Babu Kognati, co-owner of Indigo.
Ray Ewing

New Indian Restaurant Opens in Edgartown

Indigo opened recently in the former Sharky’s Cantina location on Upper Main street in Edgartown. It has already become a popular spot for diners.

During visits to the Vineyard in the summer, Babu Kognati noticed a lack of Indian food options. Eventually, he decided to do something about it.

On August 22, his new Indian restaurant, Indigo, opened in the former Sharky’s Cantina location on Upper Main street in Edgartown.

“People love Indian food and there’s nothing on the Island of this sort, so it’s always been in our book,” Mr. Kognati said.

Restaurant plans to be open year-round.
Ray Ewing
Restaurant plans to be open year-round.
Ray Ewing

Mr, Kognati is the co-owner of the restaurant, along with his partners at Rebel Foods Inc., which owns more than 20 restaurants off-Island including Madras Dosa Co. and Vaanga in Boston.

But opening a restaurant on the Island presented new challenges for the business.

“It’s a whole different ball game,” Mr. Kognati said. “It’s equal to opening like five [or] six restaurants in Boston because you need to figure out logistics.”

The restaurant has already become a popular spot for diners.

Opening day was August 22.
Ray Ewing
Opening day was August 22.
Ray Ewing

“The reception has been great,” Mr. Kognati said. “We’ve [had] our house full from day one. That shows how people [have been] waiting for this place to open.”

The head chef is Nikhil Naik, who previously cooked in London, and the menu includes many traditional Indian dishes, such as chicken tikka masala, lamb vindaloo and saag paneer. It also has fusion options, such as street-style noodles, burgers and tikka tots, tater tots or french fries paired with a creamy butter sauce, shredded cheese and pickled onions.

The restaurant’s cocktail menu pairs traditional spirits with spices like chaat masala, chai, cardamom and saffron.

Indigo was originally planned to open in May in time for the busy summer season, but it took longer than anticipated to get a liquor license and finish updating the building. Housing for staff was also an issue. Mr. Kognati said he reached out to Islanders who had expressed a desire for Indian food for help with finding rooms.

“I know we missed the season but we wanted to do it right,” he said.

Mr. Kognati added that the restaurant is committed to staying open year-round, and will adapt its menu during the colder months to include more comforting Indian food such as soup options and spicier curries.

“[People] want some place to eat, so we want to be that place for them,” he said.

 

Comments

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Mon, 09/01/2025 - 22:25

Permalink

George Stein OB

Greatly appreciate your courage. Housing is integral in every Island business

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 09/02/2025 - 07:36

Permalink

Chip Coblyn OB

Wonderful! Both the friendly staff and beautifully presented food are a welcome addition to the island. I give Indigo an enthusiastic thumbs up!

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 09/02/2025 - 08:04

Permalink

Caroline Little Vineyard Haven

I went there with three other people. We loved the food ! This made us happy because we all love Indian food. Happy to have this restaurant on our Island. Welcome.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 09/02/2025 - 13:13

Permalink

Katherine Kunhiraman (Kakie Siebel) Berkeley, Chennai

Namaskaram and congratulations! i hope it all works out wonderfully. If I ever get back to the Vineyard ( old home 1947-1977) I will come and request a masala dosa! anything...

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 09/03/2025 - 05:55

Permalink

Ron Vineyard Haven

My wife and I dined there last week and were extremely impressed with the quality and variety of the food. We highly recommend going there.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 09/03/2025 - 06:41

Permalink

Allison Doriss Edgartown

Congratulations on opening! We were there with friends on Labor Day! The moment you walk thru the doors you were greeted warmly by the manager! The food was outstanding! My favorite Indian restaurant is Dishoom in London and Indigo is even better!
Wishing you much success!

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 11/20/2025 - 12:52

Permalink

Rosalia Milone Charlestown/Edgartown timeshare

Delicious authentic Indian food and attention to details. Get the lamb biryani!! You will not be disappointed, honestly.

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.