<p>A faded yellow building that once housed the Oak Bluffs laundromat may become the future site of a bowling alley.</p> <p>Reid (Sam) Dunn, the architect who developed the Tisbury Marketplace in Vineyard Haven, presented a preliminary proposal to open a bowling alley, restaurant and bar on Uncas avenue to the town selectmen Tuesday.</p> <p>“This is totally informational,” Mr. Dunn said. “We wanted to let you know that the project is in the works.”</p>
A faded yellow building that once housed the Oak Bluffs laundromat may become the future site of a bowling alley.
Reid (Sam) Dunn, the architect who developed the Tisbury Marketplace in Vineyard Haven, presented a preliminary proposal to open a bowling alley, restaurant and bar on Uncas avenue to the town selectmen Tuesday.
“This is totally informational,” Mr. Dunn said. “We wanted to let you know that the project is in the works.”
Mr. Dunn described his two-story planned family bowling center as a bright place with lanes, pool tables, a restaurant, bar and a game room upstairs. The game room would feature what Mr. Dunn called “wholesome games,” like ping pong and shuffleboard, not video games. He said he planned to hang photographs by local artists or historic photographs of the town on the outside of the building facing the A Gallery.
“We hope to make it a place that’s more Vineyard-centric, and that will also be true on the menu,” he said.
The project would still need approval from the Martha’s Vineyard Commission, among an assortment of permitting and licensing hurdles before it could become reality — likely a two-year process.
At the meeting, Mr. Dunn tested the likelihood of winning approval from the selectmen for a liquor license, the first major hurdle in his project. “No one is going to build this building unless they know they can have a liquor license,” he told the board.
Selectmen said they would need more information, such as operating hours, capacity and seating arrangements.
Selectman Gail Barmakian expressed concerns about parking and locating a business that serves alcohol service in a site so close to a residential neighborhood. “Really it looks more like a sports bar with bowling alleys on the side,” she said. Mr. Dunn said he wasn’t ready to specify business hours. “We have a very long way to go here,” he said. “This is a totally preliminary plan, and all of these questions will be addressed as we go along . . . I wanted to let you know that this is percolating.”
The building has no septic system capability and there is no sewer, so plans would include composting toilets, Mr. Dunn said.
Several decades have passed since bowling was available in Oak Bluffs. In the 1960s, there were two bowling alleys: one in the current Sovereign Bank building, and another at the Sand Bar. The most recent bowling alley was located on Beach Road in Vineyard Haven but closed in the early 1980s. “There wasn’t enough interest in bowling,” proprietor Al Brickman said in February of 1981 after converting his facility into a roller skating parlor.
Two people spoke in favor of Mr. Dunn’s project at the meeting.
“I just want to say, that building has been empty and an eyesore for so long, and whatever it takes to put something positive in there, whatever the process is to make it work and have it fitted to the community, and the residents around there are happy with it, I am all for it,” said Oak Bluffs Association executive director Christine Todd.
Finance committee chairman Steve Auerbach also voiced support. “It has been so gross for so long, and here is an opportunity to make it first rate and add to the town’s business climate. We should look forward to cooperating and going ahead with this,” he said.
Selectman Michael Santoro marveled at Mr. Dunn’s willingness to take on difficult construction projects.
“Mr. Dunn, I have to ask you, are you crazy after what you went through with the Tisbury Marketplace at the commission? You are ready to do that again?” Mr. Santoro asked.
“You know, some people just like to flagellate themselves,” Mr. Dunn said, laughing.
“You know I’m only kidding,” Mr. Santoro said.
Selectmen also heard a request from Adult and Community Education of Martha’s Vineyard (ACE MV), to contribute $27,000 in town funds to help keep the organization going after this academic year.
Between 2008 and 2012, enrollment at the community education school increased by 92 per cent. Executive director Lynn Ditchfield said her limited staff cannot accommodate the program needs without additional funds. She will seek a total of $110,000 from all the towns this fall. “We won’t continue without the support of the towns, it’s really that simple,” Mrs. Ditchfield said.
Selectmen praised the adult education program but said they didn’t believe it was legal for the town to give money to a nonprofit organization. And even if it was legal, selectmen said they weren’t sure the town could afford it. Selectman Gregory Coogan noted that the town had already cut funding for the elementary school in recent years.
“We don’t have a lot of money lying around,” he said.
Mr. Santoro wondered if ACE had considered increasing enrollment fees to cover administrative costs.
“We do not have students that can pay,” Ms. Ditchfield said. “I feel horrible, to be honest, charging what we have to charge.”
Ms. Barmakian suggested that ACE approach the school superintendent to ask to be included into the school system’s budget, like the Nantucket Community School, also an adult education program. She said the towns could fund the program indirectly through the school district’s budget.
“It’s certainly a valuable service, it really is,” Ms. Barmakian said.
ACE will appeal to the other Island towns in the coming months.
In other business, selectmen said a bylaw at the November special town meeting that would regulate blight in the business districts will be withdrawn on the town meeting floor. Town administrator Robert Whritenour said he’d like to see more input from property owners and community members. “I think it’s been a real positive source of discussion in the community and we want to keep it that way,” he said.
Selectmen plan to bring the bylaw before voters at the April annual town meeting instead.

