Forty years after its release, Jaws remains a treasured part of Island history. A look back on the summer Hollywood filmmakers descended on the Island and struggled against all odds to make a realistic-looking movie about a giant shark with a taste for human flesh.
When Charlie Blair joined the crew working on Jaws in the summer of 1974, he had already crossed the Atlantic four times in a sailboat. The young captain had settled down on the Vineyard the previous fall after a major expedition, around the world, where an Island patron was in search of migrating birds and humpback whales.
But he didn’t anticipate the long days and nights he would endure the following summer, when a large crew of Hollywood filmmakers struggled against all odds to make a realistic-looking movie about a giant shark with a taste for human flesh.
At the time, Mr. Blair was an owner of the Ruddy Duck charter company in Edgartown, which the filmmakers had hired for a half day to help with their boats. “By the end of the day we were working for them,” Mr. Blair said. “And then the end of three days, I was managing all the small boats.”
“I worked about 21 hours a day and I slept in 10-minute catnaps everywhere,” he said. “On the sets, in the boats, on the pavement. I was one tired dude.”
But looking back, he said it was one of the best summers of his life.
The job included transporting as many as 200 crew members to and from their shooting locations off Chappaquiddick and South Beach. The Teamsters labor union in Boston was in charge of crew transportation, including boats, “but that only lasted a few days and they lost a lot of gear,” Mr. Blair said. “They got out of the boating business right away.”
Mr. Blair was one of many Islanders whose local knowledge helped make the film possible. Dozens of others appeared in bit roles and as extras, lending a real-world ambiance to the fictional Amity Island.
Forty years later, the world’s first summer blockbuster remains a treasured part of Island history. A screening Saturday at the Strand Theatre in Oak Bluffs marks both the 40th anniversary of the film’s release and the reopening of the historic theatre following its renovation this spring. The film will also show at the newly renovated Capawock Theatre in Vineyard Haven.
Jonathan Filley, a lifelong summer resident who was in college in 1974, remembers coming home and lining up a summer job at an Edgartown boat yard. Mr. Filley auditioned for the role of Tom Cassidy in the opening scenes of Jaws and soon found himself drunkenly chasing Chrissie, the shark’s first victim, over the dunes to go skinny dipping in the moonlight. He later encounters Chrissie’s arm on the beach. (The arm was actually that of Andrea Morton, who worked at the Kelley House and hid below the sand.)
After those scenes were shot, Mr. Filley landed a different job, working with Mr. Blair and others, providing support to the crew in whatever boats they could find. “You work a lot of hours,” he recalled. “You’d start at sunup and you’re going to just about sundown all summer long. It was a fairly grueling operation.”
Despite the local help, the crew still had to contend with changing tides and winds, and three mechanical sharks whose electric motors had to be replaced with pneumatic pumps that could operate in salt water. Shooting took three months longer than expected, and the film more than doubled its budget. Director Steven Spielberg has called it the hardest shoot of his career.
But the hardship is partly what made the film great, said Richard Paradise, director of the Martha’s Vineyard Film Society, which will host the screenings on Saturday. Without a shark early in the process, Mr. Spielberg was forced to rely on the power of suggestion, using underwater shots of arms and legs and allowing the primal, pulsing score by John Williams to work its magic.
“Part of the charm, part of the thrill, part of the mystery of Jaws is that it’s not perfection,” Mr. Paradise said. “Things were born out of necessity: the heavy emphasis on the unknown, the heavy emphasis on the music to create mood and tension and thrills.”
Jaws stayed in theatres well into the fall, he added, something rarely seen today. “People would go and see it over and over again,” he said. But few people anticipated how successful the film would be, and many questioned whether it would be finished at all.
“There were some very down days,” Mr. Filley recalled. “But the general mood was we had a job to do and we were doing it.” He added: “It’s really, really tough working on the water.”
In some of the later scenes, the shark is harpooned, with lines attached to floating yellow barrels. Instead of the shark, the viewer only sees the barrels racing through the water, or surreptitiously sinking beneath the surface. “It’s me on the other end in a Boston Whaler,” Mr. Filley said.
