Carlos, Beth Focarelli, Luis and Sara Dingledy outside the regional high school last Wednesday.

Migrant Relief Action Was Islandwide Effort

The Island’s emergency infrastructure, established to deal with natural disasters and critical housing needs, was put to a different test last week when nearly 50 Venezuelan migrants arrived unexpectedly at Martha’s Vineyard Airport.

The Island’s emergency infrastructure, established to deal with natural disasters and critical housing needs, was put to a different test last week when nearly 50 Venezuelan migrants arrived unexpectedly at Martha’s Vineyard Airport.

Leaning on existing relationships and protocols, a web of Island networks and individuals mobilized to provide food, shelter and resources to the group, which included men, women and children.

“Our response was humanitarian to a crisis that was politically created,” State Rep. Dylan Fernandes told the Gazette in a phone call this week.

The Gazette interviewed many of those involved in the response effort to reconstruct exactly how it unfolded.

Nearly all deferred credit to their peers and people on the ground for everything from securing food and shelter to working with lawyers and government officials to determine the best course of action for the migrants.

“I was part of the effort, but it was a collaboration,” said Dukes County manager Martina Thornton. “It was not a single agency or person — and a lot of volunteers.”

County manager Martina Thornton (second from left) helps organize migrants.
Ray Ewing
County manager Martina Thornton (second from left) helps organize migrants.
Ray Ewing

Following a two-day stay at St. Andrew’s Church in Edgartown, the migrants were moved to Joint Base Cape Cod last Friday. There, they have received shelter, care and resources through state and nonprofit organizations. State officials told the Gazette this week that some have already begun to relocate themselves, staying with family and friends across the U.S.

“Two of the individuals to my understanding departed on Monday to rendezvous with family in the New York city region,” State Sen. Julian Cyr said in a phone call Thursday. “I would expect to see more individuals leaving the temporary emergency shelter in the coming days as they’re essentially figuring out their plans and rebuilding their lives.”

A large group of volunteers, public officials and community leaders gathered last Friday at St. Andrew’s church for an emotional goodbye, sharing photos, hugs and tears as the migrants departed for Cape Cod. In the aftermath of the migrants’ stay on Martha’s Vineyard, many volunteers and public officials who were key to the local response were quick to say it was an Island-wide effort.

“It took quite a lot of logistical work,” said Oak Bluffs fire chief Nelson Wirtz, who also serves as chairman of Dukes County Emergency Services. “But I don’t think that any of us could have pulled it off without the rest of us.”

The group of migrants arrived on the Island via two planes sent by Gov. Ron DeSantis. Originating in San Antonio, Tex., both planes stopped in Crestview, Fla. en route to the Vineyard. One made an additional stop in South Carolina and the other in North Carolina, according to flight plans available online.

Spanish teacher Erin Slossberg and superintendent of schools Richie Smith.
Ray Ewing
Spanish teacher Erin Slossberg and superintendent of schools Richie Smith.
Ray Ewing

In a phone call to the Gazette this week, Martha’s Vineyard airport director Geoffrey Freeman said when the migrants arrived he treated it like any other landing. The group disembarked from the planes, and were immediately shuttled in pre-organized vans to Martha’s Vineyard Community Services, he said.

“We’re not here to socially profile or vet,” Mr. Freeman said. “I was not notified until they arrived at Martha’s Vineyard Community Services that there was an issue.”

At Martha’s Vineyard Community Services, executive director Beth Folcarelli was among the first to respond.

“I went outside to say hello and assess the situation, and I discovered that there were no English speakers,” Ms. Folcarelli said.

She immediately began putting calls out to organizations and individuals she thought could help, and word of the situation quickly spread. Calls went out to Chief Wirtz, Dukes County manager Martina Thornton, county sheriff Bob Ogden and Martha’s Vineyard Regional High School principal Sarah Dingledy, among many others.

The migrants were transported to the high school for a brief period, where Ms. Dingledy opened the cafeteria for food and shelter. Faculty and students served as translators as officials considered next steps.

“We had been told they hadn’t eaten since 6 a.m.,” Chief Wirtz said.

With the help of Janet Constantino, an employee of community services who volunteers for the Island’s homeless shelter, a decision was made to move the migrants to St. Andrew’s Church, where a homeless shelter is operated during the winter.

