The Edgartown post office needs to be "gutted," town administrator Pamela Dolby said Thursday.
Sara Brown

Edgartown Post Office Will Temporarily Relocate to Old Library

The Edgartown post office will temporarily relocate to the former town library on North Water street in the next few weeks as town officials, the postal service and the building owner work to assess water damage that has left the post office closed since last Friday.

The Edgartown post office will temporarily relocate to the former town library on North Water street in the next few weeks as town officials, the postal service and the building owner work to assess water damage that has left the post office closed since last Friday.

Greater Boston postal district manager Mike Powers made the decision to move to the recently-vacated library Thursday after assessing a temporary setup in Vineyard Haven and the damage to the post office stemming from a half-finished construction project. He called the damage to the building extensive.

“I was very disappointed with what I saw, to be honest with you,” Mr. Powers told the Gazette. “It was a total gut of the building. When you have the ceiling, the walls, the insulation being ripped out of the lobby, I think that speaks for itself.” He said there will be further assessment in the coming days as to structural integrity of the building, which will help to determine what needs to be done to reopen the post office.

The new location is the latest development in a week of scrambling and tension after the closure of the town’s main post office, where more than 3,000 postal customers get their mail at post office boxes. The postal service delivers to just more than 1,100 addresses in Edgartown on two rural delivery routes, a postal service spokesman said. Many residents and businesses rely on postal boxes to receive mail.

Customers had been rerouted to Vineyard Haven Post Office.
Kathy Agin
Customers had been rerouted to Vineyard Haven Post Office.
Kathy Agin

A construction project has been underway to build five apartments on the second floor of the building that houses the post office and a Martha’s Vineyard Savings Bank branch. The savings bank is also closed due to water damage.

The building is owned by Charles Hajjar, a Milton real estate developer who is a summer resident of Oak Bluffs. Mr. Hajjar has a number of real estate investment interests on the Vineyard, including at the Triangle.

The post office and bank are tenants in the building there. The post office was briefly closed twice in March because of rain leaks. The problem intensified late last week with heavy rainfall. Edgartown building inspector Leonard Jason Jr. said that he and the town wiring inspector visited the post office last Friday to find the ceiling saturated and parts coming down. “I advised the powers that be, the [post office] regional supervisor . . . I told him if it was me I would close the building.” He continued:

“It’s a situation you usually try to avoid. Left wide open to the weather, things don’t do well.”

The postal service announced operations would temporarily shift to the Vineyard Haven Post Office. Expanded retail hours were announced for Edgartown residents at the Vineyard Haven and Woods Hole post offices; postal service spokesmen later revised the statement to replace Woods Hole with Oak Bluffs.

If you remove the roof, rainwater will come in.
Sara Brown
If you remove the roof, rainwater will come in.
Sara Brown

Edgartown box holders were able to retrieve their mail at a dedicated space in the lobby of the post office. Early in the week some mail remained in post office boxes in Edgartown as employees worked to shift all the mail from one location to the other.

A postal service spokesman said he was not aware of any mail being damaged in the process or by water leaks.

At the selectmen’s meeting Monday, the problems were the main topic of discussion, with reports of parking issues, long lines and postal workers scrambling to find mail in makeshift boxes labeled with box numbers. The town accountant, Kimberly Kane, noted important documents go through the mail this time of year, including absentee ballots and tax and sewer bills.

Relocating to the former library was the best option for the post office, Mr. Powers said later in the week.

“I think that’s a desirable choice at this point given the crazy situation that’s occurring relative to the Edgartown post office,” he said. “Vineyard Haven is not desirable from my standpoint and certainly not from a customer standpoint.

“Our next step is to put together a plan to make that happen.”

The former Edgartown library, also known as the Carnegie library, was recently vacated as the library moved to a new location. The Martha’s Vineyard Preservation Trust is the new owner of the building. “We certainly recognize that this is a real emergency for this community,” preservation trust executive director Chris Scott told the Gazette Thursday. “The trust wants to be as helpful as we can be.”