Much of the work was routine. Every day before sunrise, Mr. Blair would ferry out to Chappaquiddick to pick up Robert Shaw, who played Quint, the grizzled New England fisherman who would finally succumb to the shark, along with his boat, in Katama Bay. Mr. Shaw was an avid drinker, Mr. Blair said, but never missed a line. He also was one of the few to anticipate the film’s success. Mr. Blair recalled a typical pre-dawn conversation:
“Charlie, what kind of boat did they send you in today?”
“Well, Mr. Shaw, I’m in a twin-engine Mako.”
“How fast will it go?”
“About 50.”
“And how slow will it go?”
“Well, if we shut an engine off we can go about four.”
“Let’s go four.”
Edith Blake, an Edgartown resident, found herself pulled into the fray when joining her future husband Henry Beetle Hough, then publisher and editor of the Gazette, to a meeting with the filmmakers about a major beach scene they were planning to shoot on Chappaquiddick.
“I got up and I said, ‘That’s not going to work. You can’t get all those hundreds of people over there and back on a ferry boat. You are going to need to find another beach,’” she recalled. Soon she was working in the casting department and acting as a stand-in for Lorraine Gary, who played the Amity police chief’s wife. She also covered the entire production for the Gazette, and the next year published a book documenting the making of the film.
Robert Carroll, an Edgartown businessman and public figure who died this year, benefited greatly from the production. The Kelley House, for example, into which Mr. Carroll had recently poured a fortune, saw heavy business over the five months of shooting, and stayed open around the clock.
“He was terribly in debt,” Ms. Blake said. “And Jaws saved him.” Other businesses, including the Edgartown Paper Store, also enjoyed the surge in profits.
Mr. Carroll had a small role in the film as an Amity selectman, complete with some improvised lines, although most of that scene didn’t make the final cut.
“Spielberg was very good about hiring local,” Mr. Filley said. “For a lot of us that’s the fun part about watching the film 40 years later.”
In the beginning, many people felt besieged by the traffic and commotion around the Island, especially in Edgartown, where much of the shooting took place. And Amity itself was a somewhat unflattering version of the Vineyard, with snobby “Islanders” and a mayor who refused to close the beaches at the risk of losing summer tourism.
“The way the movie framed the Island, nobody seemed to think highly of that,” Ms. Blake said. “But the people who were involved in it loved it.” Similarly, Mr. Blair said the Hollywood crew had their reservations when they arrived. But by the final scenes many had found Island girlfriends and didn’t want to leave.
“It was party central,” Mr. Blair said.
Of all the media events on the Vineyard over the years, Ms. Blake did not believe that any have approached the level of excitement and disruption caused by Jaws. And Jaws changed people’s lives. Mr. Filley, for example, went on to a long and successful career in film and television production, managing films and among other things working as location manager for Woody Allen for years.
“The circus came to town and I ran off with the circus,” he said. “Because of Jaws I had a whole career. And I’ve had a great time doing it.”
With the money Mr. Blair made from his sleepless summer — about $50,000 — he headed down to Florida in his sailboat to compete in several races, including the Miami-Nassau Race, in which he won first place in his division. “So I had a good run with my Jaws money,” he said. He added that the popularity of Jaws had been a boost to his fishing charter business.
“I was leery about it but I think it really perked people’s interest in sharks,” he said. He also believed the Monster Shark Tournament in Oak Bluffs, a source of much controversy until it ended last year, was likely influenced by the success of Jaws.
“The impact of the movie continues every summer,” said Lee Fierro, former artistic director of the Island Theatre Workshop. Ms. Fierro played Mrs. Kintner, whose young son Alex (played by Islander Jeffrey Voorhees) was devoured by the shark. Ms. Fierro still gets fan mail from around the world, and believes Jaws will continue to thrill audiences long into the future.
She recently returned to the Island after visiting her two most recent great-grandchildren, one of whom she was delighted to find dressed in Jaws-themed rompers.
