<p>The Edgartown planning board voted to refer a large renovation and expansion of the Edgartown Stop & Shop to the Martha’s Vineyard Commission.</p>
The Edgartown planning board voted Tuesday to refer a large renovation and expansion of the Edgartown Stop & Shop to the Martha’s Vineyard Commission, marking the end of the first phase of the public review process.
The company’s plan for a 16,000-square-foot addition, expanded parking and a revised traffic flow now goes to the MVC for review as a development of regional impact.
In a slightly changed process, the review began at the town level with public hearings before being sent to the commission. Concerns have centered on noise, parking and traffic in the Upper Main street area, which is congested in the summer season.
Meanwhle, a plan to remove the small Edgartown National Bank branch next door to make way for parking and an exit that aligns with Pinehurst Road has been resolved. Last month representatives from the bank and Stop & Shop said the two parties had not reached an agreement about the branch removal. Stop & Shop’s parent company, Ahold, owns the building; Edgartown National Bank has a lease through 2020.
At the planning board hearing Tuesday, attorney Geoghan Coogan, who is representing Stop & Shop, said an agreement had been reached to relocate the bank elsewhere on the Stop & Shop property. The plan now shows the bank just to the north of the store, in the parking lot.
Bank president Fielding Moore attended the meeting, but said he had no comment to add.
Mr. Coogan told the Gazette after the meeting that the existing brick bank building will be demolished.
Stop & Shop representative Randy Hart said the bank branch will be located in an under-utilized area of the parking lot.
Company representatives noted other lingering issues, including requests to store shopping carts in the lobby of the building, create a snow management plan and build better walkways through the parking lot. Representatives have said the store will remain open during construction, and a complete construction timeline will be available after the permitting process is complete.
A VTA bus stop located on Upper Main street next to the store will be shifted north to accommodate the renovation, but will remain off the road. VTA administrator Angela Grant said the company is happy with the plan and the realignment of the exit with Pinehurst Road. In the long term, she said, they would like to see a bus shelter to accommodate employees and others who use public transit to get to the store. “Which is what we need as a community to reduce congestion overall,” she said.
Conservation commission member Edward (Peter) Vincent Jr. asked about changing Main street to a three-lane road between the Triangle and Memorial Park.
Planning board member Fred Mascolo said the town has pursued that idea with the state Department of Transportation, which has oversight of the road, to no avail.
The board voted unanimously to refer the project to the MVC. Commission executive director Adam Turner, who has attended all three hearings, said he saw progress in the plan.
“I think they’re farther along than they were when they started,” Mr. Turner said. He commended the planning board for a thorough initial review. “We’ll do the same before we bring it back to you for a final chance,” he said.

Comments
What a wonderful change this
Ken Esq EdgartownWhat a wonderful change this will make for the unofficial town meeting place of Edgartown. It'll be nice to have better stock, wider aisles, and more parking.
Looking forward to this
BillyB OBLooking forward to this project breaking ground!
Such a shame VH couldn't get
Michael OBSuch a shame VH couldn't get their act together on remodeling and expanding that store. It would have been the catalyst for the renewed year round town on the island.
Now it's an embarassment and getting worse.
I'd like to see more
edgartown workerI'd like to see more classical architecture demolished, like the bank building downtown. That kind of aesthetic doesn't belong here - I started a petition.
You should go to the meetings
Bob EdgartownYou should go to the meetings and try to get them to add your concerns to the building process. We need people like you to come forward to make this as nice as it can be for a 16,000 sq ft building.
Please let this go through,
Leroy Oak BluffsPlease let this go through, and lets get more progressive. We need to remove that eye sore in OB, the movie theater.
Add new comment