Post Office was closed twice in March; problems intensified in April
Sara Brown
Post Office was closed twice in March; problems intensified in April
Sara Brown

He said it is his understanding that the temporary arrangement will be until June at the latest.

“I don’t believe that anything permanent is going to be installed in the Carnegie,” Mr. Scott said. “I don’t think it needs to be. There are lots of shelves . . . . they can sort mail by fiction or nonfiction.”

Mr. Powers said mail that had been taken from Edgartown to Vineyard Haven will now be sent back to Edgartown. There will be staging and storage work to make sure customers can efficiently get their mail, he said.

“Our main focus right now is just to get a better situation for mail pickup in Edgartown,” he said. “We’re establishing the best situation we can out of this.” He praised the efforts of the town and postal employees.

“We have dedicated employees who go above and beyond and we appreciate all their efforts. Our sole focus is to take care of our customers,” Mr. Powers said.

Town administrator Pamela Dolby and other town officials have been working throughout the week to resolve the situation. On Thursday morning a meeting was held at the post office with the Mr. Hajjar, the building owner, and town officials, including health agent Matt Poole. Mr. Poole said the board of health will be involved in assessing the long-term risk to the future occupants, primarily related to mold.

Speaking to the Gazette by telephone Thursday for a second time this week, Mr. Hajjar said crews are working furiously to address the situation. The contractor hired to do the construction, Gene Erez of Dukes County Builders, has two extra crews on hand, he said. “We hope to have the building water tight sometime late in the weekend,” he said.

Earlier in the week as the crisis unfolded, in a conversation with the Gazette Mr. Hajjar lamented the bad stretch of weather.

“It’s just been poor timing with all the precipitation,” he said. “Who would ever think we’d get this much rain and wind in April.” He said at the time there was no significant damage to the building, but that information has since been refuted by town officials and postal service authorities.

Meanwhile, Mr. Hajjar publicly apologized, over the phone and in a letter to the editor that appears in today’s edition.

“We’re really doing whatever we can do to get the post office back open and we hope it’s going to be sooner rather than later,” he said. “We’re just sick about what’s happened.”

Steve Myrick contributed reporting.

Comments

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 04/07/2016 - 15:47

Permalink

annoyed Edgartown

Wonderful choice - plenty of parking there and downtown Edgartown in the summer never has traffic issues!! Especially right near the Chappy ferry line... Is the "postal service district manager" they same one who suggested we go to Wood Hole PO to buy stamps!!

Sara Piazza Edgartown

If you think in terms of parking on the outskirts and walking the rest of the way, say, at the Edgartown School or at the Triangle, parking is not an issue. It's what I do all summer with all the other towns, and it's not so bad. It just takes a little extra planning. But yes, this will be a huge adjustment.

Sara Piazza Edgartown

Yes, this is all terribly inconvenient, on many levels. Driving to Vineyard Haven - for some people, every day - plus dealing with traffic and parking and long lines there is beyond inconvenient, especially in terms of financial and medical issues. My reply was directed at the original comment regarding parking; offering a solution that works in a normal situation. We will have to support the handicapped somehow - maybe add a couple of extra handicapped spaces. If there are medical issues, maybe there are people who could step up to the plate and go to the mail. Let me be the first to offer, or maybe the Meals on Wheels can pitch in since they are less than a block away. As for kids and errands, it's tough, but maybe make an adventure out of it. Put the carriage in the car and walk part of the way - you'll probably get there before the cars do. Or park at the Triangle and take the VTA bus the rest of the way. This is inconvenient for everyone - I haven't gotten my mail since last week. I was just trying to offer a constructive solution. Anyway, June 1 will be here before we know it.

Ella Edgartown

The Hajjars own the Victorian Inn and possibly the building that houses L'Etoile. Surely they will dedicate their convenient parking spaces for postal patrons?

