Selectmen Reject Lone Bid for Warren House, Will Try Again

<p>Edgartown selectmen Monday rejected a bid to buy the Warren House, a rundown town-owned former captain&rsquo;s house on North Water street.</p> <p>After a discussion in executive session with town counsel Ronald H. Rappaport, the selectmen said the bid by a group including Edgartown businesswoman Maggie White was too low. The board voted to put the house advertisement back in the central registry with a minimum bid of $2.3 million.</p>

Edgartown selectmen Monday rejected a bid to buy the Warren House, a rundown town-owned former captain’s house on North Water street.

After a discussion in executive session with town counsel Ronald H. Rappaport, the selectmen said the bid by a group including Edgartown businesswoman Maggie White was too low. The board voted to put the house advertisement back in the central registry with a minimum bid of $2.3 million.

Ms. White and investors Christopher Celeste and his wife Nancy Kramer of Facing West Ventures LLC bid $1.25 million cash or $1 million and 40 per cent of proceeds on the house at 62 North Water street. It was the only bid the town received.

Selectman and board chairman Margaret Serpa said neither of the bids “meet the obligation that the town presently has on this piece of property.”

The selectmen voted to put the building back in the central registry as soon as possible with a minimum price of $2.3 million, offering brokers a three per cent commission if they bring in a customer.

The town bought the circa-1790 building in 2004 for $3.5 million, planning at the time to expand the library next door.

Expansion plans proved unfeasible, and the library will be built elsewhere. The town put the house on the market last fall with a minimum bid of $2.5 million, but received no bids.

The second bidding process began in December with no minimum bids.

Town administrator Pamela Dolby said she had received a number of phone calls and interest in the property since news of the bid appeared in the newspaper.

“Certainly we’re disappointed,” Ms. White, who owns the Hob Knob Inn, Hob Knob Realty and Hob Knob Construction, told the Gazette Wednesday. She noted that she heard positive things from people in Edgartown regarding her plans. “I think that we will circle back to the selectmen and have further discussions . . . see if a deal is possible to be made,” she said. “We’re forever hopeful,” she said about the chance to renovate the building and “take care of the village the way it should be.” The Edgartown selectmen did give the green light for the town to participate in Cape Light Compact’s new LED streetlight project, which will bring savings by reducing the town’s streetlight bill.

Through the Cape Light Compact’s energy efficiency program, the town’s 288 mercury vapor streetlights will be replaced with LED lights at no cost to the town except for the cost of police detail during installation.

“It’s a really wonderful idea and the time has come,” selectman Arthur Smadbeck said. “And having it funded through Cape Light Compact is a boon to the town, of course.”

The street light project is also taking place in other Vineyard and Cape towns.

Demonstration lights were installed this spring in Edgartown: five on Edgartown-Vineyard Haven Road between the Triangle and the animal shelter, and five on Pease’s Point Way between the fire station and Main street.

Highway superintendent Stuart Fuller said there have been two comments on the lights, both favorable.

Program manager Kevin Galligan said the project would go out to bid in July, and selectmen could set any terms and conditions for the project. The installation project would begin in January 2014, he said, and bucket trucks doing the installation would be off the road by this time next year.

In Edgartown, the town would see $23,800 in energy savings in fiscal year 2015.

Mr. Galligan said the LED lights last longer, with a shelf life of 10 to 15 years, and have lower maintenance costs.

In other business, selectmen approved a memorandum of understanding between the Coast Guard stations Menemsha and Woods Hole and the town of Edgartown that will provide mutual assistance for marine incidents in Edgartown, with thanks to the Coast Guard for taking time to train Edgartown officers. The agreement “puts us on the same playing field for law enforcement,” police chief Antone Bettencourt said. The agreement comes as Edgartown launches a new police boat on the harbor. Mr. Bettencourt said U.S. Coast Guard senior chief Jason Olsen reached out to the town to offer assistance with training for the boat. Eleven people in the boat training program received 70 hours of training apiece, he said, and Coast Guard officers provided training at no cost and “sometimes on their own time.” The selectmen rejected a request to put a restroom trailer at the foot of Fuller street for a wedding rehearsal fireworks show Friday night, noting that they are uncomfortable with allowing the trailer on town-owned property.

