Property tax bills are going up in West Tisbury and so is spending this year, with the town preparing to ask voters to exceed the state tax cap. A proposed town budget is up almost seven per cent, with school spending a major reason.
Property tax bills are going up in West Tisbury and so is spending this year, with the town preparing to ask voters to exceed the state tax cap for the first time in a decade.
Town accountant Bruce Stone told the town selectmen last week that current fund requests exceed the annual levy limit set by Proposition 2 1/2.
“If everything gets approved, we could be $450,000 to $500,000 over the maximum allowable tax levy,” he said. “It’s the first time we have been in this situation in nine or ten years.”
Voters will authorize next year’s spending at the annual town meeting in April that may include an override and or a combination of capital and debt exclusion questions.
Selectmen began talks about ways to close the budget gap last week; more discussion is expected at their regular meeting Wednesday.
To close the shortfall, the town can vote to exclude major projects from the levy limit. For example, voters could vote to exclude ongoing debt service from a building project at the school from the levy limit or to exclude one-time capital projects like the purchase of a new fire truck.
“You can add it to the tax levy for that one year only, but it does not permanently increase the levy limit,” Mr. Stone said of the latter option.
Alternatively, selectmen could ask for an override, whether general or specific to a town department or project.
All options require a ballot vote and a vote at town meeting. There is also another solution: cut spending, board chairman Jeffrey (Skipper) Manter 3rd said.
As currently proposed, the town’s budget is $17 million for fiscal year 2016, an increase of 6.7 per cent over the current year.
The largest jump is school spending, which is up nearly $1.3 million over the current year.
The West Tisbury School added 16 more students this year, for a total enrollment of 290, but selectmen said the increases are accelerating independent of enrollment numbers.
“That’s the thing that has always gotten my attention, was that no matter what the enrollment did, the school budgets went up and up,” said selectman Richard Knabel.
Mr. Manter, who also serves as a member of the up-Island school board, said there was no reason to believe increases would not continue in the future.
“They spend money without a fiscal conscience,” Mr. Manter said of his school district which includes West Tisbury and Chilmark. He said the other elementary schools don’t come close to comparable increases.
Mr. Stone said the increases are attributed to growing special education needs and contractual obligations.
Finance leaders warned last year that school spending would soon outstrip the town’s resources under Proposition 2 1/2.
While they were able to pay school bills with excess levy capacity last year, this year that capacity is reduced.
Mr. Stone said he would apply the remaining $600,000 in free cash reserves to the tax rate.
Other substantial increases are proposed for the library and police department budgets.
Also at the meeting, the selectmen decided to keep a single tax rate for the town. Pending Department of Revenue approval, the tax rate will increase from $5.41 per $1,000 of valuation to $5.70. This translates to an increase of $248 for an average property valued at $960,563.
The town has not been told when the state will approve the valuations.
In other business, an environmental consulting firm has been hired to coordinate a yearlong study of the Mill Brook watershed.
The ESS Group has been awarded a $30,000 contract to manage data collection on the 3,700-acre freshwater river system in West Tisbury.
ESS, the sole bidder, will produce a report in one year, members of the Mill Brook watershed management committee told selectmen.
The study has a broad scope, which includes a review of existing data, water quality sampling at several points throughout the watershed, measurement of water flow and an examination of water diversion, inputs and use, and identifying land uses negatively affecting the water quality of the Mill Brook.
“What we are doing at this stage is collecting the data that will be used to develop a watershed management plan,” said committee member Selena Roman.
The committee expects to ask the town for additional funds for further work at the April town meeting.
If all goes according to plan, a draft watershed management plan will be presented to voters at the 2016 annual town meeting.

Comments
Just say no...enough is
paul adler west tisburyJust say no...enough is enough. It is time Town's learn how to make money without taxing it's residents, like they do in smart countries.
As one town official said to
Peter Fyler West TisburyAs one town official said to me a number of years ago, and I paraphrase, "If you people would stop saying 'YES' to everything at the annual town meeting we would not need to raise taxes". As Paul said, "Just say no ..."
