Oak Bluffs is one of 10 communities included in a national exhibit planned to inaugurate the The National Museum of African American History and Culture.
A rich history familiar to Vineyarders will soon reach a national audience.
Oak Bluffs is one of 10 communities included in a national exhibit planned to inaugurate the The National Museum of African American History and Culture, set to open on the Washington Mall in late 2015.
The town, a treasured summer community among middle and upper class African Americans for more than a century, will help tell a larger, underrepresented history of black leisure, Smithsonian curators said this week.
“There are certain ways that African American history gets portrayed, and showing the life on Martha’s Vineyard allows us to picture a life through a different prism,” said curator Dr. Paul Gardullo in a telephone interview. “It gives them a new look at a culture they think they may know.”
The show, Places of Pride, will replicate two cottage porch scenes, and incorporate artifacts and local knowledge from the Oak Bluffs community.
The Island’s first black-owned inn, Shearer Cottage, will feature prominently alongside the Powell Cottage, owned by the late Adam Clayton Powell Jr.
Mr. Gardullo’s colleague, Kevin Strait, already knew the Island well before he began his research. His father has a home in West Tisbury, and his mother, a home in Oak Bluffs.
But this project opened his eyes to a richer history than even he, a historian, was aware of.
“Little did I know so much history existed in the backyard of our summer home,” he said.
The exhibit will speak to those already familiar with the town’s black history, as well as those who have no knowledge of the Island or Oak Bluffs.
“We are really going to focus on questions related to regional identity and black leisure in the era of segregation,” Mr. Gardullo said.
The Smithsonian began collecting artifacts and information about the Island’s African American history a few years ago, and will continue to shape the exhibit in advance of the museum’s opening.
They came to the Island on a few occasions, meeting with several local historians, including Elaine Weintraub, board chairman of the African American Heritage Trail, and Robert Hayden, president of the Martha’s Vineyard branch of the Association for the Study of African American Life and History.
Islanders helped to shape their vision, and broaden the perspective of the exhibit, from a focus on vacation to a larger narrative of black success, and multi-generational Oak Bluffs home ownership, Mrs. Weintraub said.
“I think that Oak Bluffs is enriched by the African American community on so many different levels, and I think its inclusion is absolutely essential to any exhibition,” she said.
Gretchen Tucker-Underwood, who spent many summers with her aunt in town and now lives in the family home full time, said many assume that the vacationing on the Island was only for the wealthy.
“I think too many people don’t understand the magic of the Vineyard, especially talking about the Bluffs,” she said.
In the 1950s and 1960s, kids entertained themselves bike riding, and watching coin diving near the ferry dock.
“There were a group of 10 or 12 young, rather handsome boys who would swim out to the Oak Bluffs ferry and request coins,” she recalled. Then these “fine specimens of lads” would dive down to retrieve them, she said.
Mr. Gardullo said that while the Smithsonian is often thought of as the keeper of historical knowledge, they often cede to local sources.
“In a place like Martha’s Vineyard, where there is such a rich sense of history and pride and heritage, we don’t want to assume that we know the story,” he said.
Cookbook author and historian Jessica Harris, part-time Oak Bluffs resident, donated an old lawnmower and a kerosene lamp from her family cottage, which dates to the 1870s. She hosted the curators and several longstanding members of the African American community in her home, including Olive Tomlinson, who shared photographs taken by her father of productions put on by the Shearer Summer Theatre with the museum.
“All of them were amateur thespians, and my father was the amateur photographer,” Ms. Tomlinson recalled. “He took black and whites and developed them himself in the closet.”
He would have been proud to know his photographs were being studied by historians, she said. “When I give the pictures, it is really for my father,” she said.
As a whole, the exhibit seeks to demonstrate the richness and diversity of African American culture through the lens of region and culture, Mr. Gardullo said. “We knew we wanted to tell it through intimate stories that rooted visitors in particular places, across the north, south, east and western regions,” he said. “Oak Bluffs rose to the top of a very short list of places.”
The other sites under consideration include Tulsa, the Black West, the rice fields of South Carolina, Chicago, the Bronx, Greenville, Miss., and a hat shop in Philadelphia.
Visit nmaahc.si.edu for more information.

Comments
My husband is one of those
Sandi OBMy husband is one of those handsome young boys who would swim out to the Oak Bluffs ferry, request coins, and dive down to retrieve them. He tells the story today just as it occurred when he was a kid growing up in Oak Bluffs. He also remember the days when they would swim out to the "raft" at the INKWELL and dive from it. Lastly, those fierce competitions of basketball games at the OB basketball courts against summer guys from around the country.
Remember it well, NY against
Frank (Steve) Daniel OBRemember it well, NY against Boston in the field across from the Inkwell and swimming to the "black buoy" wow!!!
MY SONS ALSO DIVE FOR COINS
Louis Lambert 7WAPELLO ST.OAK BLUFFSMY SONS ALSO DIVE FOR COINS WHEN THEY VISIT THEIR GRAND MOTHER,MRS.VIRGINIA LAMBERT.SHE OWN A HOME AT 7 WAPELLO IN OB.
:-)
Skip OB:-)
Yes, we use to play King
Richard Walker BostonYes, we use to play King/Queen of the raft and push each other off to see who was the last person standing. A certain columnist we know threatened me after I pushed him off to become king one day! :-) After the swim back to shore, we'd often head over to the snack bar at the Seaview Hotel across from the Inkwell and have those grilled hot dogs which at the time seemed the most delicious in the world.
Hey Richard, haven't seen you
JAMES HEATHMAN Houston, TexasHey Richard, haven't seen you in years!!!! Remember those days well.
