Tisbury Officer Facing Criminal Charges

<p>A Tisbury police officer is facing several charges in Edgartown district court after allegedly interfering with firefighters trying to fight a dryer fire at her home.</p> <p>Kelly R. Kershaw, 30, will be charged with interfering with a firefighter, assault and battery on a police officer, disorderly conduct and threat to commit a crime; the complaint was issued last Wednesday and an arraignment scheduled for that Friday was continued to June 28. Ms. Kershaw is a Tisbury police officer currently on leave.</p>

A Tisbury police officer is facing several charges in Edgartown district court after allegedly interfering with firefighters trying to fight a dryer fire at her home.

Kelly R. Kershaw, 30, will be charged with interfering with a firefighter, assault and battery on a police officer, disorderly conduct and threat to commit a crime; the complaint was issued last Wednesday and an arraignment scheduled for that Friday was continued to June 28. Ms. Kershaw is a Tisbury police officer currently on leave.

According to documents filed in court, the Tisbury fire department responded to a dryer fire at Officer Kershaw’s Lagoon Pond Road residence on May 9 at 2 a.m. Police reports filed by Officers Joseph Ballotte and Jason Marathas stated that when they arrived on the scene, Officer Kershaw showed signs of intoxication and was concerned about her pet chicken.

Both officers wrote that the police and fire personnel repeatedly asked her to leave the fire scene. “Officer Kershaw was acting in [an] extremely aggressive manner towards us as we informed her that she had to leave the area,” Officer Marathas wrote. He said Officer Kershaw allegedly screamed and swore at the officers. “I informed her that she had to leave the yard now and she again yelled and threatened to kill me,” he wrote, adding that he knew that she was a sworn police officer with a valid license to carry firearms.

Officer Marathas said that at one point, Officer Kershaw swung at him and hit him on his left forearm.

“Officer Kershaw’s hysterical, aggressive and assaultive behavior caused several of the Tisbury fire fighters to stop fighting the fire so they could get out of the way,” Officer Marathas wrote.

An Oak Bluffs police officer was called to assist.

Officer Kershaw was physically removed from the scene several times by her father, the officers wrote, and eventually remained at her grandparents’ home, which was across the street from the fire scene.

“Throughout the course of this incident, Ms. Kershaw repeatedly attempted to gain access to her chicken pen, inserting herself into the middle of an active fire scene before being stopped by fire personnel,” Tisbury fire chief John F. Schilling wrote in a May 13 email to Tisbury police chief Dan Hanavan. “It was a very disappointing turn of events to have to address these kinds of issues from an “off duty” officer, especially since her actions distracted from our efforts to affect a timely resolution to the incident.”

Chief Schilling said that in response to Officer Kershaw’s concerns, a firefighter checked on the status of the chicken, and confirmed it was safe and not in danger.

According to Officer Ballotte’s police report, the fire damaged wiring and charred the floor beams that support the first floor of the house.

Comments

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sat, 05/18/2013 - 08:47

Permalink

Sick Citizen in Tisbury! Tisbury

If she is claiming that she has "PTSD" which is what "combat veterans" suffer from they should have taken her gun and badge away on the spot as combat veterans suffering and being treated for "PTSD" and who are also be known to have drug and or alcohol issues are not allowed to even buy BB's never mind carry a gun!
This whole thing stinks and makes me sick - once again!

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sat, 05/18/2013 - 10:49

Permalink

VeryAnnoyed Tisbury

She should have been disarmed and removed from service after the "stripper" incident! Good Article Sara Brown!

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sat, 05/18/2013 - 12:13

Permalink

Joseph Balonki Vineyard Haven

I THINK WE NEED SOME OFFICIAL / PUBLIC COMMENT(S) TO BE ADDRESSED IN FRONT OF THE TISBURY SELECTMEN TO ANSWER QUESTIONS WHY THERE HAVE BEEN SEVERAL, EMBARRASSING, EXPENSIVE AND QUESTIONABLE ACTIONS OF OUR PUBLIC SERVANTS OVER SEVERAL YEARS NOW AND MOST ARE STILL PENDING!

AM I ALONE HERE?

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sun, 05/19/2013 - 07:06

Permalink

John Somewhere-in-the-Middle, USA

The Wheels of Justice grind slowly forward, but they grind even more slowly when police law-breaking and misconduct are involved. They abuse the law more frequently than average law-abiding citizens, and then they help each other cover up those abuses by whatever means possible. I am always amazed when any hint of wrong-doing even makes it into the newspapers. Take away the badge and gun!! Prosecute as if this were not a cop involved! Do not simply allow this cop to "retire" and possibly take further advantage of the system.

JJ OB

I don't think the wheels of justice grind slower when officers are involved since the complaint was filed against her on wednesday and her arraignment was on friday. that does not happen to the general citizens. special circumstance since she is an officer.

VH CITIZEN VH

Re-read the story, although it looks like she appeared for an arraignment, it is reported that her arraignment will not be until 6-28-13. This is at the request of her attorney, which I have seen before, said attorney buying some time to try to make this obvious full out attack on Kershaw go away before then. In case you don't know, she was scheduled to report back to work this week, was told to get her nessecary gear, vest, uniforms etc, and was on the boat coming home and TPD serves her with this stuff right then? Coincidence? I strongly doubt it.They (TPD) took immediate and reckless actions to prevent her from going back to work and that is obvious to anyone with any law enforcement background,period. Don't get me wrong, Kershaw has been her own worst enemy in her actions on a few occasions,no doubt, but for the PD to have ANY involvement with her since the time she alleged sexual harassment by a superior officer instead of referring anything to do with her to say the State Police, stinks of vendetta and the courts and consequent settlement will bear this out, just wait and see.

John Somewhere-in-the-Middle, USA

This particular set of charges is in the top of the first inning. Let's see how long it takes to get to the ninth inning, and what the the final score turns out to be.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sun, 05/19/2013 - 14:47

Permalink

William13th In line for the Throne Michigan

I've gotta get back to the Vineyard, You guys have all the fun. This is a great story lacking only in supplying the name of the chicken. However, it's a hoot.

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.