Agreed with the above. Off
RB WTAgreed with the above. Off island I recall a State Rep standing up and saying "everything which is brought up seems to be a great idea, however, every time you raise your hands and say yes to something you will see your tax bill increase, and I don't think that seems to be sinking in".
What is insane are the
BMWhat is insane are the contractual agreements which go up no matter what you cut. I say let them strike!
We do have a conscience Skip.
Michael Marcus West TisburyWe do have a conscience Skip. As a community we have a collective conscience to provide our kids with an excellent education...and we do that very well and will continue to do so. In my opinion the most important thing we can provide to the next generation is a great education. Whether these kids stay on the Island or travel to the far reaches of the World we should provide them with the tools to pursue whatever opportunities that their passions direct them. I won't opine on how the Town spends the rest of its money...but on education I will make no compromise.
Of course education is our
paul adler WEST TISBURYOf course education is our best legacy, but how much we spend may not be related. It is intelligent spending that helps our children, not wasteful spending.
Right on!
Brian Smith OBRight on!
It is not helpful for you to
Juleann VanBelle West TisburyIt is not helpful for you to insist on "no compromise" when it comes to school spending. Perhaps your financial resources aren't limited and a rising tax bill won't impact your ability to pay for the other basic needs of life. For many of the rest of us the concern is real -- our incomes are not rising at the rate of 6.7%. I suspect that a review of the contractual agreements would shed light on possible areas to save -- or at least to moderate the automatic increases to reflect the financial realities of the rest of the community.
Contractual agreements =
DS W TisburyContractual agreements = Teacher's Union Contracts. In our stagnent economy teachers recieve pay raises every year.Many in the private sector have lost ground.So why is it fair to residents who have a stagnent income at best to have to continue to pay for salery increases for teachers. Oh yes! of course "It's for the Children"! School spending is and has been out of control for years with no end in sight. AMEN
Agree with most here, vote no
Ben WTAgree with most here, vote no in April. And what's with the online photo of the graveyard above this tax story? A subtle "death and taxes" message? And the caption . . . "Residents of bucolic West Tisbury will spend more for public education this year." The "residents" in this graveyard won't spend more, they're dead, but perhaps they can vote no too.
There's absolutely no
Brian Smith Oak BluffsThere's absolutely no correlation between what a community spends on education and student achievement. Over the last forty years student per pupil spending in this country has tripled adjusted for inflation. Student performance has remained poor and actually declined in mathematics and verbal skills. We need to ask ourselves how private schools seemingly provide a better education for a third less cost.
The decline in standards
HTP III, WT/St. George BahamasThe decline in standards began in Oak Bluffs and crept into Vineyard Haven, some time in the 90s The norm for port towns. However, as a seasonal Resident of West Tisbury, I have been terribly alarmed by the general slide in our rural community. While I don't enjoy a rising tax bill, I think it is safe to say that this drop in the bucket is well worth the annoyance if it sets us on the right path. My family treasures our time on the island, and will gladly pay up if it helps to reverse this trend towards the shabby. I hope the year 'round residents, who pay pennies to the seasonal residents' dollars will recognize this for what it is...a small price to pay to keep things nice and tidy...and the real tax base infatuated with the island and its local businesses.
A great many residents here
Benoit Baldwin West TisburyA great many residents here would be happy if you just sent in your tax payments and stayed where you are. Last summer, someone tagged the stop signs at both ends of Old County Road with the Vineyard slogan "Summer people. Some are not." The graffiti is still there, as of today, February 11. A frequent comment I get in my taxis: "Gee, you must hate it when all of us tourists are here." My reply: "No, that is how I make a living. The worst people to deal with are the ones who live here year-round." Don't think for one second the Ye Olde New England inbred hicks and washashore hippie socialists running this place aren't spending your tax dollars like drunken sailors, on things that have NOTHING to do with making its visitors (AKA golden geese) feel comfortable and welcome.
Only one tax rate in WT. No
MmcOnly one tax rate in WT. No year round residential exemption in WT as there is in VH.
Add new comment