Paul Beeson and Kirsten Anderson hope to reopen the Dairy Queen in June.
Ray Ewing

New Owners Scoop Up Dairy Queen

Paul Beeson and Kirsten Anderson signed a deal to buy the ice cream shop on Upper Main street from Christopher Celeste in December, and since then the couple have been working with the chain’s management to get up to speed on Blizzards and Dilly Bars. 

Edgartown’s Dairy Queen has new owners who hope to have the storied ice cream franchise up and running in June. 

Paul Beeson and Kirsten Anderson signed a deal to buy the ice cream shop on Upper Main street from Christopher Celeste in December, and since then the couple have been working with the chain’s management to get up to speed on Blizzards and Dilly Bars. 

“Everyone loves ice cream. Everyone loves Dairy Queen, and we want to continue that,” said Mr. Beeson said in an interview with the Gazette Monday. 

The new owners plan to keep the classics on the menu.
Ray Ewing
The new owners plan to keep the classics on the menu.
Ray Ewing

Mr. Beeson is a landscaper and a former Island chef and Ms. Anderson is a tax attorney. The couple first thought about taking over the Dairy Queen in September after Mr. Celeste announced he intended to sell the franchise

The idea came to Mr. Beeson when he had a hankering for ice cream after a long day in the landscaping business. Tired from 18 years of tending lawns and with a Blizzard in hand, he wondered what it would be like to stand behind the counter and offer soft-serve cups stuffed with candy. 

“I said, let’s just reach out and we started talking to Christopher and it trickled down to where we were the ones lucky enough to make this happen and purchase it and keep it running,” Mr. Beeson said. 

The couple, who live in Edgartown, were one of dozens who pitched Mr. Celeste on taking over the business. One of the only chain franchise eateries on the Island, Mr. Celeste has owned the Dairy Queen since 2017 and the company has Island roots going back to 1967.  

Mr. Celeste liked that Mr. Beeson and Ms. Anderson planned to be hands-on and continue the community-oriented storefront. 

“There was no shortage of people who thought they should run a Dairy Queen,” Mr. Celeste said. “Kirsten and Paul are incredibly talented, they’ve been on the Island for quite some time, they’ve run their own businesses.”

Christopher Celeste decided to sell the ice cream business last year.
Ray Ewing
Christopher Celeste decided to sell the ice cream business last year.
Ray Ewing

Mr. Beeson had just returned from two weeks of new franchise owner training in Lafayette, Colo. and he will handle the day-to-day running of the ice cream shop. Ms. Anderson will continue working as a tax attorney and handle the business’s behind-the-scenes ordering and financial work. 

They plan to largely keep things the same. The shop is staying put in the shingled building owned by the Rosenberg family, and the menu will keep supplying the Dairy Queen classics. 

“That’s our goal, to keep it running and further it and make the community happy,” Mr Beeson said. 

Mr. Beeson and Ms. Anderson are interested in extending Dairy Queen’s season, as well as broadening the hours. Ms. Anderson also hoped that it could help train the next generation. 

“I think a lot of kids, it’s their first job,” she said. “You get to be part of that process helping kids understand what it is like to work.” 

The couple is aware of the rumblings around town about when the shop is going to open. Opening day in the past has been around the April school vacation week, causing people to wonder what was happening. 

Ms. Anderson and Mr. Beeson said they are working through the permitting and hope to be open by the first week of June. Mr. Celeste, who declined to say the sale price, planned to be on hand to help them learn the ropes. 

“We can’t thank Christopher enough for all his help getting us to where we are now and we’re almost there,” Mr. Beeson said. 

Comments

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 04/30/2024 - 07:14

Permalink

Nancy Amherst, NH

Have been going there my whole life - so glad it will be continuing - and PLEASE keep the cherry dip :)!!

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 04/30/2024 - 07:47

Permalink

Robbie OB

It goes to show you islanders have no problems with franchises here. What’s wrong with allowing a few more so we can have great treats from off island? At least the franchises won’t complain they can’t get the help to open, they find a way. Great news all around. Please extend the hours and stay open longer during the season. Hard to find fresh ice cream in the off season.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 04/30/2024 - 07:51

Permalink

rob the roofer new jersey

With an opportunity to visit Dairy Queen at any time here in New Jersey I don't have the same enthusiasm as some on the Island. I think your homemade Ice cream on Island is better.

rob the roofer new jersey

My comment of Dairy Queen never spoke of closing it or that I didn't like their ice cream because I do. My comment spoke of preferring a different Ice Cream that is sold on the Island. I hope the tradition of looking forward to the opening of the Dairy Queen continues I like it and appreciate it.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 04/30/2024 - 09:04

Permalink

Gerald Jones Edgartown

Paul and Kirsten....congrats big time...glad you all have done this...and a semi new career for you all...we'll be by for sure....Linda and Gerald

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 04/30/2024 - 11:45

Permalink

JJ Klingensmith Southwest Florida

My brother and I used to be first in line every year, we would get our pictures and names in the paper every year. One year we actually camped out in a tent to make sure we would be first. I hope that tradition continues!

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 04/30/2024 - 17:16

Permalink

Jim Edgartown

Great news! I was worried about this…. Last year they closed my favorite Mexican restaurant in Edgartown.
Best of luck! I think I have an Hawaiian blizzard in my near future!

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 04/30/2024 - 23:22

Permalink

Francie Shaw Berkeley CA/ Chilmark

I have been cut off from soft serve ever since I became lactose intolerant but I miss it so! Please get the Company to create a plant based option. There are plenty of good ice creams but not soft serve. There is a growing market.

JD North Andover MA

Congrats to the new owners! Can’t wait to visit in July. I agree with Francine, would be nice to have a dairy free option.
Francine- Ben & Bills in OB has a dairy free soft serve option, that my dairy free daughter enjoys every summer!

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 05/01/2024 - 10:54

Permalink

Charlie Caallahan So Boston/Edgartown

How about a McDonalds or a Burger King,so a family with kids can go out and not have to spend $100 for burgers and fries. The island now is like Revere beach,so a few more businesses aren't gonna hurt anything.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 05/03/2024 - 08:13

Permalink

Charlie Callahan So Boston edgartown

Actually, so Boston is for fun,the vineyard is for fishing and listening to people complain about anything and everything.ArArAr.Been here forty years and the complaining gets funnier every year.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 12/06/2024 - 13:27

Permalink

JAMES HARRISON HOUSTON

You MUST bring back butterscotch dip. Pluuueeeeeezeee!

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.