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 04/07/2016 - 16:58

Permalink

Lou Edgartown

A development for which we should thank Pam Dolby. We might have to walk a bit, but at least its better than VH Five Corners. If they put temporary post boxes in too the lines will disappear. July and August will be hard, but otherwise a vast improvement.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 04/07/2016 - 17:01

Permalink

Carla Cooper

Relocating in the next few weeks? Why on earth should it take that long to rebuild the existing post office? A crew should be working around the clock to reopen the post office and it shouldn't take weeks. I've seen entire houses gutted and remodeled in less time.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 04/07/2016 - 17:35

Permalink

Sara Piazza Edgartown

In the meantime, I need to try and get my mail in VH, hopefully either first thing tomorrow morning or on Saturday. Anybody know what the hours of operation are?

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 04/07/2016 - 17:56

Permalink

deshandra brown mv

Thanks Pam for your efforts. I'd expect the owner of the PO building should be forced to abandon work on the expansion (once the building is weather-tight) and get the PO done ASAP. Work the crews 24 hours in shifts. It could be done in a week. Even on 'island time'.

Submitted by stminton (not verified) on Thu, 04/07/2016 - 18:40

Permalink

Sarah Edgartown

Pam, Your Grace under pressure! What a Herculean feat to make this happen in 4 Business days!

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 04/07/2016 - 19:36

Permalink

Janet Anthony Edgartown

Sara I walked in today @ 430 took less than 10 minutes!!! No problem getting a parking space!!!

Submitted by stminton (not verified) on Thu, 04/07/2016 - 20:16

Permalink

Sarah Edgartown

Anyone- NOT signed up for Edgartown updates Via text- (join the Town of Edgartown site,) as of 3:25pm 4/7 Text: Edg Post Office moving to old Edg Library location on N Water St until repairs complete. Expected move date within 2 weeks. (and if sooner you'll be notified Via Text)
EXPECTED move date within 2 weeks... Go lend a hand, help with a bad situation which affects all, be involved, find a way to help.
Show with spirit, offer a set of hands... on and on and on.
Lip service doesn't get things done.
Effect Change!
Take this opportunity to offer a neighbor/elderly/friend a ride to the Vineyard Haven Post Office- INTERIM to ride along, you may just learn something you don't know. They could be awaiting medication, check/refund/tax, a birthday card, a connection most meaningful from a loved one, you may make a friend!
Practice Kindness and know this is not the norm, change is constant, and without our local government we would not have an answer as quickly without them.
US postal srv doesn't own the building! Our Town Cares! (4 business days - Over rainy weekend- WITH AN ANSWER? Really....)
Seriously, being as proactive as they have been-listening to all, we wouldn't (today) have a reliable answer, with a proposed end result in sight. AND they have a proposed return to the "Other" location", Sign UP for the text's with ET on Town of Edgartown website. It's informative, and extremely immediate.
from Chappy ferry suspended, school closings, Bch rd wash outs, and rds closed due to incidents- It's information ON YOUR PHONE, immediate and necessary. In this day and age, you need to know what is Immediately necessary! The Island is not insular anymore.
Seriously folks! no one IS NOT affected, trickle down...
Lend a hand, help, thank YOUR officials, and at the very least BE KIND!

Sarah Edgartown

OH... and I forgot- "APRIL SHOWERS Bring MAY FLOWERS!"

Someone, Please, Send PAM Dolby Lots of FLOWERS!
Immense efforts, need recognition.

Sarah Edagartown

Lets come up with options, and lets all of us stay on track with this...

You can only hammer 1 nail at a time. It's Not a piano! 1 thing at a time.
If you want other changes,
GET INVOLVED, GO TO THE TOWN MEETINGS, EXPRESS YOUR CONCERNS, AND VOTE!

Resident Edgartown

FLOWERS?? Are you serious? Pam Dolby? Sara...you obviously dont know about the dark side of the Town Administrators office in beautiful downtown Edgartown!

