A $9.8 project would remove munitions from 123-acre area between Tisbury Great Pond and Long Cove.
Mark Lovewell

Effort to Remove Munitions from Beaches Moves Forward

<p>The Army Corps of Engineers is moving forward with three projects totaling $18.5 million to remove practice bombs and other debris from former World War II bombing ranges on the Vineyard and reduce the risk of injury.</p>

The Army Corps of Engineers is moving forward with three projects to remove practice bombs and other debris from former World War II bombing ranges on the Vineyard, and to reduce the risk of injury through public education.

The three projects, at Tisbury Great Pond, South Beach and Cape Pogue, will cost a total of about $18.5 million, and are at various stages in planning. Funding for the $8.1 million Cape Pogue project was obtained last year, and fieldwork could begin as soon as late March. Work at Tisbury Great Pond is further out.

Project will remove practice bombs and debris from World War II era.
Mark Lovewell
Project will remove practice bombs and debris from World War II era.
Mark Lovewell

Feasibility studies for the Tisbury Great Pond and South Beach projects were completed last summer, after which the Army Corps held public hearings on the Island. The $9.8 million proposal for the great pond in West Tisbury drew the most concern, much of it focused on the high cost and plans to remediate sand dunes at the site.

The project will involve clearing all munitions and debris from a 123-acre area between the pond and Long Cove, including portions of the inland waters and ocean. In the meantime, the Army Corps planned to increase public awareness through signs, printed material and site-specific training for the community.

A survey of about 1,000 acres, beginning in 2009, identified six hazardous munitions and 31 pieces of non-hazardous debris at the West Tisbury site, which was active between around 1943 and 1947. The practice bombs often contained small black powder charges, along with plaster, water or sand, so pilots could see where they landed.

At South Beach, a survey of about 4,400 acres, mostly in the ocean, revealed 98 pieces of munitions debris. An earlier effort had unearthed two 100-pound practice bombs at Wasque Point, 617 pieces of debris and 99 inert rockets. The Army Corps is developing a $622,000 public education and monitoring program at the site.

Meanwhile, the Cape Pogue project will cover 234 acres, including Shear Pen Pond near the northern tip of Chappaquiddick, and a portion of Cape Pogue Bay. As with the great pond project, work will involve subsurface clearing on both the land and water.

South Beach project will focus on public education.
Timothy Johnson
South Beach project will focus on public education.
Timothy Johnson

Clearing all of the munitions at the West Tisbury site likely would mean removing sand from the dunes. That would also require working with state and local agencies to minimize the impacts on nesting shorebirds and the endangered northeastern beach tiger beetle. The Army Corps would reestablish the dunes and their native vegetation.

Project manager Carol Charette told the Gazette this week that environmental protection measures would include having biologists on call, coordinating with various agencies and working within certain timeframes. “Does that drive up the cost? Absolutely,” she said.

But the biggest costs will relate to working in the water.

“When you have to work in the open ocean, that drives up the cost,” Ms. Charette said. “You are dealing with weather conditions. Some days you can dive, some days you can’t dive. It’s more dangerous, it’s more time consuming as well.”

“Once you find something, you have to dig on it right away,” she added, “because chances are you aren’t going to find it again.”

A joint contract for long-term monitoring at all three sites could help save money, but other factors such as coordinating among the projects could cancel out the benefit. “A lot of the time it’s hard to predict if it’s going to be more or less,” Ms. Charette said.

Only the Cape Pogue project has been contracted, but Ms. Charette hoped to award contracts for the other projects in June. Detailed plans would then be developed over the next several months, with fieldwork at Tisbury Great Pond likely starting in 2017. Work might last from six months to a year, not including a final report.

Army Corps documents related to the Vineyard projects are available at nae.usace.army.mil and at the West Tisbury and Edgartown libraries.

Comments

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sat, 01/30/2016 - 10:30

Permalink

Richard J. O'Neil Naples, FL

You have got to be kidding! What a WASTE. Clean up the litter you can see first.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sat, 01/30/2016 - 18:39

Permalink

Native VH

I will second that Richard!! These people got their heads in the wrong place! You are lucky you moved South! .... (A very old Friend!)

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sat, 01/30/2016 - 22:14

Permalink

vineyarder Edgartown

I was about 8 years old when they were supposed to be using live ammo on south beach. Let me tell you we were never restricted from going to south beach during the war. I worked at what is now the farm institute.planes were shooting dud rockets at a moving target over our heads while we were weeding! The army searched for bombs 10 years ago. Then a group with divers and a compressor on the beach also got into the government pocket. There are no unexploded bombs there. The whole thing is a money making deal. If there were unexploded bombs there why is south beach over crouded in the summer?

Submitted by jaldeborgh (not verified) on Sun, 01/31/2016 - 01:35

Permalink

John Aldeborgh Edgartown, MA

I have to agree with the other commenters. The country is 20 trillion in debt and there is an acute shortage of affordable housing on the island, so the government chooses to spend $18.5M on this? How about spending this money on something more tangible to the local residents, or simply not spend the money.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sun, 01/31/2016 - 14:29

Permalink

Ken Edgartown

I agree with everyone here. The government and special interests wont listen. There needs to be a shakedown at the federal level.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Sun, 01/31/2016 - 14:29

Permalink

Dee Ouchman Isles of Langerhans

Last time a few weeks stretched into months of slackers getting Sun tans. And then there was the hoopla when a developer removed the man made target burm which somehow transformed it's self into a dune.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 02/02/2016 - 08:50

Permalink

Hal Edgartown

More Government waste - we need new leadership from the top down. someone who doesn't tout these spending programs without regard for taxpayer wallets.

after 18+ million, what is the guarantee that the munitions will be gone - 100% - 90% - ??%

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 02/02/2016 - 09:00

Permalink

David Tenenbaum Wisconsin/Aquinnah

Utter lunacy. You can't even begin to count how many things are wrong with this picture. Be better to just dump $100 bills in the ocean.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 02/02/2016 - 09:22

Permalink

John Alley West Tisbury

It seems to me to be a waste of money. It is true there was a target range, a wooden railroad and bunkers on the beach. Yes it was a target range but all that has washed out to sea long ago.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 02/02/2016 - 13:30

Permalink

Dee Ouchman Isles of Langerhans

I'd bet half the houses built before 1960 used the practice bombs for door stops.

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 02/02/2016 - 14:54

Permalink

gina Menemsha/nyc

One of the more outlandish Boondoggles even for the Army Corp. of Engineers..

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Wed, 02/03/2016 - 07:09

Permalink

Gemma West tisbury

I'm all for cleaning up the environment and protecting the native ecology but unless the amo is a true health concern, I question the aim of the project, no one's rushing to clean up Noman's and that was a much more active site. Wish I could land one of those government contracts...

Submitted by Anonymous (not verified) on Tue, 02/09/2016 - 16:55

Permalink

Charles Oak Bluffs

$18.5 million to damage our south beach coastal ecosystems? Federal bureaucracy at it's worst!

Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.
  • Web page addresses and email addresses turn into links automatically.