Comments

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 06/11/2013 - 10:06

Permalink

Sue C. Palm Harbor, FL

Whoever buys this beautiful home should be someone who wants to restore it to its original beauty. 350 million dollar lottery and it would have been mine and become one of Edgartown's finest homes!!!

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 06/11/2013 - 12:58

Permalink

Muffin Klein

Is the town allowed to set up a raffle with a ticket sale minimum? I would think it possible to sell 35000 tickets for $100 each. Better odds than the lottery, Sue C.!

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 06/11/2013 - 13:59

Permalink

jim j McLean, VA

Let's see, bought in 04, pre crash, at inflated price, and now they can't get what they think its worth? Was the Vineyard that isolated from reality in 08 when the rest of the country has their "realty reality check" ? Town should;ve taken the bid.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 06/11/2013 - 16:11

Permalink

Paulli D Edgartown

this was the right move. Why should the taxpayers fund the development of this property by people who have the 'ins' with the town. If Ms White wants the property, pay the value! Edgartown needs parking, why not just make it a paying parking lot and give some kid a job for the summer?

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 06/11/2013 - 17:08

Permalink

Jim Edgartown

The town will not get $2.3M but will get much more than the great deal Maggie wanted for herself. Yes the town paid too much for the property when they bought it but that was because a small group of library lovers promised over and over again they would never come back and ask the town for more money if we bought that building. It would be nice if one of those original library pushers stepped up and bought this building and help save the town now that the town is building them a new library. I wonder how many millions the new library is costing the town after all the promises made that we would not have to spend anymore after the purchase of the Warren house.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 06/12/2013 - 13:26

Permalink

Scott Edgartown

Fair value is what the market decides it is. Fair value is not a number decided by the town or anyone else who isn't willing and/or able to step up themselves and make a bid. More than once, the market has spoken on the value of this property, and it isn't $2+ million. As for the taxpayers, this money has already been spent by the town. It is a sunk cost. I agree that it is a shame that the town may lose money, but they should have been smarter on the buy.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 06/18/2013 - 06:27

Permalink

Jim McCann New York

What a laugh....the town offers a measley three percent commission? On top of that they share the details of offers so enterprising people who actually have the interest to bid and structure well structured bids can then be castigated or criticized by the ' community'. No wonder they have no leads and no sense of getting real value. Perhaps the town should focus less on insulting buyers and brokers -- have the courage to admit they made a major mistake, and get the best bid possible and move on or simply ante up and declare it a park and demolish and renovate that area as a little greenbelt----otherwise the town deserves to just watch the old house crumble and spend money trying to maintain a false position.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 06/18/2013 - 13:07

Permalink

Dan Chilmark

As a former Town Planner I can tell you that the government is the worst possible owner of historic property. Edgartown should never have bought the parcel, but now that they have, they have to take a realistic look at the property and what the highest and best use of it would be. Think long-term now. Take a $1.25 Million bid, watch the investor sink another $750k+ into historic preservation-style restoration work, and gain not only the rejuvenation of a truly historic house but the tax $$ year after year. Scott is right. It's a sunk cost to the Town now. You'll never get that $3.5 Million in '04 back. But you may get private ownership paying property tax on an assessed valuation of $3 Million for the next 100 years, and restore a great historic house. The Town can't "win" on its lost bet, but it can get the best use and value out of the site. A parking lot doesn't generate $$ like a structure in private ownership and taxation does, and unless you want to tear down a historic house and put up a multi-story parking garage, the benefit to the congestion downtown will be minimal. Think long term, and take the bid and let the house be renovated. Then take the $$ in the form of property tax and learn that towns shouldn't buy private property without a really good plan – with signatures to agreements and studies – in place.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 07/03/2013 - 13:35

Permalink

Martha Magee

Maggie knows what she's doing. She'll do a great job. A great old house needs to be understood and loved. No brainer!

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.