Sarah Edgartown

I certainly am, and I differ that you have ever needed the TOWN to fix a huge problem, concerning your property, not putting your name... There's YOUR SIGN!!

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 04/07/2016 - 20:33

Permalink

Ken Edg.

Run a shuttle from the parking lot. Why cant they start moving immediately, forget protocol.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Thu, 04/07/2016 - 23:15

Permalink

christopher gray Chappaquonsett & Manhattan

Gosh, I am surprised that our pioneer ancestors made it past New Jersey.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 04/08/2016 - 07:31

Permalink

EL VH

I had to chuckle at the building owner when he said "who would ever think we'd get this much rain and wind in April' .... Lol! I guess he hasn't heard the old saying. Or lived here long.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 04/08/2016 - 09:22

Permalink

Rumor has it Edgartown

I can be patient but can we get a GUARANTEE that the PO will return to its old location at the triangle.. perhaps this is the developers "convenient" mistake to get the PO out of the building with no intention of having them return. I just think that Edgartown's latest real estate guru is playing his own game of monopoly to gather up as much property as he can, to do with whatever he pleases, since despite the opposition of the local residents seems to be applauded by a handful of town administrators and selectmen regardless of the consequences. Money talks - backs are being scratched...

molly Edgartown

Good Questions! Great observations! I do not understand how moving the post office to the Carnegie Library is a good solution. There is no parking. There is constant traffic due to the Chappy ferry. I don't for a minute believe the suggestion that this will all be resolved by June 1st. Especially if it will take a "few weeks" to get the current and past mail and packages to the Carnegie. Flowers for Pam??? They have got to be kidding! The postal workers are the ones who deserve the flowers!

Sara Piazza Edgartown

If this is a trick to get the PO back into town, how about we also get back everything else we've lost: the four grocery stores, two drug store/soda fountains, two liquor stores, two barber shops, a hardware store, two five and dimes, a shoe store, a home goods/toy store; along with the police station and fire station. Oh, and now the library.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 04/08/2016 - 09:46

Permalink

Melinda Loberg Vineyard Haven

Edgartown, we feel your pain! But, it's given us a great opportunity to mingle with our nice neighbors from the whaling town. We hope your situation gets resolved soon. Imagine having to brave 5 corners all summer!

Sara Piazza Edgartown

Exactly. What I've come to realize is (after I've stopped screaming, kicking my feet, and swearing, that is), these radical inconveniences and changes in routine pften turn out to be not so bad after all and bring a welcome change of perspective that I would not have sought out on my own. In this case, bringing out a community spirit; and who knows, maybe some will discover that they don't actually mind walking a few blocks and say to themselves, "Hey, I should walk around Edgartown more often; I've missed it."

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 04/08/2016 - 09:59

Permalink

BLLB EDG

Can't imagine why, but has anyone check to make SURE having the US Post Office at the library does not effect it status as a Carnegie Library?

Ken Edg.

Hasnt happened yet.The PO must approve. At least we put our best foot forward. We prbly be shuffling back and forth from VH for the next two months.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 04/08/2016 - 11:53

Permalink

Adelaide Kent New York

Anyone remember the old old Post Office on North Water Street? I remember a certain amount of disquiet after that move too. Of course that was in the old days...

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 04/08/2016 - 14:12

Permalink

C. Aiello [email protected]

Why not put a temporary trailer as the post office, in the town parking lot at the triangle (lot behind Edgartown Pizza)? Plenty of parking there. Easy access for elderly and a ramp could be put in for disabled.
When the Vineyard Haven Post Office was redone, everything worked fine with a temporary trailer next to the existing post office.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Fri, 04/08/2016 - 15:57

Permalink

DIW Edg.

The mobile trailer suggestion is a good one. Is that idea too simple for people to invision? The postal workers are/have done a great job! THANK YOU!!!

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.