<p>This summer will be the last for Fiddlehead Farm, a staple North Tisbury stop for many. Owner Robert Skydell recently learned his lease will not be renewed.
This summer will be the last for Fiddlehead Farm, a staple North Tisbury stop for foodies and families alike. Owner Robert Skydell said his lease will not be renewed come October, and the market’s last day will be shortly after Labor Day.
“It was not a decision I made voluntarily,” said Mr. Skydell, who leases the property from Kristen Kinser. “It was a surprise.”
Mr. Skydell and his former partner Rose Willett opened the roadside market in 2007. Both had experience in the restaurant business, opening The Sweet Life Cafe, Obie’s Barbeque, The Dry Town Cafe and The Offshore Ale Company. After years of feeding people, at Fiddlehead Mr. Skydell focused on providing quality ingredients so people could feed themselves. For the past 10 years he has sold homegrown vegetables and herbs, produce from other Island farms, freshly baked breads and pies and imported meats and cheeses.
The land Fiddlehead sits on has a long history with agriculture. In 1938 Louis Greene took over the tiny three-acre farm that his father had bought in 1915, growing and selling vegetables. Under Mr. Greene, Donald Mills started working the land in 1974, when the three acres had grown into 40. Mr. Mills took over the operation in 1981 after Mr. Greene’s death, operating as Hillside Farm. In 1989, 37 acres of the farm were preserved in a joint effort of the Martha’s Vineyard Land Bank,the state Agricultural Preservation Restriction program and the town of West Tisbury. Later the agricultural use of the land faltered. For a while, Neil Flynn of Katama Apiary sold honey at the stand and Bananas gallery had a shop on the property.
Fiddlehead Farm marked a second turn back toward agriculture. Mr. Skydell planted a large garden in the back, growing greens, tomatoes, squashes and herbs, and opening the market. Speaking to the Gazette Monday, he recalled that at first he expected to be in the background doing the gardening (he’s adamant about being a gardener, not a farmer). But quickly he found himself in the front of the shop, where talking to the customers became his favorite task.
“I like to get to know my customers, I know them by name, know the type of cheese they like, know the ingredients they are trying to find,” he said. “People have made it so rewarding.”
In 10 years at Fiddlehead, he said he has watched a vibrant community grow around Island-sourced food, and has felt his own place in supporting farmers on the Island. For example, he said, a farmer who grows cucumbers will do better if they can pickle some of the crop and not just sell wholesale. Mr. Skydell wants to provide shelf space for both the pickles and the cucumbers. He is also interested in the community that builds around food. He spends half the year in Nicaragua where his favorite place to be is the central market.
“When I travel I always find the market, that’s where you reveal the culture of the people,” he said. “Food more than anything builds viable, vibrant communities.”
Intent on continuing to build community through a farm market, he said he is hopes to stay in North Tisbury.
“I’m looking to join forces with one of the legitimate farmers on Island,” he said, adding: “It’s been a very tough thing to digest, but I’ve moved beyond that and am excited to look for opportunities down the line.”
Meanwhile, Kristen Kinser and her daughter Kendra Mills said this week they plan to open their own farmstand on the property, where they live and have been growing a garden non-commercially for years. They will bring back the name Hillside Farm.
“My mom and I have been thinking about this for awhile,” Ms. Mills said.

Comments
Oh, no... we love Fiddlehead
Christine ChilmarkOh, no... we love Fiddlehead and Bob. To say nothing of his indispensable supply of Goldbud fruit. Good luck to you, Bob, hope you find a new venue soon! We'll be looking for you.
Christine
I love stopping by Fiddlehead
Kyle West TisburyI love stopping by Fiddlehead! It's such a great location and will be sad to see it change but hopefully Bob finds a great space for his next iteration. Best of luck.
It's always sad to see the
Peter ChilmarkIt's always sad to see the loss of what has become an up island institution. Any word on what will become of the property?
We down islanders loved it
Dawn OBWe down islanders loved it too.
Just curious...how much land
Toni Kauffman Burlington, NJJust curious...how much land are we speaking of, why wasn't the lease renewed,and does anyone know what the land/market will be used for in the future? Was Ms. Kinser contacted?
Fiddlehead and Bob are what
Susan and Roger North TisburyFiddlehead and Bob are what make the real Vineyad what it is. A kind hard working man with great vision. The loss of this business in this location will change the character of the village yet we do hope you find a new location nearby and move onto bigger and better opportunities. One door close another opens. We look forward seeing what you do next!! Best of luck
How sad! Amazing quality and
Anne ChilmarkHow sad! Amazing quality and selection! Please stay on the island Bob...up island, especially!
Bob...we are sorry to read
Kenny DiPietro AquinnahBob...we are sorry to read this and wish you best of luck as you move ahead. While we were/are relatively new customers...we found Fiddlehead to be a wonderful up-island place to find great cheese, locally sourced produce and great conversation. You will be missed!
Kenny/Cori
Boje Moy, Bob. Terrible news.
Constance Ellis ChilmarkBoje Moy, Bob. Terrible news. We hope you'll stay Up-Islsnd!
Louie Greene's daughter,
John Alley West TisburyLouie Greene's daughter, Jackie, was instrumental in opening a roadside stand and ran it for several years. Soory to seethis business fall by the wayside. Good luck Bob in your next venture.
I stop by almost daily to
Vicki Divoll ChilmarkI stop by almost daily to chat with Bob and usually buy some high quality food. I am very sad about this surprising news and just hope Bob will find a good spot to regroup and start again. He is so good at that after all!! We love you!!
Bob, keep us posted on what
Ann Gibbons Scherlis West TisburyBob, keep us posted on what you do next--I hope we'll see a new farmstand/shop next year! We will follow you wherever you grow...
Was any attempt made to
Alex Muromcew EdgartownWas any attempt made to contact Ms. Kisner as to why she chose not to renew the lease or what her plans are for the property? It was unclear from the article whether the property has an agricultural conservation easement on it.
Bob Skydell went above and
Dan Larkosh West TisburyBob Skydell went above and beyond for his customers. Our family will certainly miss his quaint store which always stocked food of the highest quality. We certainly hope Mr. Skydell will find a new home for Fiddlehead in North Tisbury. It's a shame to lose such a location, but with Mr. Skydell at the helm there is no question Fiddlehead will continue to be successful. Thank you Bob and Rose for all you have done to make our community a better place.
So sorry to lose lovely place
Sumner Silverman Vineyard HavenSo sorry to lose lovely place. Please let us know if you will open again on the island.
people should ask why he lost
Tom Engley West Tisburypeople should ask why he lost his lease this space is cute quaint and charming only because of what Bob has but in it I'm losing my club house its a shame
This will be a "tough act to
Kathleen Kaempfert North TisburyThis will be a "tough act to follow." Good luck to you all!
I became a Gold Bud addict
Brooke West TisburyI became a Gold Bud addict thanks to you, Bob! Wishing you all the best and look forward to following you to your next destination.
Say it isn't so!!! Just
Jeff Levy AtlantaSay it isn't so!!! Just adding another prayer that you find a great new home for Fiddlehead. It's just too good to go away.
Sad to see such a wonderful
June West TisburySad to see such a wonderful shop go where I could get everything for a meal, not fight summer traffic, and know Bob would recommend the best from salt to produce. Will look forward to seeing you and what you create in a new location!
Buying great food and
Scott CanadaBuying great food and chatting with Bob has been part of our vacations on the Vineyard forever! We'll miss you - look forward to a "new" Fiddlehead.
Add new comment