Comments
This should have read, The
Joe Oak BluffsThis should have read, The most recent bowling alley was located on State Road Road in Vineyard Haven (Spinnaker Lanes) but closed. There was plenty of interest in bowling and after a successful season or two the rent increases outpaced the income derived and the Goodells had to shut her down.
Yikes, how could they have
Susanna J. Sturgis West TisburyYikes, how could they have missed that?? Thanks for the correction, Joe. Spinnaker Lanes was wonderful, even for crappy bowlers like me. I still miss it every time I drive by there.
About time something is
Frank Collins EdgartownAbout time something is proposed for the year-round community, who will whole-heartedly support it.Need much more -platform tennis is a great winter sport,esp. for anyone getting older or with movement difficulties coming on. Edgartown ignores the winter population, Park Dept. and selectmen. Support this venture.
What happened to the septic
George Stein EdgartownWhat happened to the septic system for the laundromat?
The Town of Oak Bluffs needs
Joe Alosso Oak Bluffs/ConnecticutThe Town of Oak Bluffs needs to begin thinking about economical development. The idea of working with individuals to begin businesses is town that will bring both year round work as well as year round enjoyment. This way of thinking is a little bit out of the box for the towns on MV, there usually quite content with 1 to 3 season t-shirt and trinket shops that lend little to nothing to the community.
Sewers are accessible from here (at a cost) and capacity is available at the plant, a forward thinking town would work with the developer to arrange an agreement where the developer would pay the up front costs of piping installation in exchange for a set period of reduced taxes (say 5 years, let's face it, we're not getting much on it now) In exchange the town would receive a new year round business, with year round employment, full taxes after 5 years, enjoyment for islanders, and the added benefit of removing nitrogen from the Farm Pond Watershed. Oh well, I guess a guy can dream.
While year round recreation
Diane Streett Oak Bluffs homeownerWhile year round recreation is nice, this proposal is really for a bar with some bowling. A sports bar should not be located in this area of Oak Bluffs; this congested area does not need another bar. This is a quiet, quaint neighborhood. A bar will negatively impact the historic and residential nature of the community,increase parking problems for the senior center,unduly add traffic to a narrow street, need sidewalks, bring 18 hours of daily activity (early morning deliveries through closing time loiterers,strain our already strained municipal services, and reduce property values that will ultimately reduce property taxes.
Dianne Streett is exactly
Lisa Stewart Crisp Uncas Ave. homeownerDianne Streett is exactly correct. While there are commercial entities in this neighborhood, none of them have unrelenting 7 day a week late night hours. One look at the plans it is clear the bar is a key part of this operation. Plans also show the entry and exit of the proposed parking lot on Uncas within feet of the bank parking lot entry (note that the small parking lot of the bank has an exit on Circuit Ave). How are all these cars going to fit on this tiny street? It is already barely passable at times during the summer. A family bowling experience does not include a bar. How many 9 year olds are going to be bowling at 11:00pm, really? Oak Bluffs is already well supplied in the bar area. In my opinion, the noise and loitering associated with last call at the bar will be sure to keep the Oak Bluffs police department busy especially during the summer season.
Martha’s Vineyard Commission
Deborah Arrindell Oak BluffMartha’s Vineyard Commission Playa Vista,CA
PO Box 1447 Feb 5, 2014
Oak Bluffs, MA 02557
Dear Martha’s Vineyard Commission,
I write to you as the owner of 26 Pocasset Ave (corner of Uncas). It has come to my attention that a “bowling alley/bar” is being proposed for Uncas Ave. I recently purchased the Pocasset property in July of 2013 with the intent to build a retirement home. I am extremely distressed to hear that a bowling alley/bar is going to be built on Uncas; that will in my opinion destroy the neighborhood atmosphere that appealed to me in purchasing the property. The bowling alley will be open late, will attract more traffic to the neighborhood, will increase the number of individuals loitering in the neighborhood, increase the amount of noise, decrease the property values, and overall is not a good fit. Looking out of my home and seeing a bowling alley, parking lot, people getting in and out of cars, and being loud is not how I pictured my retirement on Martha’s Vineyard. It also appears from my review of some documents that the establishment, although being pitched as a bowling alley, is really a huge bar. This is out of character with the neighborhood (quaintness, historic). I am in the process of having plans approved for my home and received a lot of feedback from various commissions/boards that the house should give the sense of Victorianism/history (no plastic windows, wraparound porch). So I struggle with how a 13,500 sq bowling alley can be allowed to be built within the lines of the Cottage City History District and not be felt to impact the historic nature of the community.
It is always nice to have places for people to go; however, on the edge of a historic residential neighborhood is not the place for a commercial establishment such as a bowling alley/bar that is going to be open late serving alcohol 7 days a week. A better fit for the bowling alley is on Circuit Ave or the other end of town; closer to other commercial establishments. If I had known that a bowling alley was going to be built on Uncas Ave I would not have purchased my property. The current location of my retirement home appealed to me because of the quietness of the area and this should be maintained. Other uses for the building should be considered such as art gallery or bookstore. A bowling alley/bar is out of character with this neighborhood and will in the end do more harm than good.
Best regards,
Deborah Arrindell MD MPH JD
Add new comment