Draft proposal would use funds from a two per cent real estate transfer fee to develop more affordable housing.
Ray Ewing

Draft Housing Bank Article Begins Circulating

<p>A draft warrant article to create a Martha&rsquo;s Vineyard housing bank is now being circulated in the six Island towns for possible inclusion at annual town meetings next spring.</p>

A draft warrant article to create a Martha’s Vineyard housing bank is now being circulated in the six Island towns for possible inclusion at annual town meetings next spring.

The article has been drafted by the coalition that formed earlier this year to promote the housing bank. If it wins approval at town meetings, the housing bank would next go to the state legislature. Modeled somewhat loosely on the Martha’s Vineyard Land Bank, the housing bank as currently proposed would collect a buyer-paid two per cent transfer fee on real estate transactions that fall above a certain threshold. The money would be distributed in the form of grants for affordable housing projects on the Island. An elected Islandwide commission would control the funds.

The article is lengthy and its language is still subject to change, as each town begins to review the details. As currently written, the measure would require approval by four of the six Island towns to pass.

At a meeting last week the Chilmark selectmen agreed to put the article on their annual town meeting warrant, offering generally positive comments although there were some questions, including the about the role of the housing bank commission in buying and selling properties, how and if commissioners would be paid, and potential conflicts of interest.

“I think this structure, as it’s presented today, it’s really very good. This is a structure which has worked very well for the land bank, we’re all very familiar with it,” selectman Warren Doty told spokesmen for the coalition who attended the meeting. “I think you’ve done a good job of putting this together.”

Selectman Bill Rossi agreed.

“I think it’s very clear what you’re trying to do,” he said. “I’m hoping that it [passes] in the spring.”

Chilmark resident Wendy Wolf said the housing bank, while a good idea, does not solve the immediacy of the Island’s affordable housing crisis. As an added measure, she suggested a portion of the money collected from the short-term rental tax go to the Molly Flender Fund, the town’s affordable housing trust.

But Mr. Rossi said the Molly Flender Fund is not strapped for cash, with $700,000 added to it this year alone. He said the problem is a lack of proposals.

“We have a lot of money sitting, waiting for a project,” Mr. Rossi said. “Quite frankly, it’s a little frustrating.”

The select board is expecting a proposal soon from the planning board for Peaked Hill Pastures, a roughly 17 acre-parcel of town-owned land that has been designated for affordable housing. A series of community engagement sessions were held over the summer and this fall; a proposal is expected by some time in December.

“Once we receive that and review that, it’ll give us a better sense of where we’re going in terms of that particular site, and what could be a significant number of building opportunities there,” selectman James Malkin said. He added:

“Should we, at that point, need to factor in some additional funding, I think that would roll into the conversation that you brought up, Wendy.”

Meanwhile, in Edgartown on Monday, members of the select board took no vote on the draft article, saying they would wait until it is reviewed by town counsel Ronald Rappaport before making a decision.

“We won’t have much to say until we hear Ron’s opinion,” selectman Michael Donaroma said.

The board tentatively scheduled a followup discussion for Dec. 6.

On Wednesday, West Tisbury select board members Skipper Manter and Cynthia Mitchell followed suit, moving to postpone consideration of the article until after the Edgartown board has heard town counsel Ron Rappaport’s legal opinion.

“I would feel much more comfortable pushing this off another week so we have the benefit of his analysis,” Ms. Mitchell said, noting that Mr. Rappaport is also town counsel for West Tisbury.

One day earlier, the Aquinnah select board voted to put the draft article on the annual town meeting warrant in that town.

The Oak Bluffs select board takes up the draft article at a meeting on Dec. 14, while the Tisbury select board will review the draft article on Dec. 15.

Comments

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Mon, 11/29/2021 - 20:36

Permalink

Mike Somewhere

I hope this does not go forward. The state should fund and provide grants for affordable housing. Subsidizing it by realestate sales is the wrong way to go.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Mon, 11/29/2021 - 22:44

Permalink

Mark Edgartown

Penalizing property owners with a new tax is not a viable or equitable solution.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 11/30/2021 - 22:41

Permalink

Ken Edg.

It seems more housing means more people which means more housing. Im ok with renovating existing properties but please no more projects.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 12/01/2021 - 07:35

Permalink

RC DC

So, on the one hand we have a land bank that is buying and preserving land - sometimes at the cost of an existing house. On the other hand, we will now have a housing bank that will be buying land and creating houses. Much like a previous comment; renovating is good, new projects not so much. Either way, most housing transactions will be feeding both banks.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 12/01/2021 - 07:45

Permalink

Charlie Callahan So Boston/Edgartown

The comments on this subject show the true nature of most of the people here.And these comments show how most people here are against it no matter what is proposed. I grew up in a dump in southie,but one thing was that if you were poor you could get help getting housing. Here for every decent person who wants to see people get a place,there are 50 who find some excuse to be against it. I have a house so I'm not looking for anything,but I know teachers,cops and firemen who can barely afford to live here on what they make

Bob Edgartown

Please stop with the teachers & cops not being able to live here this group is some of the best paid year round jobs on the island. And we have no paid fireman except the chiefs who can afford to live here as the pay is over $100K a year. The fireman on the Island are mostly volunteer but that will change as time and regulation will demand it. Wait until we have to have full time paid fireman and see what that does to your budget.

mike Somewhere

No one is against affordable housing. Just how its paid for. The state, county and towns need to establish a program that creates affordable housing for low wage/income families in appropriate areas. Not on large tracts of land out in the woods. Why should people who worked hard to get what they have, have to subsidize low income workers. That's the states job. That's what we pay taxes for.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 12/01/2021 - 09:12

Permalink

Lorraine Edgartown

There is an old fable which it just occurred to me fits this bit. Stop killing the goose that lays the golden eggs. Taxation without representation. Oh, it won't be named a tax, it will be a "fee" of some type. Just because I do not want housing fees to be attached to existing property transactions, etc., does not mean I am against housing for people. It is actually not "affordable housing" there is no affordable housing on the island. It is so easy to pass financing of programs on sitting ducks, sitting ducks cannot move and we know what happens then to the ducks.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 12/01/2021 - 16:56

Permalink

gina Menemsha / NYC

In all due resect to Mr. Abrams. I don't think he's an appropriate representative for the Housing Bank agenda.. He is a well known builder who may have a personal gain in the Housing Bank.. Just saying. ..

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.