On the 30th anniversary of the release of Jaws, the Martha’s Vineyard Chamber of Commerce threw a huge party, called Jaws Fest, with appearances by Peter Benchley, author of the bestselling novel on which the movie is based, Susan Backlinie, who played Chrissie, Ms. Fierro and others. Michael Haydn, who plays guitar by a campfire in the opening scene, also appeared at the celebration, and will perform before each screening on Saturday.
“It should be winding down — the excitement — a bit,” Ms. Blake said. But she also noted the lingering echoes of those five months in 1974 that touched so many lives on the Island.
“Look around for Amity signs,” she said. “You’ll see a few.”

Comments
I watched Jaws in an all
Jeff Winter Haines City, FLI watched Jaws in an all-night theater in Boston, the winter of 1975. I was a student at Gordon-Conwell Seminary in S. Hamilton. I was taking a course where I was living on the streets with no money. I sold my blood. With the money I earned I paid for a movie ticket to watch Jaws all night long. In addition to being "scared out of my pants," I fell in love with Martha's Vineyard. While pastoring FaithMV for five years I so enjoyed walking and driving by the movie locations that made Jaws great.
Jaws is not just a scary
Roger Feinstein Concord, MAJaws is not just a scary movie; it's a great movie! It has terrific characters and performances by Scheider, Dreyfus, and Shaw. I have been a huge fan ever since I saw it on the Island in '75 when I was a kid. Glad to see it continues to get the attention it deserves.
was the dog pipit witch never
rob n.j.was the dog pipit witch never returned to shore an island dog?
Yes he was He lived on
Donna Honig KatamaYes he was He lived on Chappy He belonged to Steven Potter who was throughing the stick
I was on the Island during
Lynn Bunnell Shelton,CTI was on the Island during the filming and it was an amazing thing to see the actors having breakfast in OB. Plus we stayed at the old house that Mr. Chase owned as well as The Wesley House and the shark was kept right outside our door. Was very cool.
My cousin's grandparents were in the State Beach seen too.
Was in a few scenes
Pete issokson Vineyard Haven / oak bluffs /EgardtownWas in a few scenes
I was a little girl visiting
Chrisa Mayhew PennsylvaniaI was a little girl visiting family with my father, Buddy Mayhew, the summer Jaws was filmed. I remember the striped tents on the beach, and just the general air of excitement.
Rob, yes Pipit was from the
julie Pompey/chappaquiddickRob, yes Pipit was from the farm Pimpneymouse Farm I grew up summers on and continue summers on Chappaquiddick Island. She passed away in 1978 and is buried on the farm with a headstone that says "star of jaws"
"star of Jaws" Haha!! That's
MIke Boston"star of Jaws" Haha!! That's Excellent! :)
I loved that dog Pipit he was
Mary Gibbs RiverdaleI loved that dog Pipit he was adorable! He looked like a puppy in Jaws 1975. So sorry to hear Pipit passed away 3 years later so young too! How did that sweet dog die? I love black labs.
I didn’t realize Pipit was a
Joe Fortunato Green, OHI didn’t realize Pipit was a girl. Just assumed a boys name! Good to know.
I spent some time in the
Marty Milner Flowery Branch, GaI spent some time in the belly of that fish. There are plenty of GREAT storytellers on Martha's Vineyard. I love them all. :-) Embellishment is the secret sauce of history!
I had a friend who had a
Kevin Shackett Jr. Mashpee, MAI had a friend who had a speaking part as Charlie in the pier scene. His name was Robert Chambers. His line was "Can we go home now? And he got paid whenever it came on tv. He was a family friend to me and a great guy also. Who was happy to share his experiences with anyone. He passed away in March 2001.
Charlie was the one that was
Karen Patenaude Lowell, MACharlie was the one that was swimming from the shark from the broken dock! That is cool!
We were Chappaquiddick brats,
Katherine Kunhiraman (Kakie Siebel) Berkeley, CAWe were Chappaquiddick brats, and thrilled to see Dr. Nevin and other familiar faces in the film. He delivered two of my sisters, one of whom was visiting that summer and became an extra in the crowd of screaming swimmers rushing from the sea. It was a little on the early side for the water to be warm enough. the screaming was genuine. I watch Jaws from time to time and get a thrill seeing all the familiar beaches where we so greatly celebrated childhood. Oh, how I love the Vineyard!
