View of new tower across the west dock in Menemsha.
Albert O. Fischer 3rd

Security Cameras at Menemsha on Hold After Residents Object

Chilmark will press pause on installing security cameras in Menemsha after a group of residents registered their formal objection to a 30-foot pole that went up on the west dock to hold the cameras.

Chilmark will press pause on installing security cameras in Menemsha after a group of residents registered their formal objection to a 30-foot pole that went up on the west dock to hold the cameras.

Voters approved $20,000 for the cameras at the 2021 annual town meeting; another roughly $10,000 wil go toward the project from the harbor master budget. A cement pedestal and pole to hold the cameras were recently installed on the dock, but the cameras are not live yet.

The cameras are meant to deter theft and vandalism at the harbor, which harbor master Ryan Rossi said has become an increasing problem in recent years.

But in a letter to the select board this week, 28 Chilmark voters raised objections about the pole and said it merited another look.

Set in concrete and rising 30 feet, the tower is meant to house security cameras within eye-shot of the harbor master shack.
Albert O. Fischer
Set in concrete and rising 30 feet, the tower is meant to house security cameras within eye-shot of the harbor master shack.
Albert O. Fischer

“We are requesting a reconsideration of what may have been a mistake and should be considered further.” the letter said. “We would ask you to please have the pedestal and tower removed from the middle of historic Menemsha harbor and consider something more in keeping with the character of Menemsha for the camera.”

At the request of the 28 petitioners, the letter was read into the record of the meeting.

Mr. Rossi, who attended the meeting, said there had been multiple instances of theft from commercial lobstermen since the pandemic started. Fishing gear has been stolen, batteries have been taken and fuel has been siphoned off private boats, he said.

“This isn’t something that I want to have to put in place, but I’ve come to the point where I no longer have answers for the multiple instances where people come to me and tell me that something has been stolen or something has been vandalized,” the harbor master said.

He said the mast and pole were installed to ensure an unobscured line of sight from the harbor master shack to the dock, so an antenna establishing a radio signal could be installed on the shack. The pole is 30 feet high so the three cameras can cover the entire area, Mr. Rossi said.

Matt Poole, one of the petitioners who attended the meeting, said there will need to be fencing around the pole to discourage climbing on it, which would make it even more of an eyesore.

“We haven’t even seen the entire sort of visual impact,” Mr. Poole said. “The cameras, I think, are probably necessary but I really, really think that there are other alternatives. I encourage the selectmen to just back away and do something more in keeping with Menemsha.”

The select board decided to halt further installation until after a meeting can be held with Mr. Rossi, selectman Warren Doty, the harbor advisory committee, the parks and recreation committee and concerned members of the public to figure out the best course of action.

“We’ve heard that the situation as it stands is really not acceptable,” Mr. Doty said.

Also Tuesday, the select board recognized town clerk Jennifer Christy for becoming a certified municipal clerk after completing a lengthy set of classes.

Board member James Malkin commended Ms. Christy.

“You are far and away the best that I know of in this position and it’s just terrific, congratulations,” he said.

Ms. Christy thanked the select board for the recognition.

“The certification process was actually really fun and it took a number of years to do,” Ms. Christy said. “But thank you very much.”

The board also authorized $1,000 for an application for a state grant as part of the town’s renewable energy plan.

Suellen Lazarus introduced herself as the new chairman of the Chilmark town affairs council. Summer programming for children will start July 4 and run through August 19 at the Chilmark Community Center, Ms. Lazarus said.

Comments

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 03/16/2022 - 22:08

Permalink

Linda Calabrese Tolland CT and Oak Bluffs

Beyond approving the funds I imagine there should have been a hearing during which time the design of the tower, including the height, would have been discussed and voted on. Beyond that, this might be considered akin to the modern day lighthouse, albeit less pretty.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 03/16/2022 - 22:36

Permalink

Thomas Edgartown

This is beyond ridiculous. With the technology today to have a 30 foot tower is just plain ignorant. I have nest cameras at a few properties that I own and I can see everything!!
This is so easily solvable with a camera that no one can see.

Peter Edgartown

A someone who was in the digital security camera business, be very wary of the claims like "12 security cameras with starlight night vision" I have seen in comments. Those system's "night vision" is actually short range IR LEDs (12 ft), not capable of lighting a scene at a distance across the harbor. And the "color night vision" is generally just white LEDs that have the same range problems (not to mention flashing off and on in their detector range all night). Finally, to store full motion video from 12 cameras in one on-site box means that the video will be so compressed and blurry that you will never get an ID of the suspect let alone a conviction. Extending a cell phone network to the harbor and then using distributed cell or wifi cameras is the only way to go. Stream the videos uncompressed to the Cloud and you will end up with video that you can actually use.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 03/16/2022 - 23:56

Permalink

Tom Engley West Tisbury

I think it was an honest mistake simple solution is take it down and do something else.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 03/17/2022 - 02:30

Permalink

George Stein Oak Bluffs

Voters approved $20 K for law enforcement enhancement in an area of volume criminal activity. I see no mention of a court injunction to stop this . So many games, quite sad.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 03/17/2022 - 05:18

Permalink

Susan Edgartown

Didn't anyone notice anything was happening when the concrete base was going in, when the trucks were there starting to erect the tower? There are always people around Menemsha to notice these things who could have stopped this!!!

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 03/17/2022 - 05:28

Permalink

Carol formerly Chilmark

I'm puzzled - security cameras that spool to the cloud are so inexpensive now, why not just buy 8 or 9 of them and put them on the buildings (eaves), as millions of homeowners do now? Why put up a new pole?

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 03/17/2022 - 06:36

Permalink

michael chilmark

Drones

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 03/17/2022 - 09:03

Permalink

Charlie Callahan So Boston/Edgartown

Too bad a lot of commentors have nothing better to do than complain about anything. I have nothing better to do, but I think this is a good idee,if it catches some lowlifes committing a crime or attacking someone

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 03/17/2022 - 19:57

Permalink

David Chilmark

Menemsha has terrible cell service. My suggestion is to change it to a wooden pole and run the distributed cellphone system that is on poles all along up-island to the pole. A wooden pole would fit better and the the improved cell service would pay for it all. Getting the cameras would be a bonus and free.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 03/17/2022 - 22:57

Permalink

Jeff Chilmark

The town voted to spend $20,000 at the annual meeting for the cameras-lets not squander the money -let it play out-i drove over today-the utility pole next to the gas station is more of an eyesore-we tend to approve what we call small projects, 20-30k without a blink of an eye without reading the language or looking at the plans. Thant's a lot of dough-Let's not waste it.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sat, 03/19/2022 - 02:02

Permalink

Rich Vineyard Haven

Clearly, a mistake. Take it down and forget about it. Not worth fussing over.

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.