Sheriff Bob Ogden on the scene.
Ray Ewing
Sheriff Bob Ogden on the scene.
Ray Ewing

Chief Wirtz said the Oak Bluffs school is usually the hub for emergencies such hurricanes and other natural disasters, but it wasn’t properly equipped to handle this situation — especially not during the school year.

Resources were diverted to St. Andrew’s, where the migrants arrived by school bus and stayed for two nights before leaving for Cape Cod.

Father Chip Seadale, minister at the church, said he was attending a clergy conference in North Carolina when he got the call from Ms. Constantino.

“She needed to find a place for people to stay that night,” he said.

He said the church had already been volunteered for the task and he immediately agreed. With no access to television at the conference, Mr. Seadale said he followed the situation through phone calls and news alerts.

“I was doing interviews on the plane,” he said. “It was this big thing, but I couldn’t watch it on TV.”

Over the next two days, Islanders brought food, money, supplies, clothes, toys and games to the church. Before heading to the ferry last Friday, several of the migrants with emergency dental problems were treated by Island dentists.

Edgartown police chief Bruce McNamee helps migrants board VTA buses to the ferry.
Edgartown police chief Bruce McNamee helps migrants board VTA buses to the ferry.

Fundraising efforts for the migrants began through GoFundMe pages and direct donations. A donation fund set up by Martha’s Vineyard Community Services raised $269,000, and the Martha’s Vineyard Community Foundation received tens of thousands of dollars.

“Contributions flowed to numerous different organizations here,” said community foundation executive director Emily Bramhall.

Both community services and the community foundation are considering options for using the funds raised. Ms. Bramhall said broad immigration efforts as well as rental assistance for the migrants are all on the table.

Mr. Fernandes said the state is also considering disbursing federal money to the Vineyard to recoup costs spent during the effort.

“We have a set pot of money that we’ve already had in the budget … for refugee-related expenses,” he said.

Beyond financial contributions, many on the Island donated their time at St. Andrew’s. Setting up beds, cooking food and playing games, some developed personal relationships with the migrants during their brief stay.

“I stayed there, I didn’t leave,” said Harbor Homes shelter manager Lisa Belcastro.

Ms. Belcastro was instrumental in handling the situation at St. Andrew’s. Staying awake for two nights, she aided migrants and listened to the stories, many filled with tragedy, of their journeys to the United States.

Migrants are now at Joint Base Cape Cod preparing for next stage in their journey.
Ray Ewing
Migrants are now at Joint Base Cape Cod preparing for next stage in their journey.
Ray Ewing

“It was easy to stay awake because I didn’t want to miss a moment,” she said.

Chief Wirtz said the shelter at St. Andrew’s was always intended to be temporary, but provided much-needed resources like beds, plumbing and a shower.

“We knew we were going to need resources beyond what the Island could provide,” he said.

Chief Wirtz began working with Sheriff Ogden to coordinate with the state government. Chief Wirtz said he contacted the Massachusetts Emergency Management Agency (MEMA) almost immediately after the migrants arrived.

It was through MEMA that the migrants were transported to Joint Base Cape Cod, where many are still sheltering. There, they have received medical assistance and have been given opportunities to take buses into town to explore the Cape.

“Everyone is settled in at the facility and everyone I have talked to is very comfortable,” Mr. Fernandes said. “They are in really good shape.”

In the days since the migrants’ departure from the Vineyard, many involved in the response have received negative phone calls, emails and messages on social media. This week, a plane dragging a banner that read “Vineyard Hypocrites” circled the Island.

“The negative comments are coming from people who don’t have any knowledge of what the situation was on the ground,” Chief Wirtz said. “My job … is to take care of the people that are in front of me.”

Going forward, the state will continue to provide resources for the migrants and help them move on to more permanent housing situations. Legal assistance has been offered by several lawyers, and a class action lawsuit was filed against Governor DeSantis this week by a Boston civil rights firm.

The migrants are free to leave the Joint Base whenever they please, state officials told the Gazette. Some have already headed to New York, and some have plans to connect with resources in places across the country. For others, a new home could emerge in a region the migrants never intended to visit.

“My office has received several offers from folks on Martha’s Vineyard for people who have offered housing on-Island,” Mr. Fernandes said.

Thomas Humphrey and Brooke Kushwaha contributed reporting.