I remember the making of Jaws
Skip Peoples Oak Bluffs & Salem NHI remember the making of Jaws very well. Use to hang out at Oak Bluffs Harbor when the techs would redo the teeth in Bruce, the mechanical Great White Shark each day due to the salt water damage to the fabricated teeth. GREAT Memories for sure ! Love the Island
I remember 40 years ago I was
Kevin Shackett Jr. Mashpee, MAI remember 40 years ago I was in kindergarten and curious about the film myself. But my mother wouldn't let me go see it because she didn't want me to have nightmares. Remember the warning slogan? "May Be Too Intense For Younger Children". That was before PG-13. But she was right because she did it because she loves me, and that's what mothers are for. But I did get my chance when it was re-released in July 1979. And I had a blast! And when I exited the theater after the film, I took one look at the poster and said to myself, "YES!!!" To this day I've seen on the theater screen 19 times. Close to a world's record.
Fondly remembering Chris
Brenda Worden Lynch Rochester, MAFondly remembering Chris Rebello who played Michael Brody
the older son of Police Chief Martin Brody.
Does any one know if "Bad Hat
Maggie NYC and EastchopDoes any one know if "Bad Hat Harry" was a local guy? (as in: Bad Hat Harry Productions. Producers of House MD and Xmen: Days of Future Past)
Hi Jonathan, Charlie and the
Paul Kirby Pine Point MaineHi Jonathan, Charlie and the many others who enjoyed the "super" summer of 1974 on the Vineyard. A great picture of the beach scene at the "bend in the road" beach. I love seeing the four beautiful Life Guard chairs that I, with the helping hands of Dudley Grimes and Eddie Mahoney, built for the movie. Joe Gonsolves hired me for the project. I painted "Amity Water Co" on the sides of my cesspool truck that Spring '74. Oh, the many wonderful memories of my 7 years on the Island.
Camping alone on the Cape in
Bruce South JerseyCamping alone on the Cape in the spring of 197? I was so drenched day after day (novice camper) that I rented a room in an empty but just-opened motel. Read the book through the night and was so freaked that I packed up and left the hotel at 3AM. Couldn't swim alone in the ocean comfortably that summer.
Yes, the circus had come to
Rob Morgan Shelburne Falls, MAYes, the circus had come to town, and it was a blast. My mother, sisters, and I were extras, as were many Edgartown friends. With his charter company, Morgan Air, my father stayed busy piloting production personnel to and from the island, as well as the film dailies each night. As a collector (pack rat) of Vineyard flotsam and jetsam, I have some Jaws memorabilia, including signs ("No Bikes Allowed on Wharf by Order of Amity Police" "Amity Real Estate"), and pages from an original script marked "Hooper" that were unearthed from an island home a few years ago. Like Jonathan Filley, I worked for a while in production. The making of the movie may have been a rambling, exuberant ride, but the result was a nearly flawless film, I think. I still love watching it--over and over again.
My two claims to fame: I was
Sara Piazza EdgartownMy two claims to fame: I was an extra in Jaws and attended Woodstock.
You were an extra in the Jaws
Rakesh Patel New Delhi IndiaYou were an extra in the Jaws Sara? Congratulations!!!
Even though it's incredible
Kevin Shackett Jr. Mashpee, MAEven though it's incredible that the film is 40 years old, and hasn't lost any of its bite, I was dissapointed that there wasn't going to be another "JawsFest." The one I went to 10 years ago celebrating the 30th anniversary was AWESOME!! There should have been one this year.
Reading Edith Blake's book
Mickey Boisvert south hadley, maReading Edith Blake's book right now; watched Jaws twice this weekend...and on our way to mv for vacay. Still struck by the real star of the movie, the island. Has anyone else (besides me and Roy Scheider) seen shooting stars during your time there?
Add new comment