Seasick But Putting Pen to Page, Whaling Wife Diaries Up for Auction

In 1885 Parnell Smith Pease of the Vineyard joined her husband on a whaling trip aboard the Alaska. Her diary is up for auction on Thursday at Swann Auction Galleries in New York city.

In June of 1885, Parnell Smith Pease of Martha's Vineyard joined her husband, Capt. Charles William Fisher, on a whaling journey aboard the Alaska that was expected to take several years. It was custom then for some wives to accompany their husbands on board. After all, walking a widow’s walk in wait could become very tiresome for both parties, in particular newlyweds.

Captain Fisher, a widower, was 50 and Ms. Pease in her early 20s when they married.

In the book Whaling Wives by Emma Whiting and Henry Beetle Hough, Captain Fisher was described as, “an outstanding figure . . . . he possessed good skin and a pleasant expression, though his profile showed a prominent and almost craggy nose, and his hair had retreated somewhat from his forehead and was thickest at the back of his head, Old Testament fashion.”

As for Ms. Pease, she was a young beauty. “Her features were regular and finely proportioned, her hair curled above her forehead, and she was radiantly young when she married.”

To pass the time on the journey, Ms. Pease kept a diary. That diary is now up for auction on Thursday, Feb. 4, at Swann Auction Galleries in New York city, priced in the $4,000 to $6,000 range.

The diary begins in September 1885 and ends in December of 1887. Imagine a young bride today setting sail with her older husband in search of whales rather than enjoying a honeymoon parked on a beach somewhere in search of a lovely tan. Ms. Pease spent the trip mostly seasick. The chapter on her in Whaling Wives was titled “Parnell Disliked the Sea.” She had no experience on a boat and had to be dropped off at various islands along the way to recuperate for months at a time.

“It was hard to have him go, but he says he will be back in a few months, and I must try and get well,” Ms. Pease wrote while staying on the Chatham Islands off New Zealand.

She did witness whale hunts, though, while on board.

“We took a whale . . . the largest one this voyage,” she wrote. “They call it a hundred and fifty barrel one. Mr. Francis got stove when he first went down but afterwards came back and took the low boat and went down again. . . . It was dark when the whale was along side, and today is a gale of wind, so bad they have not done much. I do hope it will be good weather tomorrow so we can save it. . . . We lost the large whale we took on the 18th.”

She also seemed to fare better at sea as the years continued, although she was left on land several more times. But upon encountering Australia, her spirits lifted.

“We are four weeks from Sydney. Today the Capt. is reading aloud a History of New Guinea Island. I come on deck most every day now and walk and feed the chickens. They do not look very well, 7 have died. I hope we get a lot of whales and make up for some of our ill fortune. Today I made a cake, the first I have made since leaving home.”

In the Bering Sea, the crew had more good luck.

“Sept. 20. Whales in sight every day. My cabin boy is no good when a whale is in sight. Two men sick. The last whale made about 81 bbls,” Ms. Pease wrote.

“Oct. 19. Weather good, raised whales in the morning. Lowered the larboard boat, had to cut off, too much wind. Plenty of whales in sight. Finished a pair of mittens for the steward. Snowing a little. Colder.”

Although the journey continued for two more years following December 1887, and Ms. Pease remained alive, the diary ends rather abruptly. Perhaps after nearly two years of weekly entries, the stormy seas finally caught up to Ms. Pease and her creative juices ran dry. Or better yet, maybe she found something better to do, like setting out in a low boat to heave the iron with the boys.

Visit swanngalleries.com for more information about the auction.

Comments

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 02/02/2016 - 16:46

Permalink

Johanna Schaefer Crestview, Florida

I keep in touch with the Vineyard - my longing for a second home. listen to mvy radio on all day and most nights. I read the Ms. Pease article with great interest - what a brave women. Wouldn't it be great to compile and publish a book about the women of the Vineyard past and present. If one hasn't already been done.

Leslie Floyd Chappaquiddick

I am a Pease descendant and have a great interest in this diary. I am currently working on interviewing the residents of Chappaquiddick. I think a compilation of women's history would be wonderful!

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 02/02/2016 - 22:52

Permalink

Ann Floyd Chappaquiddick

Parnell is my great, great Aunt if I have it right! What a thrill it is to read this!!

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sat, 02/06/2016 - 11:18

Permalink

Carolyn Daniele Sarasota,Fl

I had such a diary written by my great great grandmother. Caroline Mayhew. Teeny tiny writing as paper was very scarce. I let my uncle borrow it and he let John Black borrow it and I was never able to recover it. If any one has any inkling as to where it might be I'd be very grateful.
She is also in Whaling Wives.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sun, 02/07/2016 - 12:45

Permalink

Dianne Smith Chilmark

It would be interesting to know both the provenance and the purchaser (and perhaps even the price) of the diary. Worth a followup story?

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Mon, 02/08/2016 - 14:04

Permalink

Dianne Smith Chilmark

FYI from Swann Auction Galleries:

Dear Ms. Smith:

The seller and purchaser of the diary are both confidential. The sale price was $3600 plus the 25% buyer's premium for a total of $4500.

Sincerely,
_______________________________

Rick Stattler, Director
Printed & Manuscript Americana
Swann Auction Galleries
104 East 25th Street
New York, NY 10010
212 254 4710 Ext. 27
fax 212 979 1017

[email protected]

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.