Comments

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 09/22/2022 - 18:18

Permalink

Rational Person Oak Bluffs

It's shameful how islanders are patting themselves on the back for helping people we know nothing about break our laws. I'm sure they could be nice people but how would we know without a proper vetting of their background before they entered our society. I don't understand why all those who stepped up to take care of them, and then promptly remove them from the island, didn't stand up and take them into their homes and care for them until they got on their feet. If they were such wonderful people why didn't these do gooders who are falling over themselves with self praise take them in? There's plenty of work here and they could have steered them to the abundance of services the island offers. Is it because they were afraid? Or perhaps weren't comfortable with any more brown skinned people on the island? That's my bet. Hypocrites.

Donna Edgartown

Did you help at all ? You could have in so many ways. listing all your scaredy cat excuses for not helping one iota, doesn’t count and isn’t fooling anyone but you.

MDW Edgartown

Although I am not accusing the writer of plagiarism, this comment is remarkably similar to others like it I have read elsewhere. It is beyond sad. Rather, it is misinformed and disrespectfully dismissive of all the good that was done.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 09/23/2022 - 06:13

Permalink

Eric Tisbury

Reading this article today written by Aidan Pollard, Migrant Relief Action Was Islandwide Effort, in the Martha’s Vineyard Gazette a quote at the end of a this most positive reporting about the refugee crisis that touched on our island made me stop and reread. The quote as follows; “My office has received several offers from folks on Martha’s Vineyard for people who have offered housing on-Island,” Mr. Fernandes said. My surprise is in the fact there are homeless and under housed people we see every day here on island that work in service industries. Why is it easier to offer help to others in the remote that are surely deserving of our help but to ignore or is it better said to overlook the problem staring us in the face every day. The old saying about charity starting at home is lost in America these days, it is far easier to send a check or better yet a pledge on your credit card than lend a human hand to another human in need. I have no doubt that some people are sincere in their desire to help house some of the refuges that landed on our island out of the literal blue. My question, is their gratis towards the refugees any more meaningful than if it was to their unhoused fellow citizens who lives within their own town?

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 09/23/2022 - 08:26

Permalink

Christine OB

I believe the response from the island and the state gets an A+. I have never been prouder to be an islander. The negative responses in the comments sections of regional & national newspapers & on social media were remarkably similar. For example, the same comments were found both in the Boston Globe and The Washington Post. This tells me that the negativity campaign was organized, and part of the plan by DeSantis and his allies.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 09/23/2022 - 09:06

Permalink

Kathy Beauchemin Scruggs Now Florida Native Vineyarder

I have never been so proud of my fellow Islanders as I have been in this last week. What DeSantis did was truly inhumane and only politically motivated. You guys reacted so beautifully. Thank you!
The threats received on the Island was probably due to a Fox reporter who condemned MV calling it a place for only rich white people. He went on to condemn Islanders without knowing who he was talking about. He said there was no diversity on the Island. Well we know that as a lie. But so many followers of Fox News don't know the Island and believe every lie he was telling them. Then they do and say stupid things. Hold your head up high Martha's Vineyard you are the best!

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 09/23/2022 - 09:15

Permalink

Robert Skydell Essaouira, Morocco

I am so moved by this story and send my best wishes to members of my former community.
But it is an understatement to say that it saddens me that so much of the comments and memes that have appeared online are filled with such derogatory, foul and even racist tropes directed at the Island and the people who make up the community. These comments flow freely from individuals who voraciously consume the right-wing propaganda that is spewed daily by certain agenda-driven media platforms that insist on perpetuating the image of rich, liberal nimbys kicking the migrants off their precious Island. I found this story, and the public approval of the DeSantis political stunt online, a sort of microcosm of the deep division in the country we find ourselves in the very midst of.
How I wish they had the inclination instead to read stories like this one, and maybe let go of their hatred and ignorance for a change.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 09/23/2022 - 14:48

Permalink

Richard Walker Waltham

As a long time summer resident for over 70 yrs, I am moved to say how wonderfully proud I am of the response by the Marthas Vineyard community to the plight of these immigrants. It's a testament to the humanity, grace and generosity of the Islands residents!

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sat, 09/24/2022 - 06:13

Permalink

Islander61 OB

Might I suggest people read the story or see the play “Come from Away”. A story about how a small town in Newfoundland came together to host 4000 travelers who had an emergency landing at their airport on 9/11 and had to stay 5 days. It’s an amazing play written by one of the passengers on one of the planes. Very similar to this event and guess what, no one questioned their motives or actions. See the play, you’ll be thankful you did.

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.