgartownma/Parcel.aspx?pid=2452

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 01/24/2017 - 18:40

Permalink

Anne Oak Bluffs

3 million? The Halls should donate it. Ha, Ha, they'd never do something nice for the town.

Lorraine Edgartown

Sara, right on. How many village residents intensely dislike having to climb in a car and fight the triangle traffic to get mail, a dozen eggs at the market, a bit of grocery items, not all of us want to go out to eat, some of us prefer our own fixings....

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 01/24/2017 - 19:36

Permalink

Janet Edgartown

Oh great James just what we need another high end restaurant that closes in November how @ some more parking & of course more than one place in February to get a cup of coffee!!!

James PI3 Edg/New Haven

A vibrant downtown is good for everyone. Basic year round services like groceries, post office and the library have been moving away from the congested downtown where they are more accessible for years. Unless you want to demolish historic houses and put up parking lots I would continuing to support ideas that are profitable and sustainable. A good restaurant in that space could be supported year round when parking is easier. And maybe they could have a cafe for coffee!

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 01/24/2017 - 20:07

Permalink

Marie

I agree. Let a private developer purchase the property. Look what happened when they purchased to old house next to the library.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 01/24/2017 - 22:56

Permalink

Islander On Island

I doubt it will get done as quickly as proposed. The Hall's will rightfully sue the town and fight for what it theirs. Why do they think they should just be able to take it from them. Do they owe back taxes. Probably not. I pretty sure the town would have published that aspect if it were so. Sound like a Captain Warren House fiasco all over.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 01/24/2017 - 23:05

Permalink

Brubaker

Edgartown is a joke, this will benefit someone who works in town hall or there friends.

Town Employee Edgartown

They should get the landscaping contract. Look what $80,000 brings to the triangle flower bed for 6 months a year.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 01/25/2017 - 00:18

Permalink

Edgartown worker

How about a library annex? Or, if we cut down the tree that the Halls were never allowed to, it would be a great place for a multistory apartment complex for local renters, no?

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 01/25/2017 - 07:44

Permalink

Summer John Edgartown

You will NEVER, EVER get a chance to add public space downtown again - step up and make this happen

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 01/25/2017 - 13:58

Permalink

Ken Edg.

look, affordable housing right under your noses. If we had kept the warren house and this house there would have been rooms to rent for the summer help.

deshandra brown Edg

I don't believe its the obligation of the taxpayers to provide summer housing for the employees of private businesses, who routinely gouge their customers.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 01/25/2017 - 14:30

Permalink

Cassandra O'Troy Edgartown

Just take it from them. This family owns property all over the island that they refuse to maintain. These properties aren't just eyesores, they're dangerous. If they can't fulfill their obligation to the community and take some pride in ownership, they should be hit with fines. Don't reward them by giving them money.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 01/25/2017 - 21:16

Permalink

John Mort Northern Vermont

The property is a eye sore, honestly not sure what should go there. Does the property have any historical significance where it should be brought back to life? I think a post office depot for in town businesses and residences isn't a bad idea. Ideally the property should be used for town use only and not sold to some of Edgartown's big scum bag contractors who only give a crap about lining there pockets with money and careless about the history of the town. Oh ya, there is no history left in Edgartown it has been sold!

Harland Gibbs Edgartown

There is an in town Post office branch on Church Street, They don't need two in town Post Offices. Remember the old Post Office that was where the Movie theater is. If the Town takes it for Eminent Domain what will the Town do with it? Expand the Town offices?. Town park.? Parking? There are enough In town restaurants ( a new one will need Parking and in town parking is extremely scarce). The Town will pay a lot of money for a building that should be torn down, adding to the cost of acquisition. The Halls won't sell. If they wanted to sell they would have done so long ago.

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.