This is Crumpy
crumpy! What's up dude? Yeah,
Richard Walker Bostoncrumpy! What's up dude? Yeah, still have the house. Have to keep it rented a lot cause I had to borrow against it to pay for my mothers Alzheimer's care. Otherwise doing great!
Richard , how is your family
Ernest Garvin Elm Mott ,TxRichard , how is your family and do you still summer across from the elementary school. I was the year round resident waiting
For everyone to return in the summer.
History: In 1962, I delivered many special deliveries at $0.35 each to the Sherer Cottages.
Earnie, good to hear from you
Richard Walker bostonEarnie, good to hear from you man! How''s your brother Steve? Are you still a pharmicist?
My Father Ronald Faust and
Reynaldo Faust Oak BluffsMy Father Ronald Faust and his Cousin Jimmy Alston - I think may have been one of those " fine specimens of lads" Gretchen was talking about. I constantly get stopped on the street from older woman that tell me how handsome my father was and how they would spend every summer on the Vineyard as teenagers - coin diving and chasing girls....it must have been a great time. My summers consisted of working three jobs so I can have some spending money for college lol
Hello,
Laura Alston New JerseyHello,
I see your post is from 2014, but I want to reach out anyway. I am Jimmy Alston's niece and remember the name Ronald Faust. I haven't been to Oak Bluffs for many years; but really want to finally take my grown children and grands. If we're related, we should connect somehow :-) take care, Laura
There were girls that dove
DeborahThere were girls that dove for coins also,i was one.
Yes, there were girls that
JAMES HEATHMAN Houston, TexasYes, there were girls that dove for coins. Both of my cousins dove for them. After the boat left we would pitch the coins at the curb to try and get more money. Great days of summer.
And yes, Those hot dogs and
JAMES HEATHMAN Houston, TexasAnd yes, Those hot dogs and popsicles at the Seaview were great back then.
Does anyone remember
Saundi VirginiaDoes anyone remember Flintstones or the Frosty Cottage?
I lived for those summers at the Bluffs. Even though you did not keep up with your friends during the winter, we always picked up where we left off the following summer.
Katama Beach parties!
Yes I remember Flintstones.
JAMES HEATHMAN Houston, TexasYes I remember Flintstones. It was down the street from where I lived and was run by one of my classmates family. Loved their fried clams.
I am the owner of Fat Ronnies
Reynaldo Faust Oak BluffsI am the owner of Fat Ronnies, what was once called The Frosty Cottage, if anyone has any pics of the business back then or when it was called Mr. C's....I'd love to hang them in my restaurant.
Fat Ronnie's Hamburgers is
Skip OBFat Ronnie's Hamburgers is now where Frosty Cottage was
I believe this telling of
Deborah Davis PennsylvaniaI believe this telling of history on the island will be a superb presentation at the museum I look forward, as part time island resident, to seeing.Can't wait!!
What a great compliment to
thomas dresser oak bluffsWhat a great compliment to Oak Bluffs. We should be proud of our community for preserving this Island paradise. I appreciate the recollections of those who lived the life all those years ago. What a great way to preserve an important part of history. Good story. Well done.
I was one of those teens in
Roger Mitchell Sarasota, FloridaI was one of those teens in the 50's that dove for coins while the steamers were at the OB steamship wharf. While at the Inkwell we would see them coming over the horizon from Nantucket and head for the wharf. Yes, the Seaview hotdogs were the best!
that's my mom (Gloria Pope)
lance pope venice, floridathat's my mom (Gloria Pope) on the right in the picture. she was visiting the island on holiday from Boston University graduate school and stayed at Shearer Cottage which was and still is owned by my father's (Lincoln Pope) side of the family. she was staying at Shearer, he was working at Shearer. they met, got married and out popped me and my two brothers (lincoln III and Leland)
I am so deeply grateful and
Loren Oak BluffsI am so deeply grateful and proud of my great, great parents, Charles and Henrietta Shearer, for starting this legacy for our family. Great article!!
My grandfather and Adam
S. Johnson BostonMy grandfather and Adam Clayton bought their cottages around the same time. Our house and the "round house" are diagonally across from the "Bunny Cottage". Isabelle Powell and my gran were the best of friends. I think she belonged to a group called the "Cottagers"
Yes...they where called the
Reynaldo Faust Oak BluffsYes...they where called the cottagers, my Great Aunt Maggie Alston was one of the Founders of The Cottagers and they bought Cottage Corner. When I was a tween, that was the hot spot to meet girls at the Friday night dance.
Link, SOO happy you
Tweetye Carter LALink, SOO happy you identified your Mom in that shot!! Huge Grin. Love these shots. Crumpy and Ernie "seeing" you guys (your comments) is great!!
Hope you are both doing well!
What a joy reading all these
Pamela Norris Maui, HawaiiWhat a joy reading all these comments from all of you. Some of you I have not seen in years. Sold our family property in OB last year but oh the memories at the Inkwell, house parties, tennis tournaments, and hanging out on Circuit Ave.
I was a girl diver of coins
Denyse Bardouille Oak BluffsI was a girl diver of coins at the OB dock. The Uncatena would dock and my cousins and I,all girls,would yell to those disembarking, "How 'bout a quarter?" Ripped a toe on the nails on pier and Dr.Rappaport, on Circuit Ave.sewed me up. Wonderful memories...
Link,remember,Mrs.O'Brien, at
Denyse (Williams) Bardouille/ daughter of Cercy- Boston Oak BluffsLink,remember,Mrs.O'Brien, at the'rock'on Circuit Ave. Ext. She babysat for all of us while our parents partied on the island.We earned our keep by bicycling to Takemy Laundry at the airport.We worked from early in the morning til noon folding sheets on those steaming machines.I believe it was greatest job I had ever had...at 12 years old!!!
Add new comment